These were the five highest-priced home sales reported in the Columbus-Seymour Area, Indiana for the week ending November 8, 2026, and together they came to $1.9 million. Three of the homes are in Columbus, in Bartholomew County, with one each in Seymour in Jackson County and Westport in Jennings County.
The group spans seven decades of building, from a 1955 mid-century ranch to a new-construction home with a 2026 year built. Four of the five homes have four bedrooms, and the land under them ranges from 10,018 square feet to 3.13 acres.
No. 1 — $420,000 · 314 Flatrock Dr, Columbus, Indiana
The oldest home in this week’s ranking is also the one at the top. Built in 1955 in the Noblitt Falls neighborhood of Columbus, the brick and redwood ranch sits on a wooded 0.40-acre lot with frontage on the river, and it sold for $420,000. Downtown Columbus is within walking distance.
Much of the original mid-century character survives, including many of the period fixtures and architectural details. Across the back of the home, walls of windows look out on the trees and the water. The great room is the centerpiece, with redwood ceilings, built-in bookshelves and a fireplace set into a brick wall; the home has two fireplaces in all. A second living area opens to the eat-in kitchen, and a wall of built-in cabinetry sits just off the kitchen.
The home has four bedrooms and two full baths and one half bath in 3,049 square feet. The plan splits the bedrooms, with the primary suite, its two closets and its own full bath on one side and the other three bedrooms on the opposite side. A workshop and laundry are on the main level, and a loft upstairs offers room for an office or studio. Outside, a large back patio is surrounded by mature trees, and a walkway leads down to the river for fishing and boating. There is also a two-car attached garage and a storage shed.
The home went under contract 14 days after it was listed. Ryan Ebener of 1 Percent Lists Indiana Real Estate was the listing agent, and Sarah Sanders of the same brokerage represented the buyer. The brokerage also listed the No. 5 home this week.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 2 — $400,000 · 3864 Jonathan Rdg, Columbus, Indiana
The largest home of the week, at 3,104 square feet, is a two-story Craftsman built in 2007 in the Terrace Woods neighborhood of Columbus. It sold for $400,000. The property last sold for $375,275 in 2022.
The home has four bedrooms and two full baths and one half bath, and the space beyond the bedrooms is what sets it apart. There is a formal dining room, a separate den that doubles as a library, and a loft wired for surround sound. The eat-in kitchen and a two-car attached garage round out the plan, and the exterior is vinyl with brick.
Its 10,018-square-foot lot is the smallest of the five, but the fenced backyard makes good use of it. A deck and a concrete patio provide places to sit outside, young trees and ornamental grasses add privacy, and raised garden beds and a storage shed fill out the yard. The neighborhood offers convenient access to the south side of Columbus, to shopping and dining, and to Interstate 65.
Deborah Zupancic of Keller Williams Indy Metro Partners was the listing agent. Tara Cardinal of Compass Indiana, LLC represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 3 — $372,610 · 3487 Queens Way, Seymour, Indiana
The newest home in the ranking is a brick ranch in Seymour, a new-construction home with a 2026 year built. It sold for $372,610, its full asking price, and went under contract the same day it was listed.
The single-story home has three bedrooms and two full baths in 2,048 square feet, laid out around an open floor plan with an office. Tray ceilings, a kitchen island with a pantry, a walk-in closet and a double vanity are among its finishes, along with an entrance foyer. The plans call for a covered porch. The 0.34-acre lot is in a subdivision with sidewalks, curbs and street lights, and the home has a two-car attached garage.
Roger Wessel of Berkshire Hathaway Home was on both sides of the sale, as the listing agent and as the agent who represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 4 — $354,000 · 9645 N County Road 75 W, Westport, Indiana
Wyaloosing Creek borders this Westport property, which sits on 3.13 acres at the county line, the most land of any home in this week’s Top 5. The custom-built home dates from 1994 and sold for $354,000.
The two-story home has four bedrooms and three bathrooms in 2,520 square feet, with an open floor plan, generous closet space and a laundry chute. The primary bedroom has a walk-in closet and a bath with a garden tub, a shower and double sinks, and it opens directly onto a screened back patio with a heated hot tub. There is also a covered front porch.
The property also has a custom-built barn that can serve for storage or as a hangout.
The home went under contract 29 days after it was listed. Mikaela Richardson of F.C. Tucker Real Estate Experts was the listing agent, and Michelle Collings of REMAX ONE represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 5 — $350,000 · 4520 Woodcrest Dr, Columbus, Indiana
The backyard is the main event at this 1975 brick ranch on a cul-de-sac in the Heather Heights neighborhood of Columbus. Behind a fence, an in-ground pool is surrounded by room to spread out, with a covered patio and an open patio. The property also has a fire pit. The home sold for $350,000. The property last sold for $193,000 in 2017, nine years ago.
Inside, the single-story home has four bedrooms and two baths in 1,940 square feet. The kitchen has an island, a breakfast bar and a pantry, and it opens to the dining room and to the living room, and there are built-in bookcases. There is a masonry fireplace, and the home has a two-car attached garage on its 0.26-acre lot. A par-3 golf course and Richards Elementary School are both within walking distance.
John Walker of 1 Percent Lists Indiana Real Estate was the listing agent, giving the brokerage two of the five listings in this Top 5, along with the No. 1 sale. Ryan Crissinger of RE/MAX Real Estate Prof represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →