Lake living dominated the highest-priced home sales reported in Waukesha & Lake Country, Wisconsin for the week ending October 25, 2026. The five sales came to a combined $12.605 million.
The list runs from a seven-acre property on Okauchee Lake to a 1949 Cape Cod on Lac La Belle, a contemporary with two piers, a downtown Oconomowoc condominium overlooking Fowler Lake, and a Colonial with an indoor pool in the Indian Hills neighborhood of Elm Grove. Every sale was in Waukesha County, and one brokerage listed two of the five.
No. 1 — $6,300,000 · W335N5511 Island View Lane, Nashotah, Wisconsin
The week’s top sale came with 7.01 wooded acres and about 120 feet of frontage on Okauchee Lake in Nashotah, where the home sold for $6,300,000. The Cape Cod-style home was built in 1988, and the listing says it has since been completely remade inside and out, to the level of a custom new build.
At 7,608 square feet, it is the largest home in this Top 5, and its five bedrooms are also the most of the group. There are five baths, four full and one half. Inside are vaulted ceilings, a kitchen with an island and a pantry, walk-in closets and a sauna. The full basement is finished, with ceilings of eight feet or more and walk-out access.
The land is where the property sets itself apart. Beyond the main home are a detached building for entertaining, a separate garage and a pickleball court. There is a hillside trolley and a private dock, along with several terraces for entertaining, a deck and a patio. The landscaping is new, and the views across the lake take in the sunset.
Rebecca Thomas of Keller Williams – Lake Country was the listing agent.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 2 — $1,950,000 · 904 W Labelle Avenue, Oconomowoc, Wisconsin
The oldest home in this Top 5 is on Lac La Belle in Oconomowoc. Built in 1949, the Cape Cod at 904 W Labelle Avenue sold for $1,950,000. It is on a dead-end street beside the historic Merchants Plat, and the downtown’s restaurants, shops, coffee and parks are within walking distance.
The property has 61.5 feet of frontage with a sandy beach of its own, a pier and a boathouse that was renovated in 2011. The home has 4,166 square feet, with three bedrooms, one of them on the main floor, and four full baths. Wood floors, vaulted ceilings and a kitchen island are part of the main living space, and a fieldstone fireplace opens to rooms on both sides.
Downstairs, the walk-out lower level has a bar, a sauna and open space for guests. Outside are a deck and a patio.
Amy Russell of Stapleton Realty was the listing agent, and Bonnie Lewis-Tschannen represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 3 — $1,650,000 · N57W34599 Road G, Oconomowoc, Wisconsin
Two piers and 113 feet of Okauchee Lake frontage came with this 1967 contemporary in Oconomowoc, which sold for $1,650,000. The level, wooded lot covers 0.93 acres and sits just off the lake’s main bay.
The home has 2,571 square feet, three bedrooms, one of them on the main floor, and three baths, two full and one half. Radiant heat runs under the floors, and the full basement walks out toward the lake. Brick, stone and wood siding make up the exterior, and the property has a deck and a patio. There is a detached three-car garage, plus additional parking. The property last sold for $1.5 million in 2025.
The home went under contract 26 days after it was listed. Devin Piehl of First Weber Inc – Delafield was the listing agent, and Sean Casper represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 4 — $1,355,000 · 215 E Pleasant Street #302, Oconomowoc, Wisconsin
The newest home in the group is a 2020 condominium at Fowler Lake Village in downtown Oconomowoc. Unit 302 sold above its asking price of $1.3 million, closing at $1,355,000.
Its private balcony faces west over Fowler Lake. The home has 1,924 square feet, with two bedrooms, both on the main level, two full baths, a great room, a den, a kitchen with an island, a dining area and a primary suite. Wood floors run through the unit, and walk-in closets and a storage locker add room for belongings.
Residents share a rooftop deck, a fitness room, a club room, green space and a dog run, and the building has an elevator and security. The sale includes two assigned spaces in the heated underground garage, near the building entrance. The downtown’s shops and restaurants are close by. The condominium last sold for $1.069 million in 2024.
It went under contract seven days after it was listed. Tina Stapelfeldt of First Weber Inc – Delafield was the listing agent, and Marie Grandelis represented the buyer. First Weber Inc – Delafield listed two of this week’s Top 5 sales, the third- and fourth-ranked homes.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 5 — $1,350,000 · 14220 Hillside Road, Elm Grove, Wisconsin
A rotunda foyer opens this 1968 Colonial in the Indian Hills neighborhood of Elm Grove, which sold for $1,350,000. The home sits on 2 acres and has 5,245 square feet.
Its six baths, five full and one half, are the most in this Top 5, and the home has four bedrooms, with en-suite baths among them. The primary suite has a sitting area and a large closet. Elsewhere are an indoor pool, three fireplaces, a kitchen with an island, a wet bar, vaulted ceilings and a room for bathing the dog. Radiant heat runs through the floors, and the laundry is on the second floor.
The partially finished basement has full-size windows and walk-out access. A garage for five cars is attached. The property last sold for $930,000 in 2020.
Kevin Koski of 3% Real Estate was the listing agent, and The Tighe Team represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
RealtyWire selected these transactions from publicly reported residential sales identified for the calendar week ending Sunday, October 25, 2026. The report may exclude private, off-market, delayed or nondisclosed transactions. Prices, property details and professional representation are reported as available at publication and may be updated following confirmation from transaction participants.
Were you involved in one of these transactions? Contact RealtyWire to verify or correct your professional credit or submit information for a future edition.
