These are the highest-priced home sales reported in the Lake Erie Shores & Islands Area, Ohio for the week ending November 8, 2026, and together they came to $5.21 million. Three of the five are in Ottawa County and two are in Erie County, each in a different community, from an island village in the lake to a subdivision in Curtice and established streets in Huron and Sandusky.
All five are single-family homes. The oldest was built in 1969 and the newest in 2017, and the group runs from a three-bedroom home on several acres to a six-bedroom home on the water.
No. 1 — $2,645,000 · 4555 E Forest Glen Ln, Lakeside Marblehead, Ohio
The week’s top sale is on Johnson’s Island in Lakeside Marblehead, inside Baycliffs, a gated island community reached by causeway that opens directly onto Sandusky Bay and Lake Erie. The home sold for $2.645 million. It stands on a 0.35-acre quarry lot with deep-water dockage, and its private 50-foot dock is a short walk from a broad patio with views across the water.
The saltwater pool is heated and built for swimming laps. A glass front gives it the look of an infinity edge above the quarry, and it has a rock waterfall, lighting for evenings and a swim-up bar under a tiki top.
Built in 2008, the home has six bedrooms, four bathrooms and 4,847 square feet of living space, the most bedrooms and the largest living area in this group. Its open plan is organized around a vaulted great room with tinted glass walls, and the kitchen has granite counters and a breakfast bar. The primary suite is on the first floor, with its own balcony on the water side, a walk-in closet and a bath with a custom shower and a jetted tub. Downstairs, the walk-out lower level is lined with windows and has a recreation room, a game room, a full bar and a second full kitchen. A geothermal system heats and cools the home. The property last sold for $695,000 in 2017.
The home went under contract seven days after it was listed. Patricia A. Gouker of C21 DEPiero & Assoc. Inc. was the listing agent, and Matthew Adkins of Firelands Association of Realt represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 2 — $875,000 · 48 Concord Ave, Put In Bay, Ohio
In the village of Put In Bay, a cedar-sided home on 2.76 acres sold for $875,000, its full asking price. Built in 1976, the two-story home has three bedrooms, two bathrooms and 2,287 square feet.
The kitchen has been remodeled with granite counters and solid wood cabinets, and wood floors run through most of the rooms. A sunroom and an office add space beyond the bedrooms, and the home has a wood-burning fireplace. Outside there is a front porch and a fenced backyard, along with a large pole barn and a storage shed with room for boats, golf carts and other island gear.
Sonya Niese and James H. Knight, both of Keller Williams Citywide-PC, were the listing agents. Madeline L. Pugh of Century 21 Bolte Real Estate represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 3 — $699,900 · 6137 Old Stone Trl, Curtice, Ohio
The newest home in the group was built in 2017 in Chippewa Reserve, a subdivision in Curtice near the Chippewa Golf Course. The property last sold for $44,000 in 2016, before the current house was built. The traditional home has now sold for $699,900, its full asking price. It is on a cul-de-sac, on a secluded, landscaped lot of 1.93 acres.
Inside, the great room has a fireplace that rises two stories, and the kitchen has a large island with seating for six and a walk-in pantry. The primary suite is on the main floor, with a walk-in closet and a bath with two vanities, a walk-in shower and a soaking tub. Upstairs, two bedrooms share a Jack-and-Jill bathroom with a vanity for each, and a second living area opens off the landing. The finished basement has a recreation area with custom built-ins and a kitchenette, another bedroom and a full bath, and a separate room with an egress window.
In all, the home has four bedrooms, three full baths and a half bath, 2,829 square feet of living space and a three-car garage. Outdoors there is a heated saltwater pool, a custom stone fireplace that burns natural gas, a rear patio and a fire pit.
Lisa Donald of The Danberry Co was the listing agent. Debi Jewell of RE/MAX Preferred Associates represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 4 — $515,000 · 1024 Main St, Huron, Ohio
A center-hall home on Main Street in Huron, built in 1969 and the oldest in this group, went under contract four days after it was listed and sold for $515,000. The property last sold for $237,500 in 2011.
A grand foyer leads into rooms finished with hardwood floors and crown molding. The living room has a bay window, and the formal dining room has a chair rail and a pair of corner cupboards. The kitchen, with white cabinets, adjoins a family room, and the first floor also has a walnut-paneled office, a laundry room and a mudroom. The primary bedroom keeps its original hardwood floors and has two closets and a private bath with double sinks that was redone in 2021.
The two-story home has five bedrooms, three bathrooms and 3,318 square feet, and a large recreation room fills the finished basement. Outside are a screened porch and a workshop with a utility sink and a Bilco door. The landscaped grounds include a garden pond, a waterfall and a patio, and the home has a two-car garage.
Linda J. Armstrong of RE/MAX Quality Realty – Sandus was the listing agent, and Holly Brokaw of Firelands Association of Realt represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 5 — $480,000 · 3903 Deerpath Dr, Sandusky, Ohio
A large open common area lies behind this brick home on Deerpath Drive in Sandusky. Built in 1986 on 0.42 acres, the two-story home has five bedrooms, three full baths and a half bath, and 3,621 square feet of living space.
The main rooms follow an open floor plan, and one bedroom is on the first floor with a full bath. The other bedrooms are upstairs, and the finished lower level adds more living space. A deck extends the living space outdoors, and the home has an attached garage. The property last sold for $282,000 in 2019.
Listed at $475,000, the home went under contract four days later and sold for $480,000, $5,000 above its asking price. Victoria Valle of The Danberry Company was the listing agent, and Patricia Rimboch of BHHS Professional Realty represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →