The five highest-priced home sales reported in Buffalo–Niagara, New York for the week ending October 25, 2026, added up to $5.16 million. Four of the homes are in Erie County and one is in Niagara County, and all five are single-family homes, in Clarence, Youngstown, Angola, East Amherst and Lancaster.
Two of the five sit on the water, two others have several acres of land around them, and the remaining sale is a renovated home on a court in East Amherst.
No. 1 — $1,600,000 · 6155 Salt Rd, Clarence, New York
The top sale of the week was 6155 Salt Road in Clarence, which sold for $1,600,000. The home stands on 8.39 acres, the largest lot in this Top 5, and the grounds read more like a small country estate than a suburban yard: an in-ground pool and patios, a barn with a workshop, a greenhouse, a gazebo and a clubhouse for children.
Built in 2012 by Tesmer as a custom home, it is the newest of the five. The exterior combines stone and vinyl siding, and inside the rooms are finished with detailed millwork. Formal living and dining rooms and a family room are arranged as an open plan. The kitchen has granite counters, an island, a breakfast bar and a butler’s pantry, and there is a separate home office. The primary suite is on the main floor and has a walk-in closet.
The home has five bedrooms, five bathrooms (four full and one half) and 4,258 square feet of living space, with two fireplaces and a three-car attached garage. Upstairs are more bedrooms, two baths and a den that could be used as another bedroom. The finished lower level adds a second family room, a gym, a wet bar and a full bath. The property last sold for $117,000 in 2009, before the current home was built.
Karen Baker Levin of Howard Hanna WNY Inc. was the listing agent, and Amy L Benjamin of HUNT Real Estate ERA represented the buyer. Baker Levin listed two of the week’s five top sales, this one and the No. 4 sale in East Amherst, giving Howard Hanna WNY Inc. both of those listings as well.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 2 — $995,000 · 4090 Lower River Rd, Youngstown, New York
The oldest home in this Top 5, 4090 Lower River Road in Youngstown, dates to 1926 and sits on the Niagara River. It sold for $995,000, its full asking price.
The brick and stucco home is a Tudor under a slate roof. A four-season sunroom lined with windows looks out over the river. On the main floor, a living room with a fireplace opens to the dining area, and the primary suite has an additional room that could serve as a nursery, a dressing room or a walk-in closet. Hardwood floors run through the home.
The lower level has a family room with a second fireplace and another sunroom with a bar that opens to a deck overlooking the water. Stairs give direct access to a floating dock, and the property also has beach access. A park setting lies across the street, with walking and biking trails nearby.
With six bedrooms, the most in this group, plus three full baths and 3,903 square feet on a 0.66-acre lot, the home has space for a guest or in-law suite with its own entrance and several rooms that work as offices or hobby space. A detached three-car garage has overhead storage.
Dana Fideli of Keller Williams Realty WNY was the listing agent. Lisa A Lannon of Great Lakes Real Estate Inc. represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 3 — $955,000 · 565 Wendt Rd, Angola, New York
At 565 Wendt Road in Angola, in the Angola on the Lake neighborhood, the attraction is Lake Erie: the home looks straight out over the lake and has direct access to a sandy beach. It sold for $955,000.
The 1989 traditional home is the largest in this Top 5, with 4,503 square feet, four bedrooms and four bathrooms (three full and one half). A tiled foyer with pillars and a built-in bench leads to a living room with hardwood floors, coffered ceilings, a stone gas fireplace and a bay window. Glass pocket doors open from there to a den finished in wainscoting.
The eat-in kitchen pairs a Viking gas range and double ovens with a large island, granite counters and beamed ceilings, and its own bay window faces the lake. On the second floor, the primary suite has lake views, two walk-in closets and a bath with a skylight and double vanities. A finished third level adds a loft and two bonus rooms under skylights.
The home also has a separate in-law apartment with vaulted ceilings, its own kitchen and bath, a bedroom with lake views and a loft reached by a spiral staircase. Outside, a large deck under an awning overlooks a landscaped yard with a pond. Attached and detached garages give the property room for four cars, the most of the five. The property last sold for $330,000 in 1998.
Susan D Lenahan of MJ Peterson Real Estate Inc. was the listing agent, and Donald McIntosh of ERA Team VP Real Estate represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 4 — $810,000 · 18 Blue Heron Ct, East Amherst, New York
The home at 18 Blue Heron Court in East Amherst went under contract six days after it was listed. It sold for $810,000.
The 1985 two-story traditional, finished in brick, stucco and vinyl siding, has been renovated inside with custom cabinetry, built-ins and detailed moldings. A foyer opens to formal living and dining rooms, and the kitchen has an island, a pantry, a breakfast bar and a beverage center. The family room rises to a high ceiling, and a den and powder room are also on the main floor. Upstairs, the primary suite has a walk-in closet and its own bath.
The home has four bedrooms, three bathrooms (two full and one half), two fireplaces and 3,243 square feet of living space, with a partially finished basement and a two-car attached garage. Its 0.28-acre lot is professionally landscaped, with a patio, gardens and irrigation sprinklers. The property last sold for $304,000 in 2004.
Karen Baker Levin of Howard Hanna WNY Inc., who also listed the week’s top sale in Clarence, was the listing agent. Calvin Caruso III of Keller Williams Realty WNY represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 5 — $800,000 · 5600 William St, Lancaster, New York
The 6.10 wooded, secluded acres at 5600 William Street in Lancaster back to Buffalo Creek. The home went under contract 11 days after it was listed and sold for $800,000, $50,000 above its $750,000 asking price.
The 1996 Colonial, in brick and vinyl siding, opens with a two-story foyer. The great room has vaulted ceilings, skylights and hickory floors, and a loft adds interest on the upper level. A sunroom with a wall of windows and a two-sided fireplace looks across green space toward the creek, and French doors lead out to a Trex deck surrounded by landscaping. The kitchen has cherry cabinetry and a center island, and a separate office has French doors and built-in shelving. The primary suite is on the first floor, with a trey ceiling.
The home has four bedrooms, four bathrooms (three full and one half) and 3,013 square feet of living space. A partially finished basement with its own exterior entry adds recreation and storage rooms. The three-car attached garage has an epoxy floor and a workshop, and the property also has a second garage and sheds. It last sold for $285,000 in 2005.
Jeanine M Kacala of HUNT Real Estate ERA was the listing agent, and Dalton Reynolds of Keller Williams Realty WNY represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
RealtyWire selected these transactions from publicly reported residential sales identified for the calendar week ending Sunday, October 25, 2026. The report may exclude private, off-market, delayed or nondisclosed transactions. Prices, property details and professional representation are reported as available at publication and may be updated following confirmation from transaction participants.
Were you involved in one of these transactions? Contact RealtyWire to verify or correct your professional credit or submit information for a future edition.
