These are the five highest-priced home sales reported in the Indianapolis metro area for the week ending October 11, 2026. Together they total $13.71 million, and the top sale finished $1.7 million ahead of the second.
No. 1 — $4,600,000 · 2035 Saint Andrews Cir, Carmel, Indiana
The week’s top sale came from the Crooked Stick Golf Club community in Carmel, where a French Provincial home on the golf course sold for $4,600,000. New Generation Homes built it in 2020 off the second tee box of the Pete Dye championship course. The brick and stone home sits on a 1.20-acre cul-de-sac lot with mature trees, and its 15,419 square feet of living space is the most of any home in this week’s five.
In the living room, beams and coffers finish the high ceilings above a fireplace. The kitchen is set up for entertaining, with handcrafted B&L cabinetry, stone countertops and a custom range hood, along with double ovens and two refrigerators and two dishwashers. Each of the six bedrooms has its own bath, and three half baths bring the total to nine. A Savant smart-home system runs the home, and there is an elevator.
Much of the space is given over to recreation. An athletic wing has a half-court indoor basketball gym, an exercise room and an indoor hockey practice room, and the home also has a private cinema, a sauna and two laundry rooms. The full basement is finished, with daylight and ceilings of nine feet or more. Outside are a large screened porch, an outdoor kitchen and a heated saltwater gunite pool with a heated in-ground hot tub. The attached garage has room for four cars. The property last sold for $565,000 in 2019, before the current home was built.
William Mitchell of eXp Realty, LLC was a listing agent for the home, as was Michelle Dumas. Trina Roth of CENTURY 21 Scheetz represented the buyer in the week’s largest sale.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 2 — $2,900,000 · 9150 Timberwolf Ln, Zionsville, Indiana
On the north side of Zionsville, in the Timberwolf neighborhood, an all-brick French Provincial home on 3.99 wooded acres sold for $2,900,000. Its grounds, the largest lot among the week’s five, back to Carpenter Nature Preserve. Built in 1998, it is also the oldest home in the group. From the street, the home shows storybook rooflines and an arched entry, and its brick facade is varied rather than uniform.
Inside, a stone archway frames the way into a two-story foyer, where a curved staircase rises to the second floor. The great room centers on a limestone fireplace and has a curved wall of bay windows, and it opens to a formal dining room and a keeping room with a fireplace and built-ins of its own. The kitchen draws on French chateau style. It has custom cabinets, a built-in wine lattice and a decorative hood finished in tile, and there is also a walk-in pantry and a breakfast nook. A sitting room just off the kitchen has another fireplace and more built-ins. The step-down sunroom has exposed brick and vaulted, beamed ceilings.
The primary suite is on the main level and has a fireplace, a private balcony, a large walk-in closet and a bath built around a freestanding soaking tub. Upstairs, a bonus room above the garage has its own balcony and bath. The finished lower level adds a theater with a fireplace, an exercise room and more space for recreation. In all, the home has six bedrooms and eight baths, six full and two half, in 12,615 square feet. Outside are a brick-walled patio, a wide lawn, a fire pit, an in-ground spa and an in-ground pool with a diving board, and the attached garage fits four cars.
The home went under contract 14 days after it was listed. Traci Garontakos of The Agency Indy was the listing agent, and Karissa Sterling of Berkshire Hathaway Home represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 3 — $2,095,000 · 5818 Marvie Dr, Zionsville, Indiana
In Zionsville’s Wild Air community, a new Traditional home built in 2026 sold for $2,095,000 after being shown at the 2026 BAGI HomeARama. Finished in wood siding and stone, it stands on a 0.28-acre corner lot and came with an extensive landscaping package.
The main kitchen is backed up by a separate, fully equipped prep kitchen and pantry, so hosts can work out of sight. The primary suite is on the main level. Downstairs, the partially finished lower level has a lounge, a walk-up bar, an open theater and another bedroom. The home has five bedrooms, five baths, four full and one half, and 6,485 square feet, with a three-car attached garage. Outdoors there is an outdoor kitchen with a gas grill and an outdoor fireplace. Wild Air residents have a clubhouse, a fitness center, a park, a playground and trails.
The home went under contract five days after it was listed and sold at its full asking price. Mindy Garcia and Victoria Hilse, both of CENTURY 21 Scheetz, were the listing agents, and Adrienne Johnson of Epique Inc represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 4 — $2,085,686 · 640 Exmoor Dr, Carmel, Indiana
Another home built in 2026, this one in Carmel’s Jacksons Grant On Williams Creek, sold for $2,085,686. The Traditional home is finished in brick and stucco and has four bedrooms, two of them on the main level, and six baths, five full and one half, in 6,240 square feet on a 10,454-square-foot lot. It has an elevator, a kitchen with an island, a breakfast bar and a pantry, and a fireplace in the great room, with a second fireplace outdoors. There is also a deck, and the basement has daylight and ceilings of nine feet or more. The three-car attached garage faces the side.
The listing agent for this sale could not be verified. Lori Shanahan of Compass Indiana, LLC represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 5 — $2,025,000 · 15390 Whistling Ln, Carmel, Indiana
In Carmel’s Bridgewater Club, a brick Traditional home built in 2006 sold for $2,025,000. It is in the Whistling Straits section of the gated community, which has a second gate of its own, and its 0.68-acre lot is on a cul-de-sac on the golf course, with views of the 14th hole.
With seven bedrooms, it has the most of any home this week, along with six baths, five full and one half, and 8,625 square feet. The primary suite is on the main level and has a fireplace and a spa-style bath. Fireplaces also warm the great room, the library and the hearth room, and the home has a breakfast room, a bonus room and a family room with large windows and custom remote-controlled blinds. A speaker system runs through the home.
The lower level walks out to the yard and is built for guests and entertaining, with a theater, an exercise room, a billiards room, a game room and a full kitchen, plus two guest suites with full baths. Outside are a deck and a patio with a fire pit and a conversation area. The garage has room for four cars, and one of its bays has a 20-foot ceiling. The community has a pool. The property last sold for $1.425 million in 2021.
The home went under contract 10 days after it was listed. Jeffrey Boller of Vision One Real Estate was the listing agent, and Matt King of F.C. Tucker Company represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
RealtyWire selected these transactions from publicly reported residential sales identified for the calendar week ending Sunday, October 11, 2026. The report may exclude private, off-market, delayed or nondisclosed transactions. Prices, property details and professional representation are reported as available at publication and may be updated following confirmation from transaction participants.
Were you involved in one of these transactions? Contact RealtyWire to verify or correct your professional credit or submit information for a future edition.
See full market data on our Indianapolis Metro Area market page.
