The five highest-priced home sales reported in the Indianapolis metro area for the week ending October 4, 2026, came to a combined $10.375 million. Four of the five were in Hamilton County, two of them in Westfield, and the fifth was in Zionsville in Boone County.
The group spans more than three decades of building, from a 1994 home in Carmel to a new-construction home finished this year. Two of the sales tied for fourth place, each closing at $1,800,000, and one of them was handled on both sides by the same agent.
No. 1 — $2,770,000 · 16195 Oak Rd, Westfield, Indiana
The most expensive sale of the week was also the newest home in the group. The home at 16195 Oak Road in Westfield, completed in 2026, sold for $2,770,000. It sits on 4.07 acres, the largest lot among the five, and was set facing southwest so that its rear rooms and patios take the afternoon and evening light.
An arched entry opens to rooms with 12-foot ceilings, Andersen windows and solid wood doors. The traditional design, finished in stone and cement siding, has 7,816 square feet of living space on two floors, with five bedrooms, each with its own bathroom, and seven baths in all: five full and two half. The kitchen has an island and a scullery beside it, and the home also has two laundry rooms, a wet bar, a flex space above the garage and a wellness room with a sauna. A two-sided fireplace serves the great room.
Outdoors, two covered patios share a two-sided fireplace and an outdoor kitchen, and the rest of the acreage is open land. The property has a three-car side-facing garage, no homeowners association, and sits minutes from downtown Westfield.
The home went under contract 20 days after it was listed. Alexis Alvey and Nick Burrow of The Brokerage Company of Indiana were the listing agents, and Kyle Ingle of eXp Realty, LLC represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 2 — $2,150,000 · 10590 Geist View Dr, McCordsville, Indiana
On the water at Geist, the ranch-style home at 10590 Geist View Drive in the Springs Of Cambridge neighborhood of McCordsville sold for $2,150,000, its full asking price. Built in 2022, it has a private boat dock with water and electricity, a kayak rack and a jet ski platform, all set along a quarried stone seawall.
The main floor opens to a great room with custom ceiling beams and a fireplace with a built-in bench, leading into a kitchen with quartz counters, a large island and a walk-in pantry. The primary suite is on this level and opens to a covered upper deck with its own fireplace. Two more bedrooms and an office with built-ins share the floor, and oak engineered hardwood covers much of it, with views of the lake from throughout the home.
The walkout lower level adds a custom bar, a workout room and a fourth bedroom with its own bath, and steps out to a covered patio and a heated saltwater pool in a fenced back yard. The home has four bathrooms and 5,916 square feet in all, on a 0.34-acre lot, along with a four-car tandem garage.
Jennifer Moretton of F.C. Tucker Company was the listing agent, and Liz Marks-Strauss, also of F.C. Tucker Company, represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 3 — $1,855,000 · 20319 Chatham Hills Blvd, Westfield, Indiana
In the Chatham Hills golf community in Westfield, the home at 20319 Chatham Hills Boulevard sold for $1,855,000. Built in 2018 on a 0.34-acre lot, it looks out over the sixth tee box and a pond, and the community’s clubhouse, golf course, pools, fitness center, tennis courts and trails are close at hand.
The traditional home, in stone and wood siding, has five bedrooms, five bathrooms (four full and one half) and 6,391 square feet. On the main level are a private office, the primary suite, hardwood floors and a living room built around a floor-to-ceiling stone fireplace. The kitchen has a center island, double ovens and a gas cooktop. Three bedrooms are upstairs, along with a bonus room lit by skylights and served by its own heating and cooling system.
The finished daylight basement, with ceilings of nine feet or more, has a recreation room, a wet bar, a home gym and a flex room now set up with a sauna and cold plunge. Outside, a stamped concrete patio with remote-controlled screens leads to a recessed hot tub, a fire pit and an outdoor kitchen, all facing the course and the pond. The home has a four-car garage, and the property last sold for $1.035 million in 2018.
Justin Wiley of Berkshire Hathaway Home was the listing agent. Berkshire Hathaway Home was the listing brokerage on two sales in this week’s Top 5.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 4 — $1,800,000 · 620 Mayfair Ln, Carmel, Indiana
The largest home in the group, and the oldest, is the brick traditional at 620 Mayfair Lane in the Claybridge neighborhood of Carmel. Built in 1994 on a cul-de-sac, it sold for $1,800,000 and has 11,201 square feet, seven bedrooms and 10 bathrooms (eight full and two half), the most of any of the five.
Five fireplaces warm the home, among them one in the library and one in the primary bedroom. The kitchen has a large island with its own sink and a custom range hood, and it opens to the living room. The layout includes in-law quarters, and the daylight basement has ceilings of nine feet or more and walks out to the 1.18-acre grounds, where mature trees surround an in-ground pool, a deck, a patio, a fire pit and an outdoor dining area. The home also has a four-car garage.
The home went under contract the same day it was listed and sold at its full asking price. Lori Shanahan of Compass Indiana, LLC was on both sides of the sale.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 5 — $1,800,000 · 435 Benderfield Dr, Zionsville, Indiana
Matching the Carmel sale at $1,800,000, the French Provincial home at 435 Benderfield Drive in Zionsville’s Benderfield neighborhood went under contract two days after it was listed and sold $100,000 above its $1.7 million asking price. Built in 1996 on a 0.84-acre wooded lot on a cul-de-sac, it is within easy walking distance of schools, shops, the Village and the Rail Trail.
The home has been extensively updated. New oak hardwood floors run through the main level and the upstairs hallway, and the renovated kitchen has custom cabinetry, quartz counters, floating shelves and a 36-inch gas range. A main-level office, a mudroom, a breakfast room and the primary suite share that floor, and the primary bath, redone in 2026, has a soaking tub and a tiled shower with a quartz bench. A screened porch looks out on the wooded lot and the in-ground pool.
There are five bedrooms, five bathrooms (four full and one half) and 6,643 square feet in the brick and wood-sided home. Upstairs, a bonus room could serve as a sixth bedroom, and the finished daylight basement has the fifth bedroom, a wet bar, a fireplace and a workshop. A basketball court and a three-car garage round out the property, which last sold for $1 million in 2022.
Lauren Masur of Berkshire Hathaway Home was the listing agent, giving the brokerage its second listing in this week’s Top 5, and Robbin Edwards of Encore Sotheby’s International represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
RealtyWire selected these transactions from publicly reported residential sales identified for the calendar week ending Sunday, October 4, 2026. The report may exclude private, off-market, delayed or nondisclosed transactions. Prices, property details and professional representation are reported as available at publication and may be updated following confirmation from transaction participants.
Were you involved in one of these transactions? Contact RealtyWire to verify or correct your professional credit or submit information for a future edition.
See full market data on our Indianapolis, Indiana market page.
