The five highest-priced home sales reported in Indianapolis Area, Indiana for the week ending October 25, 2026, totaled $6.96 million. All five homes are in Indianapolis, and they span more than a century, from a Victorian built in 1900 to a waterfront ranch built in 2004. Only $15,000 separated the top two sales, and the third- and fourth-ranked homes sold for the same $950,000.
No. 1 — $2,100,000 · 7440 N Illinois St, Indianapolis, Indiana
The Meridian Hills home that led the week was built in 1940 and has been expanded and reworked over the past five decades, with help from designers both local and national. Some of the changes were small, such as walnut trim in place of oak and newer, more contemporary light fixtures. Others reshaped the home: the footprint grew, and the screened porch was moved to the rear.
The kitchen, renovated recently, was designed by Fu Tung Cheng of Cheng Design. A skylight brings daylight into the room, which has a Gaggenau gas range, an integrated Sub-Zero refrigerator and countertops of concrete and stainless steel, and a passthrough opens it to the great room. That great room, at the back of the home, has a vaulted ceiling and a bronze fireplace. The rear of the home also has a sunken family room with space for a pool table and a home theater. What was once the formal living room is now a library, with large windows looking out over the front grounds.
The brick home has five bedrooms, four of them on the main level, along with four bathrooms and 6,885 square feet of living space. The primary suite includes a private office, a sitting and dressing area and a custom closet, and its bath has a steam shower, a garden tub and heated tile floors. There is also a sauna. The grounds cover 1.16 acres, the largest lot in this week’s Top 5, with mature trees, a patio and a fountain, and the landscape is the work of the father-daughter team of Frits Loonsten and Suzie Reese.
The home went under contract 13 days after it was listed and sold at its full asking price of $2,100,000. Matt McLaughlin of F.C. Tucker Company was the listing agent, and Mary Wernke of Encore Sotheby’s International represented the buyer. F.C. Tucker Company also listed the No. 3 sale this week.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 2 — $2,085,000 · 8811 Spinnaker Ct, Indianapolis, Indiana
The No. 2 sale is a waterfront ranch on the main body of Geist Reservoir, set on a cul-de-sac in Masthead. Built in 2004, it is the newest home in this week’s group, and at 7,634 square feet it is also the largest. The main living space sits on one floor, with two finished walkout lower levels beneath it.
Large windows look out on the water from room after room. On the main level, a hearth room adjoins the kitchen, and there are a great room, a dining room and an office. The primary suite is on this level too, with a sitting area, a private balcony, a spa-style bath and a California Closet.
The first lower level has a bar, a recreation area and four more bedrooms, one of them a suite with its own sauna and steam shower. The second has a theater room and another bar. In all, the home has five bedrooms, 10 bathrooms, five fireplaces and a four-car garage, the most bathrooms and garage spaces among the five sales.
Covered patios and decks face the reservoir. The outdoor spaces include an in-ground pool with a broad pool deck, a heated hot tub, a gas fire pit and an outdoor bar. At the water’s edge are a seawall and a private boat dock, and the property also has a boat garage.
The home sold for $2,085,000. Jeff Kucic of Engel & Volkers was the listing agent.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 3 — $950,000 · 1928 N Delaware St, Indianapolis, Indiana
The oldest home in this week’s Top 5 is a Victorian built in 1900 in the Herron-Morton Place Historic District. The wood-sided home has a white picket fence and a broad covered front porch, and it has been completely renovated while keeping its original hardwood floors, along with pocket doors, natural woodwork and three fireplaces. A curved stained-glass window sits along the main staircase, and a second staircase serves the home as well.
The main floor has formal living, family and dining rooms. In the kitchen, Victorian-style cabinetry is paired with soapstone counters, the original butler’s pantry remains, and a third seating area adjoins the room. An enclosed back porch is also on the first floor. The second floor has four bedrooms, two of them primary suites, as well as two renovated bathrooms and another enclosed porch. On the third floor, under high ceilings, are a game room with a kitchenette, the fifth bedroom and a full bath.
The home has 6,156 square feet of living space. It still uses boiler-and-radiator heat and also has two HVAC systems. Outside there is a brick patio with mature landscaping, and the three-car garage is detached. The property last sold for $575,000 in 2015.
It went under contract seven days after it was listed and sold for $950,000. Rob Measel and Amanda Hadley, both of F.C. Tucker Company, were the listing agents, and Kristi Gaynor, also of F.C. Tucker Company, represented the buyer. With the No. 1 sale, it was one of two homes in this week’s Top 5 listed by F.C. Tucker Company.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 4 — $950,000 · 9451 Timber Crest Ln, Indianapolis, Indiana
Tied with the Morton Place Victorian at $950,000, the No. 4 sale is a brick ranch built in 2001 in Timberline. It sits on a cul-de-sac, on a 0.41-acre lot with mature trees, and the neighborhood has a pool, a park and a playground. The property last sold for $570,000 in 2014.
The owners remodeled the kitchen and every bathroom, along with the flooring, lighting and trim. The main level has high ceilings and floor-to-ceiling windows, and it includes a kitchen with a breakfast nook, a hearth room with custom built-ins, a sun room, a dining room, a sitting room and an office. The primary suite has deck access, a custom closet and a bath with heated floors, and a guest suite on the same level has its own bath.
Of the home’s three fireplaces, one is in the primary bedroom and another is in the hearth room. The walkout lower level has nine-foot ceilings, a family room, a wet bar and the remaining two bedrooms, each with its own full bath. In all, the home has four bedrooms, five bathrooms and 5,642 square feet of living space, with a three-car attached garage.
A contract came seven days after the home was listed. Allen Williams of Berkshire Hathaway Home listed the home and also represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 5 — $875,000 · 5315 N Pennsylvania St, Indianapolis, Indiana
A large oak tree stands over the No. 5 sale, a brick home in Ambleside built in 1929 and a short walk from 49th and Penn. It has four bedrooms, three bathrooms and 3,167 square feet on two stories, on an 8,712-square-foot lot. Inside, its period details have been kept, including hardwood floors, built-ins and a fireplace in the living room. The kitchen has been updated in white, the closets were professionally fitted, and the interior was freshly painted. Beyond the main rooms are a separate family room and a partly finished lower level with another bathroom. Outside are a patio and a detached two-car garage. The property last sold for $824,900 in 2024.
Listed by Joe Everhart and Quinn Demaree of Everhart Studio, Ltd., the home went under contract three days after it came on the market and sold at its full asking price of $875,000. Susan Martello of eXp Realty, LLC represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
RealtyWire selected these transactions from publicly reported residential sales identified for the calendar week ending Sunday, October 25, 2026. The report may exclude private, off-market, delayed or nondisclosed transactions. Prices, property details and professional representation are reported as available at publication and may be updated following confirmation from transaction participants.
Were you involved in one of these transactions? Contact RealtyWire to verify or correct your professional credit or submit information for a future edition.
