The five highest-priced home sales reported in the Indianapolis metro area for the week ending October 18, 2026, totaled $18.84 million. Three were in Hamilton County, one in Fishers and two in Carmel, and two were in Indianapolis.
All five are single-family homes, and they cover a wide range: a large estate on the water, a home on wooded acreage outside any subdivision, a custom home finished this year, a contemporary with resort-style grounds and a Craftsman on a city lot.
No. 1 — $9,243,820 · 10606 Brooks School Rd, Fishers, Indiana
The week’s top sale was a gated waterfront estate at 10606 Brooks School Road in Fishers, which sold for $9,243,820. The property covers 5.23 acres with about 570 feet of shoreline on Geist Reservoir. It is the largest of the five in land and in living area, with 21,010 square feet, and it also has the most bedrooms and bathrooms: nine bedrooms and 12 bathrooms, nine of them full and three half baths.
Built in 1990 in a traditional style and finished in stone and stucco, the home is reached by a gas-lit drive lined with trees. Inside, an elevator serves three levels, and there are seven fireplaces. On the main level, a study with a fireplace opens to a lounge with a bar and a billiards area. The kitchen has commercial-grade appliances and a 14-foot island, with a separate caterer’s kitchen a few steps away, and it opens to a heated 38-foot veranda with a grilling area, retractable screens and views of the lake.
The primary bedroom sits in a private owner’s wing that also has a reading room. It has a double-sided fireplace, curved walls and a full wall of windows looking out to the water, and its bath is set beneath a barrel ceiling of glass tile. The suite has 650 square feet of closet space. Upstairs, one wing has a loft and two bedrooms with their own baths, while a separate guest wing has its own kitchen, living room and laundry.
The walkout lower level is given over to entertaining. A theater, a fitness studio and an arcade share it with a wine cellar for 700 bottles and a bar that seats 15. On the water is a three-slip boat dock 50 feet long. The grounds also have a 50-foot gunite pool with a slide and waterfalls, a spa, fire features, several patios and a children’s play cottage with its own heating and air conditioning. A newer carriage house has two apartments of 900 square feet, each with its own living room, kitchen, bedroom suite and laundry. The property last sold for $2.165 million in 2016.
Allen Williams and Joel Woelfle, both of Berkshire Hathaway Home, were the listing agents on the week’s highest-priced sale. Kay Kammeyer of F.C. Tucker Company represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 2 — $3,133,159 · 3300 W 106th St, Carmel, Indiana
A long drive lined with trees leads back to 3300 West 106th Street in Carmel, where a Chateau and Italianate home stands on 4.63 wooded acres outside any subdivision. It sold for $3,133,159. Built in 1989, it is the oldest of the five homes. It is finished in stone and stucco and has 8,584 square feet, five bedrooms and eight bathrooms, five of them full and three half baths.
The great room has a raised ceiling with exposed beams and a stone hearth fireplace, and the main level has travertine floors. A formal dining room with a masonry fireplace, a private office and a mudroom with a dog wash station are also on that floor. The updated kitchen has an oversized center island, quartz counters, Sub-Zero refrigeration and Thermador double ovens. Upstairs, the primary suite takes up its own wing, with a domed ceiling, a limestone fireplace and a custom walk-in closet. The lower level has a kitchenette and a recreation room.
The main living spaces open straight onto the patio and the pool. An open-air pool house has a full kitchen, a bath and laundry, and the property also has an outdoor kitchen and an outdoor shower. Around the home are mature trees, fruit trees, perennial gardens and broad lawns. The property last sold for $800,000 in 2004.
Michelle Armstrong of Encore Sotheby’s International was the listing agent, and Trystan Guernsey of F.C. Tucker Company represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 3 — $2,650,000 · 9214 Bluestone Cir, Indianapolis, Indiana
The newest of the week’s five homes, finished in 2026, is a custom home built by JK Heritage Homes at 9214 Bluestone Circle in the Admirals Pointe neighborhood of Indianapolis. It sold for $2,650,000. The brick home sits on a cul-de-sac on a wooded lot of 0.38 acres and overlooks Geist Reservoir. It has two stories and a walkout lower level, with 10,065 square feet, eight bedrooms and ten bathrooms, eight of them full and two half baths.
The great room rises to a 22-foot ceiling, and accordion-fold doors 16 feet wide open it to a patio with its own gas fireplace and a vaulted ceiling finished in wood. The kitchen has Z Line appliances and a center island topped in waterfall quartz, with a prep kitchen and pantry behind it. At the front, a formal office has built-in cabinets and an electric fireplace, and the main-level laundry room includes a dog-washing station.
The primary suite has a vaulted ceiling, a sitting area that looks over the private backyard and a gas fireplace surrounded in Taj Mahal stone. Its bath has a freestanding tub and dual vanities. Upstairs are four more bedrooms, each with its own bath, and a loft. The walkout lower level has a speakeasy-style lounge, a wine cellar, a wet bar and an exercise room, along with two more bedrooms with their own baths, one of them a bunk room. The property last sold for $112,450 in 2024, before the current home was built.
Dan O’Brien of Trueblood Real Estate was the listing agent, and Amy McIntyre of Circle Real Estate represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 4 — $1,955,000 · 7070 Dean Rd, Indianapolis, Indiana
At 7070 Dean Road, in the Glendale neighborhood of Indianapolis, a contemporary Prairie-style home on two wooded acres in Washington Township sold for $1,955,000. Built in 2018 and finished in stone and cement siding, it has 8,724 square feet, five bedrooms and six bathrooms, five of them full and one a half bath.
The open main floor centers on a kitchen with a large Cambria quartz island, Thermador appliances and a walk-in pantry. Next to it, the dining room can be closed off with double glass doors and a pocket door, and it has a full bar with a beverage refrigerator, an ice maker and a sink. The owner’s suite is on the main floor, with a spa-style bath, an oversized walk-in closet and its own laundry station. Upstairs are two bedrooms with their own baths and a loft, and the finished lower level adds two more bedroom suites, a home theater, a fitness room and a wet bar.
The backyard has a saltwater pool with a diving board, a court for basketball and pickleball, a firepit and a covered porch with a gas fire pit. The property is fenced and irrigated, with mature trees and professional landscaping. The property last sold for $1.64 million in 2022.
The home went under contract 14 days after it was listed. Tom McNulty and Pat McNulty, both of McNulty Real Estate Services, were the listing agents, and Mike Deck of Berkshire Hathaway Home represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 5 — $1,859,000 · 751 1st Ave NW, Carmel, Indiana
The Craftsman home at 751 1st Avenue NW is in the Carmel Arts District, blocks from the Monon Trail and within walking distance of downtown Carmel. It sold for $1,859,000. Built in 2018 in brick, cedar and cement siding on a quarter-acre lot, it has 5,488 square feet, four bedrooms and five bathrooms, four of them full and one a half bath. Inside are a bright library, a fireplace, a kitchen made for cooking and gathering, a primary suite with a spa-style bath and a finished basement. Outside, a stone patio with a pergola is set among landscaped grounds, and the home has a three-car garage.
Jason O’Neil of Circle Real Estate was the listing agent, and Bhavana Thapar of The Agency Indy represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
RealtyWire selected these transactions from publicly reported residential sales identified for the calendar week ending Sunday, October 18, 2026. The report may exclude private, off-market, delayed or nondisclosed transactions. Prices, property details and professional representation are reported as available at publication and may be updated following confirmation from transaction participants.
Were you involved in one of these transactions? Contact RealtyWire to verify or correct your professional credit or submit information for a future edition.
See full market data on our Indianapolis Metro Area market page.
