Known as Breeze Hill, the house at 1933 Lititz Pike closed at its full asking price, its architectural design attributed to C. Emlen Urban and its 1.54 acres of grounds laid out by Thomas W. Sears. It was the highest of five home sales reported in the Lancaster, Pennsylvania metro area for the week ending September 20, 2026, a group that came to $5.02 million combined.
The other closings reached Reinholds, Paradise and Narvon, and a second Lancaster address made the list. Acreage runs through the whole group: all five properties sit on more than an acre, and the houses on them range from the 1927 estate to a 2019 build in the Morganshire community.
No. 1 — $1,595,000 · 1933 Lititz Pike, Lancaster, Pennsylvania
The 1927 residence at 1933 Lititz Pike sold for $1,595,000 on September 16, 2026. Listing materials attribute the architectural design of Breeze Hill, as the property is known, to C. Emlen Urban, and credit Thomas W. Sears with the layout of the grounds, a 1.54-acre plan whose stone walls and original circulation patterns remain intact. The five-bedroom house carries a reported 5,767 square feet.
The house was built to unusual standards for its date: exterior walls of three courses of solid brick carried on steel beams, finished in stucco and stone beneath an original Peach Bottom slate roof. A grand staircase rises from a foyer of heartwood flooring inlaid with tile, and the kitchen keeps a working fireplace with its original mantel. A sunroom with floor-to-ceiling paned doors opens to a wet bar and a family room under paneled cathedral ceilings.
Marble fireplaces appear in the dining room, the sitting room and the primary suite, which also has a walk-in closet with custom built-ins and a recently renovated bath. The third floor is original to the house and fully habitable, finished with architectural millwork and a clawfoot-tub bath, and is configured as a library and art studio.
Major systems have been updated under the current ownership, including a full-house rewire to 200-amp service in 2023 and a natural gas boiler in 2024. A circular driveway centered by a brick island sets the approach, and the rear grounds hold a heated Gunite pool and spa, a stone patio with a brick outdoor fireplace, and a three-car carriage garage. The property previously changed hands for $1,200,000 in 2022.
Anne M Lusk of Lusk & Associates Sotheby’s International Realty was the listing agent. The $1,595,000 closing put Lusk at the listing side of the highest-priced reported Lancaster-area transaction of the week, and Lusk has appeared in six earlier RealtyWire Top 5 roundups for the metro. Abby Young of Coldwell Banker Realty represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 2 — $935,000 · 204 Mustang Trl, Reinholds, Pennsylvania
A Landmark-built Sullivan model completed in 2019, the house at 204 Mustang Trail sits on a 2.07-acre homesite in the Morganshire community at Reinholds, with a wooded strip along the property line. It has four bedrooms and a reported 3,984 square feet, and it settled at $935,000 on September 14, 2026.
Ten-foot ceilings run through the main level, with a coffered ceiling in the great room, a cathedral ceiling in the study and a tray ceiling in the dining room. The kitchen is fitted with Cambria quartz countertops, 42-inch Wellborn cabinetry, an oversized center island seating six and an adjoining butler’s pantry, and opens to both the great room and a hearth room, each with its own gas fireplace.
The first-floor owner’s suite has an expanded walk-in closet and a bath with a freestanding soaking tub. Other build choices include a finished bonus room, custom mudroom lockers, oak staircases with Craftsman-style railings and a three-car garage. A 20-by-12-foot deck overlooks the rear yard, and the daylight lower level carries nine-foot ceilings and rough-in plumbing for a future full bath. The property previously changed hands for $657,823 in 2019.
Chris Birk of Keller Williams Elite listed the house, which went under contract 24 days after the current listing date, and the sale ranked No. 2 in RealtyWire’s Lancaster metro area Top 5 for the week. Lynn Zimmerman of Kingsway Realty – Lancaster represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 3 — $915,000 · 3174 Grande Oak Pl, Lancaster, Pennsylvania
A contract arrived two days after the current listing date for 3174 Grande Oak Place, a contemporary rancher on a private 1.23-acre lot in West Hempfield Township, inside the Hempfield School District. The house carries four bedrooms, three full baths and a reported 4,021 square feet, and the sale settled September 15, 2026 at $915,000.
