Market Datavs. 1 year ago
30-year mortgage7.11%▲ +0.87 pts15-year mortgage6.45%▲ +0.96 pts10-year Treasury5.10%▲ +1.02 ptsMortgage spread2.01 pts▼ -0.15 ptsMedian list price (Oct)$415k▼ -2.2%List $/sqft (Oct)$222▼ -1.3%Days on market (Oct)63 +0 daysActive listings (Oct)1.18M▲ +7.4%New listings (Oct)357k▼ -7.5%Pending sales (Oct)381k▼ -10.7%Housing starts (Sep)1.22M▼ -7.4%Building permits (Sep)1.4M▼ -3.2%New-home sales (Sep)676k▼ -5.3%Existing-home sales (Oct)3.75M▼ -8.8%Months of supply (Sep)8.4▲ +0.2 moMortgage delinquency (Q2)1.86%▲ +0.08 pts
Updated 8:40 AM ET
Housing Market

Activist Land & Buildings Presses Invitation Homes to Sell Houses One at a Time and Return $2 Billion a Year

Jonathan Litt's fund says the largest single-family landlord's homes trade at a roughly 40% discount and wants home-sale proceeds returned to shareholders.

Activist Land & Buildings Presses Invitation Homes to Sell Houses One at a Time and Return $2 Billion a Year

Land & Buildings Investment Management, the Stamford, Conn., activist fund run by Jonathan Litt, went public on Nov. 16, 2026, with a campaign against Invitation Homes (NYSE: INVH), the country’s largest owner of single-family rental homes. In an open letter to Invitation Homes shareholders, the fund calls on the board to commit to returning at least $2 billion of capital to shareholders every year. That money would come from selling houses one at a time to individual buyers for as long as the stock trades below what the fund thinks the homes are worth.

The letter adds that Land & Buildings “will not hesitate to take whatever steps we believe are necessary to maximize value.” It does not disclose the size of the fund’s stake.

The discount at the center of the Invitation Homes fight

Land & Buildings’ case starts with a simple comparison. Since last December, according to the letter, Invitation Homes has sold homes at an average price of roughly $460,000. Yet at the current share price, the fund argues, the public market values each home the company still owns at about $270,000, a discount of roughly 40%.

The fund says it valued more than 90% of the company’s wholly owned homes individually, “address by address,” and arrived at an average of about $425,000 per home. That supports its net asset value estimate of about $45 per share, after deducting a 6% cost to sell every home. Land & Buildings says that figure is more than 65% above the current share price.

“U.S. single-family homes are the deepest, most liquid and most transparent real estate asset class in the world, so the value of this portfolio is not a matter of opinion,” Litt wrote.

Invitation Homes’ own numbers point the same way. In its third-quarter 2026 results, released Oct. 28, the company said it had bought back nearly $1 billion of stock from Dec. 1, 2025, through Oct. 27, 2026: 36,923,753 shares at an average price of $26.78. The company said that price implied a value of about $280,000 per home, against a gross average sales price of about $460,000 for the homes it sold over the same period. The board authorized another $500 million repurchase program on Oct. 26, which RealtyWire covered with the third-quarter results.

Three demands

The letter makes three recommendations, which Land & Buildings says it has already made privately:

  • Return at least $2 billion a year through buybacks or special dividends, on a leverage-neutral basis, paid for by selling homes individually while the shares trade below net asset value. The fund argues that with nearly $40 billion of gross asset value, the company could keep this up “for many years if necessary.” It also says annual home sales in Invitation Homes’ markets are large enough to absorb a program of that size.
  • Offer tenants a path to ownership through a 6% rebate toward the down payment. The fund says this is roughly what brokerage, repair and vacancy costs would be on an open-market sale, so it would cost the company little or nothing extra.
  • Sharply curtail acquisitions and development. The fund says the 21st Century ROAD to Housing Act and its effects on capital markets “have closed or impaired most avenues for growth in the near-term, some permanently.”

The letter goes further than buybacks. It says the board should state plainly that it will keep selling homes and returning capital for as long as the discount lasts, “even if that ultimately means liquidating the Company.”

A record the fund calls self-inflicted

Land & Buildings says Invitation Homes has trailed the S&P 500, the broader REIT index, its closest peer American Homes 4 Rent and its own compensation peer group over one, three and five years. The fund says shareholders who held the stock for five years have lost more than a fifth of their investment, including dividends. It adds that the shares trade only modestly above their $20 IPO price from early 2017, while national home prices have risen nearly 80% since then.

The fund blames that record on the company’s own choices. It says Invitation Homes was a net buyer of homes every year from 2022 through 2025 despite a poor cost of capital. It also cites more than $79 million the company has paid to resolve four legal matters over its treatment of residents and its business practices, including a $48 million settlement with the Federal Trade Commission in 2024. And it criticizes the board for granting more than $25 million in special retention awards to the CEO and three other executives in March 2026.

The boardroom flashpoint

The letter’s timing follows a board change Land & Buildings plainly dislikes. Invitation Homes announced that M. Colin Connolly, president and CEO of Cousins Properties, would join its board effective Nov. 13, expanding it to 10 members. He will sit on the compensation and the investment and finance committees. “As a sitting REIT CEO, Colin offers deep, practical expertise in capital allocation, real estate investment, and operations,” Invitation Homes CEO Dallas Tanner said in the announcement. Board chair Michael Fascitelli said Connolly “brings a fresh perspective.”

Land & Buildings reads the appointment differently. The letter says board members told the fund just last week that “refreshment was not needed,” and days later added “another sitting REIT chief executive” instead of a director who brings “the shareholder perspective and capital allocation discipline” the fund wants.

Invitation Homes is already moving in the direction the fund wants, just more slowly. In the third quarter it sold 658 wholly owned homes, which it said went mostly to families buying for their own use, and bought 216, using about $245 million in net proceeds to buy back stock. Its guidance calls for $900 million to $1 billion of wholly owned dispositions in 2026. Land & Buildings dismisses this as “half measures,” saying the program is “neither sized nor communicated in a way that will change how investors value the shares.” The fund also notes that management again declined to commit to the size or timing of future capital returns on its third-quarter earnings call.

For scale, on our reading, a $2 billion annual return funded mainly by home sales would mean selling houses at about twice the pace of this year’s disposition guidance. In the markets where Invitation Homes is concentrated, that would mean a steadier flow of former rental houses onto the resale market, many of them likely sold to owner-occupants, as the company says most of its recent sales were. The policy backdrop matters too. The Treasury Department has proposed rules for the 350-home investor ban, and Tanner has said such a ban won’t lower home prices right away.

Invitation Homes is not Land & Buildings’ first public REIT campaign; the fund’s website lists earlier corporate engagements, including with Ventas. The letter says the fund still prefers to work constructively with the company and that “nothing would please us more than for the Company’s own actions to resolve our concerns.”

βœ‰

Stay ahead of the market.

Get expert insights, market updates, and new opportunities delivered to your inbox.

RealtyWire Newsletter Signup
We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe anytime.