These were the five highest-priced home sales reported in the Youngstown-Warren metro area for the week ending October 11, 2026, and together they came to $3.8 million. Four of the homes are in Mahoning County and one is in Trumbull County. The group runs from a lakefront property to two one-story ranches and a pair of two-story colonials, and the homes span more than three decades of building, from a 1991 ranch to a home finished in 2025.
No. 1 — $1,545,000 · 1408 NE River Rd, Lake Milton, Ohio
The shoreline is the point of 1408 NE River Road. The home sits on the water at Lake Milton, on a lot of 0.66 acres, and it looks west across a lake that measures more than a mile from one shore to the other. A private dock with a boat lift sits at the water’s edge, so fishing, swimming and an afternoon on a boat start from the property itself.
The two-story home, built in 1997, has four bedrooms, two of them on the main level, and four bathrooms: three full baths and a half bath. It has a fireplace, and the full basement is finished and opens to the outside through a walk-out. There is garage space for five vehicles divided between an attached garage and a detached one. Lake Milton is a state park, and the home is close to its beach, trails and amphitheater, as well as golf and wineries.
The home sold for $1,545,000, the highest price of the week. The property last sold in 2023 for $1.105 million.
Justin R Vayner of Vayner Realty Co. was the listing agent, and Jill E Herock of Burgan Real Estate represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 2 — $639,900 · 4025 Shelly Lynn Dr, New Middletown, Ohio
Built in 2025, the home at 4025 Shelly Lynn Drive in New Middletown is the newest of the week’s five, and it sold for $639,900, its full asking price. It stands in the Carousel Corners development and mixes colonial and Craftsman design: a large dormer breaks the roofline on the second story, and black soffits and gutters set off neutral siding and stone accents. An oversized covered porch runs across the front.
Inside, the foyer rises two stories before opening to a great room with large windows and a gas fireplace. The kitchen is open, with an eating area that leads out to a cement patio in back, and a dining room that can also serve as a flex space sits nearby along with a pantry, a half bath and the laundry. The primary suite is on the first floor, with a tray ceiling, a double vanity, a large tiled shower and a walk-in closet fitted with built-in shelving. Upstairs, two more bedrooms share a full bath and have access to an unfinished bonus room over the garage.
In all, the home has three bedrooms, three bathrooms and 2,250 square feet on a lot of 0.32 acres, with a two-car garage. The full basement has poured concrete walls, studded perimeter walls and plumbing roughed in for a future full bath.
Jenna M Koontz of Howard Hanna was the listing agent. Elizabeth Mutschler of Keller Williams Chervenic Realty represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 3 — $601,000 · 180 Huntington Trl, Cortland, Ohio
At 1.78 acres, the setting of 180 Huntington Trail in Cortland’s Huntington Acres is the largest of the week’s five, and the home is a cedar ranch built in 1991, the oldest in the group. Mature landscaping surrounds it in a private setting. Outdoors there is a covered front porch, a large patio at the back, an outdoor kitchen, a gas grill, a gas fire pit and a shed.
The one-story home has 5,005 square feet, four bedrooms, all on the main level, and five bathrooms, the most of any home in this Top 5: three full baths and two half baths. A foyer opens into a great room where a wall of windows brings in daylight, and both the great room and the family room have fireplaces. The kitchen is built around a big center island and has room for a table, and there is also a formal dining room. The primary suite has an updated bath. The partially finished lower level includes a wine room, and an attached garage holds three cars.
The property last sold in 2019 for $419,000. This time it went under contract nine days after it was listed and sold for $601,000, just above its $600,000 asking price.
Carol Koutsourais of CENTURY 21 Lakeside Realty was the listing agent, and Amy K Floran of EXP Realty, LLC. represented the buyer. CENTURY 21 Lakeside Realty listed two of the week’s Top 5 sales, this one and the No. 5 sale in Canfield.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 4 — $555,000 · 4875 Tree Line Trl, New Middletown, Ohio
Set on a cul-de-sac in New Middletown, 4875 Tree Line Trail is a custom ranch from 2017 with a stone and vinyl exterior and an attached three-car garage. It sold for $555,000. The property last sold in 2023 for $458,500.
The main floor is open, with a living room, a dining area and an eat-in kitchen finished in KraftMaid cabinets and granite counters, centered on a large island with a second sink. Sliding Pella doors with built-in blinds lead to a covered porch at the back and two paver patios, one of them with a fire pit. The backyard is fenced for privacy and has a raised garden bed and a storage shed. The primary suite has a tiled shower and a walk-in closet measuring 8 by 10 feet.
An open staircase goes down to a finished lower level of roughly 60 by 22 feet, with a great room, a granite bar and kitchenette, a game room that came with its pool table, and a full bath with a tiled shower. The home has three bedrooms, three full bathrooms, two fireplaces and 3,280 square feet on a lot of 0.68 acres. The garage has hot and cold water, a utility sink and washable wall panels.
Joseph A Sabatine of Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Stouffer Realty was the listing agent, and Marty Campana of Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Stouffer Realty represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 5 — $455,000 · 279 Jade Cir, Canfield, Ohio
The colonial at 279 Jade Circle in Canfield’s Stone Bridge neighborhood went under contract three days after it was listed and sold for $455,000, its full asking price. The property last sold in 1997 for $213,500, 29 years earlier.
Built in 1993 with a brick and vinyl exterior, the two-story home has four bedrooms, three bathrooms and 2,212 square feet on 0.61 acres, with an attached two-car garage. A foyer with a large closet leads to a formal living room and a dining room. The kitchen has Cambria quartz counters, stainless steel appliances and plenty of pantry storage, and its eating area opens to a family room with a gas fireplace. Upstairs, the primary suite has a walk-in closet and a bath with a garden tub, and each of the other bedrooms also has a walk-in closet.
The backyard is fenced and private, with a wooded view, a deck of about 13.7 by 12 feet with a fabric gazebo, and a shed. A full basement sits below.
Kelly L Restle of CENTURY 21 Lakeside Realty was the listing agent, giving the brokerage its second sale in this Top 5. Audrey Sommers of Howard Hanna represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
RealtyWire selected these transactions from publicly reported residential sales identified for the calendar week ending Sunday, October 11, 2026. The report may exclude private, off-market, delayed or nondisclosed transactions. Prices, property details and professional representation are reported as available at publication and may be updated following confirmation from transaction participants.
Were you involved in one of these transactions? Contact RealtyWire to verify or correct your professional credit or submit information for a future edition.
See full market data on our Youngstown-Warren Metro Area market page.
