The four-bedroom house at 1685 Bahns Mill Road, built in 2000 and set on 7.56 acres in the Red Lion School District, changed hands on September 16, 2026 for $950,000, the highest price among five home sales reported across the York, Pennsylvania metro area for the week ending September 20, 2026. The five closings together accounted for $4.05 million.
Four municipalities are represented on the list. Lewisberry accounted for two of the closings, with single sales recorded in Windsor, Hanover and York. Two of the homes carry named community identities, Olde Forge Estates in Lewisberry and Hepplewhite Estates in York, while the remaining three are identified only by their street addresses and school districts.
No. 1 — $950,000 · 1685 Bahns Mill Rd, Windsor, Pennsylvania
The week’s highest reported price went to a country property in Windsor, where a four-bedroom house on 7.56 acres sold for $950,000. Built in 2000 and carrying a reported 6,310 square feet, the residence closed on September 16, 2026 and sits within the Red Lion School District.
An open layout runs under cathedral ceilings, with hardwood floors through the main level, fresh paint and new carpet. The kitchen is fitted with double ovens and a built-in wine refrigerator and opens directly to the dining area, and a sunroom floored in brick adjoins the rear deck. The primary suite has its own fireplace, a walk-in closet and direct deck access, with an en-suite bath; additional bedrooms have attached bath access, and a loft overlooks the main level. The walk-out lower level adds a wet bar, a wine room, a full bathroom and a fourth bedroom.
Outdoors, the property holds a 16-by-40-foot heated saltwater pool, an in-ground hot tub, a permanent grilling area, custom Key West-style swings and a combined wood-fired pool heater and pizza oven. A 41-by-90-foot pole barn with three bay doors and 200-amp service stands alongside a three-acre fenced pasture suited to horses or livestock and a chicken coop area with an automatic egg layer, and there is room to park a livestock trailer. A circular driveway gives pull-through access to the improved three-car attached garage. The property previously changed hands for $270,000 in 2015.
The sale was the highest-priced reported in the York metro area for the week, ranking No. 1 in RealtyWire’s Top 5. Erin Aspito of Keller Williams Keystone Realty was the listing agent. Adam McCallister of EXP Realty, LLC represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 2 — $827,500 · 804 Stonybrook Ln, Lewisberry, Pennsylvania
Second on the list is 804 Stonybrook Lane in Lewisberry, a 2004 house on a landscaped acre that sold for $827,500, closing $27,500 above its final asking price of $800,000. The transaction was recorded on September 16, 2026. The four-bedroom home carries a reported 4,444 square feet, with three full and three half bathrooms.
High ceilings and a stone-wrapped gas fireplace anchor the main gathering space, which also holds upgraded appliances and a bar with an ice maker. The formal dining room is finished with Brazilian cherry floors and detailed woodwork. A dedicated home office and walk-in closets sit on the main floor, and the lower level is given over to a custom oak bar, a movie area and open room for games and hobbies.
The grounds carry a large in-ground pool served by an outdoor shower and a half bath housed in the detached garage. That garage has epoxy floors and room for multiple vehicles, a boat, a workshop or a golf simulator, along with a second level suited to a fitness room and a secure, temperature-controlled hobby room. A three-car attached garage serves the house itself. The property previously changed hands for $572,500 in 2020.
The house went under contract 3 days after the current listing date, and the sale took the No. 2 position on the week’s York-area list. Barb Conklin of Coldwell Banker Realty was the listing agent. Brittany Rivera of Coldwell Banker Realty represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 3 — $810,000 · 1189 Westminster Ave, Hanover, Pennsylvania
A custom farmhouse-style house at 1189 Westminster Avenue, in the southern part of Hanover, took third place at $810,000. Settlement was recorded on September 18, 2026. The transaction record lists four bedrooms, three bathrooms and a reported 2,250 square feet.
