Water and land set the tone for the highest-priced home sales reported in the Rochester Area, New York for the week ending October 25, 2026. Two of the five homes are in Canandaigua, one is a ranch above Naples, one sits on the shore of Lake Ontario in Ontario, and the fifth is in the Demarco neighborhood of Honeoye Falls. They range from a Victorian built in 1868 to a ranch completed in 2008, and the five sales came to a combined $7.075 million.
No. 1 — $2,840,000 · 4752 W Lake Rd, Canandaigua, New York
The oldest home in this week’s group is also its most expensive. Built in 1868, the Victorian at 4752 West Lake Road in Canandaigua sold for $2,840,000. It sits on 2.87 wooded acres on Canandaigua Lake, with about 139 feet of shoreline facing south across Menteth Cove. The waterfront has a wade-in beach, deep water for boating, cobblestone walls, irrigated lawns and a lighted dock built of Ipe.
The boathouse has been reworked as a place to spend the day. Along with storage for a boat and kayaks, it has a bathroom, a covered outdoor kitchen with a grill and refrigerator, a lounge around a gas fire pit and a covered veranda on its upper level looking out over the lake.
Visitors arrive under a porte cochere, which was rebuilt along with the home’s covered porches. Inside, the 5,038-square-foot home keeps much of its nineteenth-century character: restored millwork, curved radius windows, sweeping staircases and a window seat set into the turret. There are three fireplaces and new hardwood floors. The family room has a large radius picture window, a game room rises two stories, and the updated kitchen has custom cabinetry, a Wolf range, a granite island with a prep sink, a breakfast bar and a walk-in pantry.
The home has four bedrooms and four bathrooms, three full and one half. Upstairs, the primary suite faces the lake, and its bath has radiant heated floors, a soaking tub, a walk-in shower and a walk-in closet. A loft-style bonus room, a private guest suite, first-floor laundry, a whole-home generator and a three-car garage complete the property.
Danielle M. Clement of Tru Agent Real Estate was on both sides of the sale, listing the home and representing the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 2 — $1,775,000 · 6126 Rossier Rd, Canandaigua, New York
At 35.30 acres, 6126 Rossier Road in Canandaigua has by far the most land of the five, and the land is much of its story. The Colonial, built in 1994, sold for $1,775,000. The acreage takes in mature woods, open pasture, a stocked pond, creeks and ravines, with trails kept up for riding, hiking and hunting. A six-stall barn opens onto fenced pastures, there is an outdoor riding arena, and a second barn provides room for equipment.
The home is also the largest of the group, at 6,011 square feet, with the most bedrooms, eight, and the most bathrooms, five, four of them full and one a half bath. It has been extensively remodeled. The kitchen has a large island, quartz countertops, radiant heated floors, custom cabinetry and oversized windows. A double-sided masonry heater with a wood-fired pizza oven joins the dining and living areas, and a stone fireplace anchors the family room.
The primary suite has a walk-in closet. A finished third floor has its own full bath, and part of the basement is finished as well, with a walkout. One bedroom is on the main level, and an in-law suite added in 2015 has a separate entrance, its own kitchen, bathroom, bedroom and living area, and radiant floors. The property last sold for $470,000 in 2011.
Shelby L. Bailey of Keller Williams Realty Greater Rochester was the listing agent, and Catherine R. Wyble of Keller Williams Realty Greater Rochester represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 3 — $875,000 · 6600 Fribolin Rd, Naples, New York
The newest home of the five is a 2008 ranch on 8.09 acres at 6600 Fribolin Road in Naples. It sits at the end of a dead-end road on secluded, wooded land, and the listing describes a lake view. The home sold for $875,000, which was $235,000 above its asking price of $640,000.
With two bedrooms, it has the fewest of the group, and both are on the main level, including the primary suite. There are three bathrooms, two full and one half, in 2,438 square feet. The full walkout basement is unusually generous, with bay windows, a sliding glass door, a high ceiling, a half bath and an extra garage bay on the lower level, in addition to the three-car attached garage above. Two staircases lead down to it, and carpeted stairs go up to an attic with room for storage. Outside are a deck, a gazebo and a workshop.
Leandro S. Caprini of Caprini Realtors was the listing agent, and Richard J. Testa of Howard Hanna represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 4 — $805,000 · 447 Ontario Dr, Ontario, New York
On Lake Ontario, 447 Ontario Drive in Ontario went under contract 16 days after it was listed and sold for $805,000, which was $105,100 above its asking price of $699,900. The ranch was built in 1960 and sits on 0.93 acres with about 115 feet of waterfront and beach access. A lawn slopes down to a patio at the water’s edge.
It is the smallest home of the five, at 2,028 square feet, and its one-floor plan is built around the lake. The tiled entry foyer looks straight out to the water and opens to a great room with a cathedral ceiling, a stone fireplace, hardwood floors and a wall of windows. The updated kitchen, with white custom cabinetry and quartz countertops, opens to the great room, and the living areas lead out to a large deck. The home has three bedrooms, all on the main level, including a primary suite with a lake view, and two bathrooms. There is also a home office, first-floor laundry and a two-car garage.
Ontario Drive is a street of lakefront homes just east of Webster, with public water, sewer and gas, and marinas on Irondequoit Bay and at Pultneyville are nearby. The property last sold for $288,500 in 2011.
Richard J. Testa and Robert Testa of Howard Hanna were the listing agents, and Adam J Grandmont of Keller Williams Realty Greater Rochester represented the buyer. Howard Hanna listed two of this week’s five homes, this one and the sale at 104 Semmel Road.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 5 — $780,000 · 104 Semmel Rd, Honeoye Falls, New York
Much of life at 104 Semmel Road, a 2006 Colonial in the Demarco neighborhood of Honeoye Falls, happens out back. The three-acre property has an in-ground pool, a pool house, a large stone patio and a fire pit, surrounded by landscaped gardens and a private yard. The home sold for $780,000.
Inside are 3,400 square feet, five bedrooms and three bathrooms, two full and one half. A two-story foyer opens the home. The kitchen and family room are one open space, with a sliding glass door to the patio, and the formal dining room has Brazilian cherry floors. Engineered wood runs through the rest of the first floor, which also has a room that can serve as an office or a formal living room. Upstairs, with bamboo floors, the primary suite has an updated bath with a heated floor and a large walk-in closet, and a flex room can be used as a bedroom or a second family room.
The partly finished lower level adds more living space, a large workshop, storage and a walkout to the pool area. A three-car garage completes the home, which is in the Honeoye Falls-Lima school district. The property last sold for $368,250 in 2008.
The home went under contract 11 days after it was listed and sold $40,100 above its asking price of $739,900. Kay J. Lang of Howard Hanna was the listing agent, and Jasmine Disch Watson of Tru Agent Real Estate represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
RealtyWire selected these transactions from publicly reported residential sales identified for the calendar week ending Sunday, October 25, 2026. The report may exclude private, off-market, delayed or nondisclosed transactions. Prices, property details and professional representation are reported as available at publication and may be updated following confirmation from transaction participants.
Were you involved in one of these transactions? Contact RealtyWire to verify or correct your professional credit or submit information for a future edition.
