Seventy-six feet of level Conesus Lake frontage, ending in a walk-in shale beach, came with the house at 5410 E Lake Rd, the top sale on the week’s Rochester list. Five reported home sales across the Rochester, New York metro area for the week ending September 20, 2026 accounted for $4.77 million.
The list reaches Conesus, Ontario, Pittsford, Hilton and Livonia, one sale in each. Water figures in several of them: lake frontage in Conesus, a waterfront house in Ontario and a lake-view property a minute from the boat launch in Livonia. The Pittsford and Hilton sales turned on land instead, two wooded acres in one case and approximately 40 acres in the other, and the houses behind the group were built as far apart as 1910 and 2025.
No. 1 — $1,300,000 · 5410 E Lake Rd, Conesus, New York
Built in 1910, the Conesus lakehouse sold for $1,300,000 and holds five bedrooms. The sale closed on September 17, 2026. An updated kitchen with solid-surface counters opens onto a combined living and dining room facing the water, and a game room with a bar and an eat-in kitchen extend the entertaining rooms.
Listing materials describe lake views from every room. The first-floor primary suite includes a private sitting room or office with its own exterior door, and three more bedrooms and a full bath occupy the second floor, where the original natural trim and wood ceilings remain.
A deck off the living room and a paver patio with multi-tier entertaining areas and a hot tub step down toward the beach, set among manicured lawns and mature landscaping. An attached two-car garage carries room to add a bunk house or another bedroom, and level exterior access reaches the storage areas.
The closing ranked No. 1 in RealtyWire’s Rochester Metro Area Top 5 for the week, and the property previously changed hands for $995,000 in 2024. Andrew M. Kachaylo of RE/MAX Hometown Choice was the listing agent. RealtyWire’s Rochester-area Top 5 has carried one earlier Kachaylo listing.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 2 — $1,095,000 · 2501 Lake Rd, Ontario, New York
New construction accounts for the No. 2 sale: a waterfront house in Ontario completed in 2025, which closed September 16, 2026 for $1,095,000. Five bedrooms sit within a reported 4,200 square feet, and the house is set back from the road behind 120 feet of frontage. The current residence replaced a 1958 structure that was gutted and substantially enlarged.
Thirty-nine windows turn the interior toward the water. The kitchen is fitted with a 10-foot island, quartzite counters, custom cabinetry, double ovens, a beverage cooler and a large pantry, and the primary suite opens onto the deck beneath a sizable loft. Hewn radiant-heat flooring, a cathedral shiplap ceiling and a stone fireplace run through the main rooms, with an office and library behind glass doors on the first floor.
A full-length deck stretches along the water side of the house, and the lower level is given over to family and guest rooms. The garage has a heated floor and a 10-foot door sized for boat storage, and a shed handles overflow. Systems installed in the rebuild include a three-zone HVAC setup, a metal roof, a new septic system, a 400-amp panel and fiberglass Pella windows.
The sale closed at its full asking price and ranked No. 2 in RealtyWire’s Rochester Metro Area Top 5 for the week. Hollis A. Creek of Howard Hanna was the listing agent. Two earlier listings under that name have appeared in RealtyWire’s Rochester-area Top 5. The property previously changed hands for $281,000 in 2023, before the current residence was completed in 2025.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 3 — $995,000 · 150 Park Rd, Pittsford, New York
A 1979 house on two wooded acres in Pittsford sold for $995,000, closing on September 15, 2026. Four bedrooms are spread across a reported 5,718 square feet, a figure the listing attributes to a floor plan included with the photographs.
Mature trees screen the lot, which sits minutes from the Village of Pittsford, Powder Mills Park and highway access. The great room opens under vaulted ceilings and exposed beams, lit by recently replaced skylights, and the kitchen carries granite counters, a stone backsplash, a large island and a butler’s pantry.
The main floor holds a primary suite with a spa-style bath, a second bedroom with its own full bath and an office, arranged around a central atrium ringed by a sunroom and an indoor grilling and dining room. The finished lower level adds a recreation room, two more bedrooms, another full bath and a workshop, and an oversized three-car garage is attached.
The transaction ranked No. 3 in RealtyWire’s Rochester Metro Area Top 5 for the week, and it went under contract 10 days after the current listing date. Kyle James Borshoff of Tim Borshoff Realty Inc was the listing agent. Christine E. Yager- Halstead of Elysian Homes by Mark Siwiec and Associates represented the buyer. The property previously changed hands for $860,000 in 2022.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 4 — $700,000 · 164 Payne Beach Rd, Hilton, New York
Acreage carried the No. 4 sale. A 2004 ranch house in Hilton changed hands on September 15, 2026 for $700,000, with approximately 40 acres behind it and about 700 feet of road frontage. Four bedrooms occupy a reported 2,447 square feet.
The single-level plan runs open through the main rooms, where large windows look out over the surrounding property. The kitchen is set up with a gas cooktop, double ovens, an oversized pantry and wide counter workspace, and a covered patio runs along the back of the house.
The acreage is laid out for use: trails cross it for hunting, hiking and recreational vehicles, and a stocked pond sits on the property. A pole barn measuring 46 by 64 feet carries 14-foot ceilings and 200-amp electrical service.
The closing ranked No. 4 in RealtyWire’s Rochester Metro Area Top 5 for the week. Philip Pizzingrilli of Tru Agent Real Estate was the listing agent. Tiffany A Williams of Keller Williams Realty Greater Rochester represented the buyer. The property previously changed hands for $32,000 in 1999, before the current residence was completed in 2004.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 5 — $683,000 · 5223 E Lake Rd, Livonia, New York
The September 18, 2026 closing at 5223 E Lake Rd in Livonia completed the week’s five at $683,000. The custom-built house dates to 1967 and holds five bedrooms across a reported 3,699 square feet.
The house overlooks the lake rather than fronting it, a minute from the boat launch and marina. A near-wraparound deck ties the main rooms to the view, and a wall of windows carries it inside. Custom woodwork defines the interior, and the kitchen is fitted with high-end appliances, double ovens, generous prep space and more than one place to eat.
The primary suite runs as its own wing, with a large walk-in closet, a small fireplace and a walk-in shower. Lower-level rooms have a separate entrance suited to guest, in-law or multi-generational use, and an oversized laundry room could serve as a second kitchen area. A four-car garage arrangement with rear access, an oversized driveway, room for boat storage and a generator complete the property.
The sale ranked No. 5 in RealtyWire’s Rochester Metro Area Top 5 for the week, and it went under contract 13 days after the current listing date. Matthew Sharman of Real Broker NY LLC was the listing agent. The property previously changed hands for $238,500 in 2011.
See this property in Google Street View →
RealtyWire selected these transactions from publicly reported residential sales identified for the calendar week ending Sunday, September 20, 2026. The report may exclude private, off-market, delayed or nondisclosed transactions. Prices, property details and professional representation are reported as available at publication and may be updated following confirmation from transaction participants.
Were you involved in one of these transactions? Contact RealtyWire to verify or correct your professional credit or submit information for a future edition.
See full market data on our Rochester, New York market page.
