
A federal judge in Fort Lauderdale has permanently thrown out a flat-fee broker’s antitrust lawsuit against the National Association of Realtors and 13 Florida Realtor associations and MLSs. The broker claimed the groups worked together to avoid enforcing their own rules against commission steering. U.S. District Judge William P. Dimitrouleas signed the order dismissing the case with prejudice on Nov. 16, 2026. Dismissal with prejudice means the claims cannot be filed again against these defendants. The order also tells the clerk to close the case.
The plaintiff, Jorge A. Zea, represented himself. Court filings describe him as a licensed Florida broker who runs SnapFlatFee.com, a low-cost listing service. Sellers pay a flat fee to get their home on the MLS and handle showings and negotiations themselves. His suit did not attack NAR’s rules. It argued that organized real estate adopted rules meant to protect competition and then agreed not to enforce them, which hurt discount brokers like him.
What the NAR antitrust lawsuit claimed
According to the Oct. 16 report and recommendation by Magistrate Judge Shaniek Mills Maynard, Zea’s amended complaint named four kinds of rules he said were not enforced:
- rules against commission-based steering, where a buyer’s agent points clients toward or away from homes based on the pay offered rather than what the buyer wants;
- rules against commission filtering, where MLS listings shown to consumers are screened by the compensation offered or by brokerage;
- the written buyer-broker agreement requirement, which, according to the complaint, obliges an agent to sign an agreement with a buyer before touring a home and to state the compensation; and
- the IDX display rule, which requires listing websites to show the listing firm and a contact for the listing agent.
A fifth count accused NAR alone of breaking its own antitrust-compliance policy through public messages about commission levels, full-service representation and alternative brokerage models. The defendants were NAR; eight associations, including Miami, Orlando Regional, Naples and Broward, Palm Beaches and St. Lucie; and five MLSs, including Stellar MLS, Beaches MLS and realMLS.
Why the court rejected it
The magistrate judge’s analysis, which Dimitrouleas adopted in full, turned on one point. Section 1 of the Sherman Act requires an agreement to restrain trade, and the complaint never plausibly alleged one. Zea argued that the agreement was the governance structure itself, where competing brokers “sit together, vote together, and collectively set the rules and enforcement standards that govern all of them.”
Maynard disagreed, citing Eleventh Circuit precedent that participation in trade organizations “provides no indication of conspiracy.” She wrote that a committee’s vote on a single ethics complaint “does not necessarily reflect an agreement to suppress competition,” and that Zea had not identified “a vote, communication, directive, policy, meeting, or other factual event” showing the defendants agreed not to enforce the rules.
The record also undercut his claim that enforcement uniformly failed. The report notes that the Orlando Regional Realtor Association reversed an initial dismissal of one of Zea’s steering complaints, held a hearing, found a violation of Article 1 of the Code of Ethics and imposed sanctions. Maynard wrote that this “undermines Plaintiff’s assertion that Defendants uniformly declined to enforce” the steering rules.
Zea also offered so-called “plus factors” meant to suggest collusion: a shared motive to protect what he called the “5β6% commission norm,” chances to coordinate through NAR governance, the claimed statistical improbability of so many dismissals, and NAR’s public messaging. The report found none of them enough. “If existence of a profit motive was enough to make it plausible that the defendants had colluded to fix prices, then essentially every alleged price fixing agreement would survive a motion to dismiss,” it said, quoting an earlier decision.
Second try, final answer
This was Zea’s second complaint. Then-Chief Magistrate Judge William Matthewman recommended dismissing the original 122-page complaint without prejudice in March. That report also questioned the reliability of Zea’s legal authorities and noted “apparently hallucinated cases and fictitious legal concepts,” according to Maynard’s later report. Maynard wrote that she found no hallucinated cases in his response to the second motion to dismiss. The court gave him until April 27 to try again, and he filed a 96-page amended complaint.
In the final order, Dimitrouleas wrote that Zea’s objections “merely reassert arguments that the Report already analyzed and rejected.” He agreed that Zea “has had a meaningful opportunity to amend,” that further amendment “would be futile,” and that dismissal with prejudice was appropriate. The court never reached the defendants’ other arguments, including standing and their claim that disputes over the buyer-agreement rule belong in the Western District of Missouri, where NAR’s commission settlement is supervised.
Where it fits
The ruling follows other decisions upholding dismissals of antitrust suits against organized real estate. The 10th Circuit upheld the dismissal of Homie’s suit against NAR, and the Fifth Circuit upheld the dismissal of a challenge to a Realtor membership rule. Not every challenge to industry practices has failed: a federal judge let agents’ antitrust claims against Zillow go forward on all five counts.
On our reading, the order says little about whether steering happens. It holds that Zea did not plead an agreement among the defendants. The rules he cited still apply to Realtor members and MLS participants. The ruling means a broker who thinks they are not being enforced will have a hard time turning that into a federal conspiracy claim without evidence of an actual agreement. More industry litigation coverage is on our agents and brokerages page.



