The 2002 Imperial Homes residence at 23771 Tuscany Way sits on an oversized 0.56-acre homesite inside The Colony Golf & Bay Club, with a private elevator, a gas fireplace and a reported 5,647 square feet. Its sale was one of five reported home sales across the Cape Coral, Florida metro area for the week of September 21 through September 27, 2026, which together accounted for $10.90 million.
The week’s closings were spread across Tuscany Isle, Boca Grande, Harbour Cottages, The Shores and Montelago, reaching Estero, Sanibel, Fort Myers and Miromar Lakes as well as Boca Grande itself. Each property sits in a named golf, beach or boating community, from The Colony Golf & Bay Club in Estero to Miromar Lakes Beach & Golf Club.
No. 1 — $2,750,000 · 23771 Tuscany Way, Estero, Florida
A custom Imperial Homes residence in Tuscany Isle, inside the gated Colony Golf & Bay Club community, changed hands for $2,750,000 to lead the metro’s reported sales. The September 21, 2026 closing covered a four-bedroom house built in 2002 at 23771 Tuscany Way in Estero, carrying a reported 5,647 square feet and a flat tile roof installed new in May 2026. The property previously changed hands for $2,450,000 in 2005.
Handcrafted double doors open to soaring ceilings, floor-to-ceiling windows and barrel-vaulted ceilings with accent lighting, and marble flooring and a gas fireplace run through the main level. The kitchen is fitted with a Dacor gas range, a Sub-Zero refrigerator, a center island and a walk-in pantry, and the entertaining rooms include a butler’s pantry and a wet bar with custom cabinetry, wine storage and a beverage refrigerator. A private elevator reaches a second level holding additional en-suite bedrooms, a family room loft with its own wet bar, and private balconies. The primary suite has a sitting area with direct access to the pool and spa, dual custom walk-in closets and a bathroom with a Jacuzzi tub, dual vanities and a walk-in shower.
Outdoors, a gas-heated pool and spa face the lake, a Florida room with a Blackstone grill extends the house year-round, and a private cabana adds its own living room and coffee bar. The home has a three-car garage, and recent work includes new air-conditioning units, water heaters, hardwood flooring, carpet and fresh interior and exterior paint. The Colony Golf & Bay Club centers on a newly renovated Bay Club with open-air terraces and a rooftop bar overlooking Estero Bay, and members also have a fitness center, tennis and pickleball facilities, boat-shuttle access to Pelican Landing’s private 34-acre island beach park, and the Jerry Pate-designed 18-hole championship course at The Colony Golf & Country Club.
Mike Darda and Andrew Darda of Compass Florida LLC were the listing agents. The $2,750,000 transaction ranked No. 1 in RealtyWire’s Cape Coral Metro Area Top 5 for the week. Jenna Richardson of Premier Sotheby’s Int’l Realty represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 2 — $2,400,000 · 402 Lafitte Street, Boca Grande, Florida
Steps from the sand on Boca Grande’s Golden Beach, a four-bedroom house at 402 Lafitte Street sold on September 23, 2026 for $2,400,000. Built in 1990 in the Somerset Shores subdivision, the island home carries a reported 2,987 square feet.
Each bedroom has its own private entrance, dedicated air-conditioning and a full en-suite bath, an arrangement aimed at hosting guests. Plantation shutters run throughout, and the kitchen combines custom cabinetry with a Sub-Zero refrigerator, a KitchenAid cooktop, a double oven, a dishwasher and a built-in wine refrigerator. The house was built for island weather: solid cedar siding, a standing-seam metal roof, hurricane shutters and a fire suppression system.
An elevated heated pool and spa anchor the outdoor area, with Trex decking wrapping the house for low-maintenance upkeep. Expansive storage beneath the home holds beach gear alongside covered gathering areas, and parking runs to a two-car garage, two additional covered spaces and a generous driveway. A private loft balcony upstairs takes in peekaboo Gulf views, and the historic village and its dining and shopping sit a short distance away.
Cynthia Crawford and Zeke Sieglaff, Jr. of Gulf TO Bay Sotheby’s Internat were the listing agents. The $2,400,000 transaction ranked No. 2 in RealtyWire’s Cape Coral Metro Area Top 5 for the week. Brian Corcoran of The Brc Group, LLC represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 3 — $1,950,000 · 1126 Harbor Cottage Ct, Sanibel, Florida
Gregory Demaras and Eric J Pfeifer of Pfeifer Realty Group LLC were the listing agents. The island sale ranked No. 3 in RealtyWire’s Cape Coral Metro Area Top 5 for the week. Milissa Sprecher of McCallion and McCallion represented the buyer.
