These are the highest-priced home sales reported in Carmel-Fishers & Hamilton County, Indiana for the week ending November 1, 2026, and together the five sold for a combined $7.56 million. Two of the homes are in Westfield, two are in Noblesville and one is in Fishers.
Water and golf run through the list. Two of the homes have docks on reservoirs, two sit in golf communities, and one was newly built this year. The group spans five decades, from a remodeled 1970s lake home to new construction, and three of the five are single-story homes.
No. 1 — $1,810,000 · 16450 Vintage Ct S, Westfield, Indiana
The top sale of the week is a Craftsman-style home in Brookside, in Westfield, which sold for $1,810,000. Built in 2016 by Wedgewood, the single-story home is finished outside in brick with cement and shingle siding, and it has 6,152 square feet of living space across its main level and a full walk-out basement.
The great room is the centerpiece of the main floor, measuring 21 by 27 feet under ceilings that rise past 15 feet, with a gas fireplace set into custom built-ins and solid-oak hardwood underfoot. The kitchen has a center island and a walk-in pantry, and the main level also includes a dining area, a mudroom and three of the home’s five bedrooms: the primary suite and two more bedroom suites. The home has five bathrooms, four full and one half.
The finished basement has ceilings over nine feet and room for a family room, a recreation room, an exercise room, a wet bar and additional bedroom space. Outside, there is a heated in-ground pool, a heated spa, a deck, a patio and a covered lanai built with IPE Brazilian hardwood. The lot, at 0.58 acres, is the largest in this Top 5, and the attached four-car garage is the biggest as well. The listing puts The Bridgewater Club a short golf cart ride away.
The home went under contract on the day it was listed and sold above its asking price. Scott Hackman of CENTURY 21 Scheetz was the listing agent, and Mary Petruzzi of REMAX ONE represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 2 — $1,555,000 · 10761 Harbor Bay Dr, Fishers, Indiana
In Canal Place, on Geist Reservoir in Fishers, a custom-built ranch sold for $1,555,000. The 2005 home, finished in brick and stucco, sits on a 0.57-acre waterfront lot with a floating dock, a boat slip and a heated in-ground pool.
On the main level, the kitchen has an oversized granite island, double ovens and a walk-in pantry, and it looks out over a great room with an atrium ceiling, a fireplace and custom built-ins. A three-season room adds more space on the same floor. The primary suite has a bath with a jetted tub, two vanities and a walk-in shower with two shower heads, and its oversized closet has custom built-ins and a rolling ladder that reaches extra storage above.
The finished walk-out basement is built for entertaining, with a custom bar, a theater room and a workout room, plus two bedrooms joined by a Jack-and-Jill bath. In all, the home has five bedrooms and five bathrooms, four full and one half, in 5,564 square feet. A deck off the main level overlooks the pool and the water, and there is an outdoor wood-burning fireplace. The three-car garage is finished with built-in cabinetry and storage lockers.
The home went under contract six days after it was listed. Timothy Bennett of 1 Percent Lists Indiana Real Estate was the listing agent, and Lindsay Ohmer of CENTURY 21 Scheetz represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 3 — $1,545,730 · 706 Chatham Hills Ct, Westfield, Indiana
The newest home in this Top 5 is a custom ranch by Foxlane Homes, built in 2026 in Chatham Hills, the golf community in Westfield. It sold for $1,545,730. The community has a golf course, a clubhouse, a fitness center, a pool and tennis and basketball courts.
Brick, stone and cement siding wrap the exterior, and the open main level is arranged around the kitchen, which has Amish-crafted cabinetry, commercial-grade appliances, an oversized island and a working pantry. The dining room next to it rises to a vaulted ceiling. The great room has a gas fireplace and opens onto a covered patio with a built-in outdoor kitchen. Beamed ceilings top the primary suite, whose bath has a freestanding soaking tub and a zero-threshold shower, and a second main-level bedroom with its own bath can serve guests or work as a study.
The finished lower level adds a recreation room, a wet bar, a media area and two more bedrooms that share a full bath, with a large unfinished area left for storage or future rooms. The home has four bedrooms and four bathrooms, three full and one half, in 4,385 square feet on a 0.40-acre lot, along with a three-car courtyard garage. It went under contract 12 days after it was listed. Andrea Kelly of Encore Sotheby’s International was the listing agent.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 4 — $1,376,000 · 16437 Shore Oaks Ct, Noblesville, Indiana
In Sagamore, in Noblesville, a two-story home on a cul-de-sac sold for $1,376,000. The property is on the golf course along the 11th fairway and fronts a lake, and the home has views of the water. Built in 2006 in a rustic traditional style of brick and stone, it has 6,656 square feet and six bedrooms, making it the largest home in this group and the one with the most bedrooms.
The kitchen opens to a two-story great room, where a gas fireplace is framed by custom built-ins and a wall of windows looks out to the course and the lake. Cooks get a Wolf gas range, double ovens, a Sub-Zero refrigerator, stone counters, an oversized island and a walk-in pantry. Also on the main floor are an office with a custom wood-beam ceiling and a guest suite with its own bath, and a Trex deck extends the living space outdoors.
Upstairs are the primary suite, with a large walk-in shower and two vanities, and three more bedrooms. The finished daylight lower level has a custom bar, a game room, a fitness room, a sixth bedroom with its own bath and a theater lounge with a four-screen entertainment system. The home has five bathrooms, four full and one half, and an attached three-car side-load garage on a 0.35-acre lot. The property last sold for $1.15 million in 2022.
Kaitlyn Barnes of Compass Indiana, LLC and Nicholas Laviolette of Compass Indiana, LLC were the listing agents, and Katherine James of Berkshire Hathaway Home represented the buyer. Compass Indiana, LLC was the listing brokerage on two sales in this Top 5, this one and the No. 5 sale.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 5 — $1,270,000 · 1224 Willow Way, Noblesville, Indiana
The oldest home in the group dates to 1976, and it has since been completely remodeled. It sits on Morse Reservoir in South Harbour, in Noblesville, and sold for $1,270,000. The fenced backyard runs to 68 feet of water frontage and a private dock, and the listing places the shoreline just inside the idle zone, where calmer water suits swimming, kayaking and paddle boarding.
Inside, the open main floor has hardwood throughout, and the remodeled kitchen pairs granite counters and custom cabinetry with a Sub-Zero refrigerator and a Bosch gas range. The home has five bedrooms, two of them primary suites, and the fifth bedroom is oversized, with its own staircase and full bath, so it can work as an in-law suite, an office or a bonus room. There are five bathrooms, three full and two half, in 4,272 square feet, and the walk-out lower level is finished.
For time by the water there is a covered porch, a Trex deck and a broad hardscape patio. The two-car garage has Gladiator slatwall storage and a Tesla EV charger, and the South Harbour community offers beach access, a clubhouse, a pool, a park and tennis courts. The property last sold for $575,000 in 2018.
Andy Sheets of Compass Indiana, LLC was the listing agent, making this the second sale in this Top 5 listed through that brokerage. Stacey Smith of F.C. Tucker Company represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
RealtyWire selected these transactions from publicly reported residential sales identified for the calendar week ending Sunday, November 1, 2026. The report may exclude private, off-market, delayed or nondisclosed transactions. Prices, property details and professional representation are reported as available at publication and may be updated following confirmation from transaction participants.
Were you involved in one of these transactions? Contact RealtyWire to verify or correct your professional credit or submit information for a future edition.
