The estate at 17245 S Mill Creek Road, built in 2001 on 6.74 wooded acres, brought the top price among five reported sales across the Indianapolis, Indiana metro area that combined for $9.33 million for the week ending September 6, 2026.
The week’s sales reach well beyond one corner of the metro: two closed in Noblesville, including one on Morse Reservoir in the Oakbay community, while the others landed in Zionsville, in New Palestine in Hancock County, and on Lamb Lake in Trafalgar’s Lamb Lake Estates. Four of the properties sit on more than an acre of ground, and a Zionsville closing that finished above its final asking price appears at No. 4.
No. 1 — $2,222,000 · 17245 S Mill Creek Rd, Noblesville, Indiana
A long approach through mature trees leads to 17245 S Mill Creek Road in Noblesville, which closed on September 1, 2026, at $2,222,000 β the week’s highest-priced reported sale in the metro. Built in 2001, the six-bedroom home carries a reported 10,856 square feet, with hardwood flooring, expansive windows and a new custom kitchen inside.
The flexible floor plan takes in multiple gathering areas, formal and casual living spaces and dedicated work-from-home rooms, while a billiard room, a theater area, a fitness room and a steam sauna occupy the finished lower level. The primary suite features dual walk-in closets.
The 6.74 wooded acres hold a stocked pond, a private pool with a pool house, an outdoor kitchen, a hot tub, a fire pit and a small pole barn, along with both attached and detached multi-car garages. The property went under contract 17 days after the current listing date and previously changed hands for $1,150,000 in 2020.
The $2,222,000 closing stands at No. 1 in RealtyWire’s Indianapolis Metro Area Top 5 for the week. Derek Gutting and Konnor Gutting of Keller Williams Indpls Metro N were the listing agents. Justin Steill of Berkshire Hathaway Home represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 2 — $1,935,000 · 6837 W 300 S, New Palestine, Indiana
In New Palestine, the 2018-built two-story home at 6837 W 300 S sold for $1,935,000 and went under contract 4 days after the current listing date. The five-bedroom house spans a reported 6,282 square feet with a finished basement, on more than six acres in Hancock County within the New Palestine school district. The sale closed September 4, 2026.
The backyard is organized around a 20-by-44-foot heated pool with a sun shelf, corner benches, a waterslide and an automatic safety cover, joined by an outdoor kitchen and a six-person sauna. The finished basement leaves room for recreation, a home gym, a theater or guest space.
Recent work runs deep: a new shingle roof and new gutters in 2024, a new metal roof, fresh exterior paint and many new windows in 2025, plus a new variable-speed pool pump and a new cartridge filter. The property sits minutes from Indianapolis, Fishers, Geist, Greenfield and McCordsville, with quick access to I-465 and I-70.
The $1,935,000 closing was the week’s No. 2 reported sale in the metro. Sean Daniels of Daniels Real Estate was the listing agent. This is Daniels’ second appearance in a RealtyWire Top 5 roundup for the metro. Fred Nelson of Century 21 Scheetz represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 3 — $1,800,000 · 7540 S Susan Ln, Trafalgar, Indiana
The 1.48-acre waterfront property at 7540 S Susan Ln, in the Lamb Lake Estates community in Trafalgar, sold for $1,800,000 on September 4, 2026. With more than 400 feet of shoreline on Lamb Lake, the all-brick residence pairs a covered front porch with a reported 5,748 square feet across a main level and a finished walkout lower level.
A double-sided fireplace joins the living room to an adjoining den and library, and the eat-in kitchen flows to a lakeside porch. The main-level primary suite offers deck access, a walk-in closet, dual vanities, a jetted soaking tub and a separate tiled shower; two more main-level bedrooms share a Jack-and-Jill bath, and the walkout level holds a family room, a fourth bedroom, a fitness area and an equipment garage.
Outside, a full-length composite deck with a gazebo and a covered lower-level patio overlook a gently sloping yard that runs to a private dock tucked into a calm cove, and garage space totals an attached two-car and a detached three-car. The 1990-built home went under contract 16 days after the current listing date and previously changed hands for $659,000 in 2006.
The lakefront closing took the No. 3 position in this week’s RealtyWire Indianapolis Metro Area Top 5. Daniel Frische of Smythe & Co, Inc was the listing agent.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 4 — $1,768,750 · 8905 Whitestown Rd, Zionsville, Indiana
A 2020-built custom home on 4.58 private acres at 8905 Whitestown Rd in Zionsville closed August 31, 2026, at $1,768,750. The property went under contract 2 days after the current listing date and closed $78,750 above its final asking price of $1,690,000.
The five-bedroom house, with a reported 6,376 square feet, opens through a wraparound porch into a two-story entry and a living room with 22-foot ceilings, expansive windows and hardwood floors across the main living areas. The kitchen centers on a large island beside a walk-in pantry, and the main-level primary suite includes a walk-in closet with its own washer and dryer. Upstairs sit four bedrooms, a loft, a dedicated office, a second laundry room and two separate staircases.
A finished lower level is pre-plumbed for a future wet bar, and the grounds hold a saltwater pool and a fire pit, with views across neighboring properties just minutes from downtown Zionsville. The home lies within the Zionsville Community Schools district.
The above-asking result earned the No. 4 position in the week’s RealtyWire Top 5 for the Indianapolis metro. Katie Childress and Nathan Childress of Ever Real Estate, LLC were the listing agents. Courtney Walsh of eXp Realty, LLC represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 5 — $1,600,000 · 7270 Oak Cove Ln, Noblesville, Indiana
On the main body of Morse Reservoir, the home at 7270 Oak Cove Ln in Noblesville’s Oakbay community closed September 4, 2026, at $1,600,000. Built in 1991 and held by its original owner since, the five-bedroom house carries a reported 5,782 square feet on a 0.4-acre lot, with a paver walkway leading down to a private dock.
The main-floor owner’s suite frames lake views, opens to the deck and includes a custom closet, while the great room pairs its own water views with a gas fireplace. Two upstairs bedrooms each have a full bath, and the walkout basement adds a family room with a second gas fireplace, two more bedrooms, a bonus room and generous storage. A screened porch, deck and paver patio overlook professionally maintained grounds planted with hydrangeas, lilies and mature trees, and a four-car garage completes the property, which sits within Noblesville Schools.
The Morse Reservoir sale rounds out the week’s RealtyWire Indianapolis Metro Area Top 5 at No. 5. Rachel Quade of F.C. Tucker Company was the listing agent. Jane Wells of F.C. Tucker Company represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
RealtyWire selected these transactions from publicly reported residential sales identified for the calendar week ending Sunday, September 6, 2026. The report may exclude private, off-market, delayed or nondisclosed transactions. Prices, property details and professional representation are reported as available at publication and may be updated following confirmation from transaction participants.
Were you involved in one of these transactions? Contact RealtyWire to verify or correct your professional credit or submit information for a future edition.
See full market data on our Indianapolis, Indiana market page.