One of only four single-family homes in the Harbour Cottages community on Sanibel’s east end, the house at 1126 Harbor Cottage Ct closed on September 25, 2026 for $1,950,000. The 1987 home has three bedrooms, two baths and a reported 2,202 square feet. The property previously changed hands for $1,000,000 in 2019.
A split-bedroom floor plan uses pocket doors to separate the sleeping quarters, and the main level adds an office and a screened lanai overlooking the canal. Vaulted ceilings and tile floors run through the interior, with quartz countertops in the kitchen and at the bar areas. On the exterior, impact-resistant doors and windows, Hardie board siding, a three-year-old metal roof and a newly redesigned pool cage address the weather side of island ownership.
The waterfront setup is the property’s distinguishing feature: direct Gulf access with no bridges, and a seawall, dock and boat lift all replaced within the past six years. No neighbors sit across the street, and lush landscaping screens the lot. Harbour Cottages residents share tennis and pickleball courts, an outdoor grill and a heated pool, while the causeway, beaches on both sides of the island and Sanibel’s bike and walking paths are close at hand.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 4 — $1,900,000 · 14250 Royal Harbour Ct Unit 715, Fort Myers, Florida
Wide river views open from the front door of 14250 Royal Harbour Ct Unit 715, a residence in The Shores at Gulf Harbour that sold for $1,900,000. The three-bedroom, three-bath residence in the Iona area of Fort Myers dates to 2002 and carries a reported 3,213 square feet. The property previously changed hands for $730,000 in 2022.
The home was taken to the studs and rebuilt. That work brought an impact entry door, impact windows and sliders, a new air-conditioning system with upgraded ductwork and linear vents, an upgraded tankless water heater, LED lighting throughout, soundproof insulation between interior walls and a 3M floor barrier for quiet. The open kitchen and gathering rooms carry waterfall quartz, high-gloss cabinetry, 24V under-cabinet and toe-kick lighting, touchless faucets, reverse osmosis water and a glass-walled wine room.
The owner’s suite includes a spa bath with a steam shower, an LG Steam refresh closet and a built-in ironing system. Other appointments run to keyless entry, a Ring alarm, Blink cameras, a wall safe, remote-control zebra and blackout blinds, a laundry room with a second refrigerator, and Tesla and golf cart chargers. Some community amenities require membership with Gulf Harbour Yacht and Country Club.
Tasha Morris of Keller Williams Elite Realty was the listing agent. The transaction closed September 23, 2026, and the listing went under contract one day after the current listing date. The $1,900,000 closing placed her at the listing side of the No. 4 sale in RealtyWire’s Cape Coral Metro Area Top 5 for the week.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 5 — $1,899,000 · 18151 Montelago CT, Miromar Lakes, Florida
A four-bedroom courtyard residence at 18151 Montelago Ct in Miromar Lakes Beach & Golf Club sold for $1,899,000, and the closing was dated September 21, 2026. Built in 2003 in the Montelago neighborhood, the renovated home has four baths, a reported 3,254 square feet and a new roof. The property previously changed hands for $897,000 in 2017.
The courtyard is the organizing idea: a pool and spa with southeast exposure sit at the center, ringed by an outdoor kitchen, a fireplace, covered seating and tropical landscaping, with a detached casita off to one side for guests, a home office or multigenerational use. Walls of glass connect the interior rooms to that courtyard, while the rear of the house takes in north-facing golf course views.
The renovation brought an open floor plan, updated flooring, a new kitchen, reworked bathrooms and custom built-in appointments, and the systems include a whole-home generator, a whole-home water softener and filtration system and central vacuum. Miromar Lakes Beach & Golf Club is built around a 700-acre freshwater lake with three miles of private white-sand beach, boating, water skiing, kayaking and fishing, two marinas, a 10,000-square-foot zero-edge infinity pool, a full-service Beach Club with waterfront dining, a European-style spa, a fitness center, and tennis, pickleball and bocce courts. The Arthur Hills Signature Championship Golf Course is available through optional membership.
Jennifer Springer Rinden and Mary Kate Collins of Orchid Realty International were the listing agents. The $1,899,000 closing took the No. 5 position in RealtyWire’s Cape Coral Metro Area Top 5 for the week. David Gruninger of William Raveis Real Estate represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
RealtyWire selected these transactions from publicly reported residential sales identified for the calendar week ending Sunday, September 27, 2026. The report may exclude private, off-market, delayed or nondisclosed transactions. Prices, property details and professional representation are reported as available at publication and may be updated following confirmation from transaction participants.
Were you involved in one of these transactions? Contact RealtyWire to verify or correct your professional credit or submit information for a future edition.
See full market data on our Cape Coral, Florida market page.
