Market Datavs. 1 year ago
30-year mortgage7.11%▲ +0.87 pts15-year mortgage6.45%▲ +0.96 pts10-year Treasury5.12%▲ +0.99 ptsMortgage spread1.99 pts▼ -0.12 ptsMedian list price (Oct)$415k▼ -2.2%List $/sqft (Oct)$222▼ -1.3%Days on market (Oct)63 +0 daysActive listings (Oct)1.18M▲ +7.4%New listings (Oct)357k▼ -7.5%Pending sales (Oct)381k▼ -10.7%Housing starts (Sep)1.22M▼ -7.4%Building permits (Sep)1.4M▼ -3.2%New-home sales (Sep)676k▼ -5.3%Existing-home sales (Oct)3.75M▼ -8.8%Months of supply (Sep)8.4▲ +0.2 moMortgage delinquency (Q2)1.86%▲ +0.08 pts
Updated 4:40 PM ET
Agents & Brokerages

Only Illinois and Arizona Make Agent Discipline Easy to Find in State License Lookups, Consumer Group Says

The Consumer Policy Center rated 24 states poor and found that in 16 a consumer checking the official license lookup would see no sign of an agent's disciplinary action.

Only Illinois and Arizona Make Agent Discipline Easy to Find in State License Lookups, Consumer Group Says

Agents and their clients are told to check a state’s license lookup before hiring someone. A new 50-state review says that check will usually miss an agent’s disciplinary record. In a report released Nov. 17, 2026, the Washington-based Consumer Policy Center rated only Illinois and Arizona as giving consumers good access to discipline information about real estate licensees. It rated 24 states poor.

The report, Evaluating State Disclosure of Disciplinary Actions Against Real Estate Agents, was written by CPC fellow Wendy Gilch. From September through November 2026 she used each state’s official real estate license lookup the way a consumer would. She searched for licensees with a documented disciplinary history or, where none was available, agents charged with a crime in the past five years.

“State regulators need no additional authority to increase consumer access to important information about agents they may employ,” Gilch said in the release. “Regulators need only a stronger commitment to their statutory obligation to protect home buyers and sellers.”

How the real estate agent discipline records were scored

Each lookup was scored on three questions, worth up to 8 points in total. Is the action easy to find, flagged in the first result a consumer sees (up to 4 points)? Does it explain in plain language what happened (up to 3)? Does it show the brokerages the licensee has worked for (1)? A state scoring 6 to 8 rated good, 3 to 5 needs improvement, and 0 to 2 poor. Kentucky, Washington and Wyoming were left unrated because the results were inconclusive.

Of the 47 states rated, Illinois scored highest with 7 points. It flags the action on the licensee’s summary and explains it in plain language, but it does not show work history. Arizona scored 6. It explains actions and lists past brokerages, but a consumer has to click into the profile and scroll to find the discipline. No state earned all 8 points.

Twenty-one states rated needs improvement, including Texas, California, Pennsylvania and Michigan. The 24 rated poor include Florida, Massachusetts and Missouri at 2 points each. Sixteen states scored zero, among them New York, New Jersey, North Carolina, Georgia, Maryland, Ohio and Nevada. In those 16, the report says, a consumer who checked the lookup as the commission advises “would have found no sign of the action, no document and no work history.”

Buried, mislabeled or kept somewhere else

Only Delaware, Idaho and Illinois flagged an action in the first summary or search result. In 27 more states it appeared only after the consumer clicked into a profile or scrolled down. In the other 17, the action could not be found on the lookup at all. Only eight states described the violation in plain language. Only Arizona and California showed an agent’s past brokerages.

The report gives examples. Wisconsin files actions under “Orders,” and consumers have to download a PDF to learn what happened. Kansas lists violations as statute numbers only, after several clicks. Several states, including Arkansas, Maryland, Minnesota and Nevada, publish discipline in batches on separate pages or in newsletters that never connect to the licensee’s record. New Jersey’s lookup showed nothing for licensees with actions. The report says New Jersey made only four disciplinary actions public in fiscal 2025 while overseeing more than 96,000 licensees.

Some discipline never becomes public at all. Oregon resolves minor violations with Educational Letters of Advice. These are not counted as discipline, are kept out of disciplinary records and are expunged after six years. The report says Oregon issued 106 such letters in 2025, nearly three for each of its 39 public actions.

Criminal charges and a clean-looking record

The report’s harshest criticism concerns licensees facing serious criminal charges. It says a Texas licensee charged with possession of child sexual abuse material kept an active license with no disciplinary history on the lookup for more than three years after charges were filed, until the Texas Real Estate Commission revoked it in September 2026. The report quotes the commission saying it “does not have the authority to revoke or suspend a license holder that has been only charged or accused.” CPC counters that Section 1101.662 of the Texas Occupations Code requires a three-member panel to temporarily suspend a license when a licensee’s continued practice would be a continuing threat to the public welfare. It notes that the panel can act without advance notice or a hearing and that the statute does not require a conviction or plea.

The report also found records that dropped out of search. It says one Arizona agent could no longer be found in the state’s lookup a few days after his Sept. 4, 2026, arrest, and was searchable again by Oct. 12.

Agents licensed in several states, and an AI test

Agents near state lines often hold more than one license, and each state’s record stands alone. The report contrasts that with mortgage lending. A free search through NMLS Consumer Access shows every state where a loan officer is licensed, along with public regulatory actions. ARELLO, the association of real estate regulators, keeps a national disciplinary database, but the report says only regulators can use it and just 15 jurisdictions are actively sharing and updating records.

CPC also asked an Anthropic AI model, with web search on, whether the same agents had been disciplined. It found no record of any action in 34 of the 47 states, including Illinois and Arizona, whose discipline sits inside lookup tools that web searches cannot open. In the 13 states where it found something, the information came from commission minutes, posted orders and newsletters rather than the lookups.

What CPC wants states to change

The report makes nine recommendations:

  • flag discipline on the main record in a caution color, “never green”;
  • label records “Disciplinary Actions” instead of terms such as “Orders” or “Case History”;
  • add a plain-language summary of each action;
  • keep records permanent and searchable;
  • list past brokerages with dates;
  • disclose warning and educational letters;
  • require licensees to report federal or state housing and consumer-protection actions within 30 days, including civil settlements and pretrial diversion;
  • enroll licensees in the FBI’s fingerprint-based Rap Back monitoring and use interim suspensions for serious felony charges; and
  • publish discipline on pages that search engines can read.

It also urges ARELLO and its members to open a consumer version of the national database.

The report says it is a snapshot of known records in each state, not an audit of every file, and that it is not meant to criticize commission staff, “many of whom work with limited resources.” CPC says its next report will look at how easy it is to file a complaint and how many complaints end in public discipline.

Consumer protection in the homebuying process is drawing attention elsewhere too: Sens. Booker and Warren have asked the FTC to look into portal referral fees and lender steering. Our agents and brokerages page tracks licensing and industry-practice news.

βœ‰

Stay ahead of the market.

Get expert insights, market updates, and new opportunities delivered to your inbox.

RealtyWire Newsletter Signup
We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe anytime.