These are the highest-priced home sales reported in Columbus-Seymour Area, Indiana for the week ending October 25, 2026, and together the five sold for $3.28 million. Every one of them is a single-family home in Columbus, in Bartholomew County, and the group runs from a home built in 2017 to one built in 1974.
Two of the five are in the Tipton Lakes area, one on the water and one with an in-ground pool and an outdoor kitchen. The others include a home on more than an acre in Meadows At Otter Creek and a wooded property in Amberley where the same agent was on both sides of the sale.
No. 1 — $807,500 · 2013 Deer Creek Cir, Columbus, Indiana
The top sale of the week, at $807,500, is also the newest home in the group. Built in 2017 in Deer Creek, the two-story, wood-sided home has five bedrooms, more than any other home in this Top 5, with one of them on the main level. It also has the most bathrooms, five in all: four full baths and a half bath.
The home has 4,575 square feet of living space on a 0.30-acre lot. The home has an entrance foyer and high ceilings, and a fireplace warms the great room. The kitchen has an island and a pantry, and there is covered and screened outdoor space as well as a three-car attached garage. The community provides maintenance. The property last sold for $77,000 in 2015, before the current home was built.
Karen Abel of CENTURY 21 Scheetz was the listing agent. Michael Burchyett of Berkshire Hathaway Home represented the buyer, one of two sales in this Top 5 for Burchyett, who also handled both sides of the No. 5 sale.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 2 — $777,000 · 4695 Stonebridge Ct, Columbus, Indiana
Water defines the No. 2 sale, a brick home on the lake in Tipton Lakes – Stonebridge that sold for $777,000. The property has direct access to the water and a private boat dock, and the lake is in view from the home. Behind it, a large deck built with Trex decking has a gazebo for dining outside, and a covered patio opens from the lower level. At the front, the porch was expanded in brick and limestone.
Built in 1996, the home has 4,749 square feet, the most living space of the five, along with four bedrooms and four bathrooms. The great room rises two stories and has a reading nook looking down on it. There is also a formal dining room, and the kitchen opens to a large breakfast room. The upper level has three bedrooms and a home office.
The finished walkout basement adds a recreation room and a guest suite. The home has two fireplaces, one in the family room and one in the basement. The lot measures 0.30 acres, and the garage holds two cars. The property last sold for $520,000 in 2020.
The home went under contract four days after it was listed. Karen Abel of CENTURY 21 Scheetz was the listing agent, giving Abel the listings for both of the week’s two highest-priced sales. Bre Russell of F.C. Tucker Real Estate Experts represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 3 — $594,000 · 5183 Northwood Dr, Columbus, Indiana
In Tipton Lakes – Northlake Woods, the No. 3 sale, at $594,000, is a brick traditional built in 1992 whose backyard is set up for entertaining. A covered porch leads out to an in-ground pool and an outdoor kitchen, all within a fenced yard. The neighborhood has sidewalks, street lights and mature trees, and the community has a park, a playground, tennis courts and trails.
Inside, the home has 4,188 square feet, four bedrooms and three bathrooms. The main level has refinished hardwood floors, a formal living room that can serve as flex space, a dining room and a family room with a fireplace. The kitchen pairs granite countertops with off-white cabinetry and stainless KitchenAid appliances, and has a large pantry. A big laundry room is also on the main level. Upstairs, the primary suite has tray ceilings, a walk-in closet and a bath with split vanities, a jetted garden tub and a separate shower. The basement is partially finished, and there is a three-car attached garage on the 0.32-acre lot.
The property last sold for $514,000 in 2023. Jes Waller of F.C. Tucker Real Estate Experts was the listing agent, and Christopher Braun of RE/MAX Real Estate Prof represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 4 — $555,000 · 13010 E Otter Creek Ln, Columbus, Indiana
The No. 4 sale brought the most land of the week: 1.41 acres in Meadows At Otter Creek, minutes from Otter Creek Golf Course, where a home built in 2001 sold for $555,000. A long driveway leads to the home and its three-car attached garage, and the backyard is fenced. The home also has a deck, and the neighborhood has no homeowners association.
The home, finished in vinyl and brick, has four bedrooms, four bathrooms and 4,484 square feet of living space. The eat-in kitchen has granite countertops and stainless steel appliances. A 1,472-square-foot unfinished basement with daylight windows, egress windows and ceilings of nine feet or more is roughed in for future finishing. The property last sold for $42,000 in 2001.
The home went under contract 15 days after it was listed. Trish Meier of eXp Realty, LLC was the listing agent, and Bethany Rust of Real Broker, LLC represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 5 — $550,000 · 4623 E Windsor Ln, Columbus, Indiana
The oldest home in this Top 5 is a 1974 Tudor in Amberley, a wooded subdivision just beyond the city limits, which sold for $550,000. It sits on 1.11 acres of mature trees with views into the woods.
The home has been renovated around a combined kitchen and great room with two islands, quartz counters, a six-burner gas cooktop, wine and beverage refrigerators and a walk-in pantry. The home has hardwood floors and two wood-burning fireplaces, one in the family room and one in the primary bedroom. A loft and a bonus room that could serve as an office or a gym add space beyond the three bedrooms. The home has three bathrooms and 3,172 square feet.
Outdoor living centers on a large screened porch with a heated swim spa, and a second screened porch adds more room outside. The attached garage has a workshop area, and a detached garage stands separately. The property last sold for $529,000 in 2025.
The home went under contract 12 days after it was listed and sold at its full asking price of $550,000. Michael Burchyett of Berkshire Hathaway Home was on both sides of the sale, as listing agent and buyer’s agent, the second sale in this Top 5 for Burchyett, who also represented the buyer of the week’s top sale in Deer Creek.
See this property in Google Street View →
RealtyWire selected these transactions from publicly reported residential sales identified for the calendar week ending Sunday, October 25, 2026. The report may exclude private, off-market, delayed or nondisclosed transactions. Prices, property details and professional representation are reported as available at publication and may be updated following confirmation from transaction participants.
Were you involved in one of these transactions? Contact RealtyWire to verify or correct your professional credit or submit information for a future edition.