Engineered hardwood floors, vaulted ceilings and skylights run through the main level. The custom kitchen pairs granite countertops with a 48-inch gas range and a center island seating six, and opens to a living room with exposed wood beams and a floor-to-ceiling stacked stone fireplace. A secondary bedroom off the kitchen has its own full bath, set up as a guest suite, and a finished lower level is reached by two separate stairways.
The main level is heated by a four-zone radiant floor system, and improvements include a roof and skylights in 2018, central air conditioning in 2022, and Marvin Infinity fiberglass windows with LP SmartSide siding in 2024. The rear porch opens to a StruXure-covered patio system installed in 2022, and a second covered patio sits beside a hot tub added in 2019. A detached 28-by-28-foot pole barn built in 2020 holds two garage bays. The property previously changed hands for $363,350 in 2013.
Alexander Reedy of Hostetter Realty LLC represented the listing side of the No. 3 sale in RealtyWire’s Lancaster metro area Top 5 for the week. The house went under contract 2 days after the current listing date, and the sale closed $125,100 above its final asking price of $789,900. Phyl Rittel of Coldwell Banker Realty represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 4 — $800,000 · 3671 White Oak Rd, Paradise, Pennsylvania
The ranch house at 3671 White Oak Road in Paradise was marketed through an on-site auction held July 31, 2026, and the sale settled September 14, 2026 at $800,000. Built in 1972 on 1.8 acres, it has three bedrooms and a reported 2,328 square feet, with countryside views from the front and rear of the property.
A sliding patio door opens to a hardscape patio and a gazebo. The property also carries a 20-by-34-foot detached shed and workshop and a backup generator hookup. It previously changed hands for $265,000 in 2003.
Having appeared in one earlier RealtyWire Top 5 roundup for the metro, John Stoltzfus of Stoltzfus Realty was the listing agent on the No. 4 sale in RealtyWire’s Lancaster metro area Top 5 for the week.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 5 — $770,000 · 509 Buchland Rd, Narvon, Pennsylvania
A center-hall Colonial built in 1992, 509 Buchland Road sits on more than two acres in Salisbury Township, within the Pequea Valley School District. The four-bedroom house carries a reported 2,410 square feet and changed hands for $770,000 on September 16, 2026.
Hardwood floors run through the formal living and dining rooms, and the custom kitchen has granite countertops and a center island alongside a breakfast room. The first-floor primary bedroom carries vaulted ceilings, skylights and a walk-in closet with an en-suite bath, while a great room adds skylights and a fireplace recently converted to a wood-burning stove. Three more bedrooms and a full hall bath occupy the second floor, along with an office that could serve as a fifth bedroom.
The rear yard holds a landscaped lawn, a new deck, new fencing, a storage shed and a recently converted saltwater pool, with the great room and breakfast room looking out over it. The front lawn faces open pasture. The property previously changed hands for $507,000 in 2021.
At $770,000, the sale took the No. 5 spot in RealtyWire’s Lancaster metro area Top 5 for the week, with Teresa Tomlinson of RE/MAX Centre Realtors as the listing agent. Chris Marrella of Keller Williams Platinum Realty – Wyomissing represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
RealtyWire selected these transactions from publicly reported residential sales identified for the calendar week ending Sunday, September 20, 2026. The report may exclude private, off-market, delayed or nondisclosed transactions. Prices, property details and professional representation are reported as available at publication and may be updated following confirmation from transaction participants.
Were you involved in one of these transactions? Contact RealtyWire to verify or correct your professional credit or submit information for a future edition.
See full market data on our Lancaster, Pennsylvania market page.