The plan centers on an open great room with custom wood beams, tall windows and a stone fireplace, with a dining area alongside and a kitchen fitted with upper-tier appliances, cabinetry and generous counter space. The owner’s suite has a tray ceiling, a walk-in closet and an attached bath with a soaking tub and a separate rain shower. An office, two further bedrooms and a loft bedroom round out the same level.
A deck and a landscaped yard sit at the rear of the house, and listing materials identify golf course views from the site.
The closing placed third among the week’s reported sales in the metro area. Tim Forbes of Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Homesale Realty was the listing agent.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 4 — $767,500 · 105 Bellows Ct, Lewisberry, Pennsylvania
In Olde Forge Estates, a custom ranch house built in 2008 at 105 Bellows Court in Lewisberry sold for $767,500, closing $56,500 above its final asking price of $711,000. The deal settled on September 14, 2026. The record lists three bedrooms, three bathrooms and a reported 4,082 square feet on 2.17 acres.
A brick facade, covered porches, hardscaping and designed gardens front the house. Inside are site-finished hardwood floors, intricate millwork, triple crown molding, floor-to-ceiling windows and custom-milled fireplace mantles. The kitchen is appointed with natural cherry cabinetry, quartz countertops and GE Monogram appliances. The house has two owner’s suites, each with a renovated spa-inspired bath and heated tile floors, and a third bedroom can be taken on the main level or in the lower level, which also holds a custom cherry bar, a media lounge, a fireplace, a workshop and guest accommodations opening to covered outdoor rooms.
Much of the property’s detail is outdoors. The 2.17 acres have been cultivated over many years into winding stone walkways, hidden garden rooms, a pergola for al fresco dining, fountains, architectural lighting and an armillary garden enclosed by wrought-iron fencing. The gardens are recognized as a Certified Wildlife Habitat, a Monarch Waystation and a Pollinator Friendly Garden, and take part in the Homegrown National Park movement. The site is minutes from Routes 15 and I-83 and roughly twenty minutes from Harrisburg International Airport. The property previously changed hands for $585,000 in 2019.
The house went under contract 5 days after the current listing date, and the closing came in fourth for the week in the metro area. Jennifer Hollister of Joy Daniels Real Estate Group, Ltd was the listing agent. Dottie Bernatos of Coldwell Banker Realty represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 5 — $694,000 · 2579 Hepplewhite Dr, York, Pennsylvania
The fifth sale, at $694,000, brought a 2021 custom home at 2579 Hepplewhite Drive in Hepplewhite Estates to settlement on September 18, 2026. The five-bedroom house sits in the Central York School District, backs onto open farmland and carries a reported 3,251 square feet with four bathrooms. It closed $4,100 above its final asking price of $689,900.
The main level runs between a living room with a gas fireplace, the dining area and a kitchen with textured quartz countertops, a center island, stainless steel appliances and a butler’s pantry. Two flexible rooms sit off that space, one of them fitted with built-ins, a tray ceiling and crown molding. Upstairs, the primary suite has two closets and an attached bath, joined by three further bedrooms, a Jack and Jill bath, a guest bath and the laundry room.
A patio at the rear looks out over the surrounding countryside, and the neighborhood sits minutes from Outdoor Country Club. The property previously changed hands for $675,000 in 2022.
The house went under contract 3 days after the current listing date. Adam Flinchbaugh of Keller Williams Keystone Realty was the listing agent. Flinchbaugh has appeared in three earlier RealtyWire Top 5 roundups for the York metro area, and Keller Williams Keystone Realty held the listing side of two of this week’s five highest-priced reported sales. Shane Laucks of Inch & Co. Real Estate, LLC represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
RealtyWire selected these transactions from publicly reported residential sales identified for the calendar week ending Sunday, September 20, 2026. The report may exclude private, off-market, delayed or nondisclosed transactions. Prices, property details and professional representation are reported as available at publication and may be updated following confirmation from transaction participants.
Were you involved in one of these transactions? Contact RealtyWire to verify or correct your professional credit or submit information for a future edition.
See full market data on our York, Pennsylvania market page.
