Water and land set the tone for the five highest-priced home sales reported in the Wisconsin Dells & Baraboo Area, Wisconsin, for the week ending October 25, 2026. Together the five sold for $3.63 million.
Two of the homes are in Reedsburg, in the Lake Buckhorn and Buckhorn communities, and the top sale sits on a private lake in Juneau County. The rest of the list moves inland, to a self-sufficient farm property outside Loganville and the only new construction of the group, a ranch home finished in 2025 in Sauk City.
No. 1 — $875,000 · W1502 Trout Rd, Wisconsin Dells, Wisconsin
The top sale of the week is a 2020 Prairie and Craftsman-style home on Trout Lake, a private, nine-acre lake where motors are not allowed. The property has 150 feet of frontage and a pier, and the water suits fishing and kayaking. The home sits back from the road on 1.79 partly wooded acres along a private road, and the land is on an ATV and snowmobile trail.
Inside, the open living area of the main level centers on a wood-burning fireplace of river stone that rises from floor to ceiling. A long dining area is sized for big gatherings, and the kitchen and laundry are on the same floor. The home also has a great room and vaulted ceilings. The primary bedroom opens onto a covered porch, and the upper level has a bedroom facing the lake, two loft-style bunk rooms and a half bath. All told, the home has four bedrooms and three bathrooms, two full and one half, in 2,450 square feet, with a deck, a patio and a screened porch outside.
The detached garage is heated and insulated, and it includes a game room and its own stairway up to an unfinished attic. The property last sold for $500,000 in 2024. It is within minutes of the Wisconsin River, Wisconsin Dells and Interstate 90/94.
Sally Luehman of REMAX RealPros was the listing agent, and Dan Chin of Real Broker LLC represented the buyer. It was one of two sales in this Top 5 listed by Luehman for REMAX RealPros; the other ranks fourth.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 2 — $790,000 · E10085 Buck Bay W, Reedsburg, Wisconsin
At 4,300 square feet, the second-place home in the Lake Buckhorn community of Reedsburg is the largest of the week’s five, and its five bedrooms are also the most. The 2005 brick and vinyl ranch sits on a wooded corner lot of 3.09 acres on a cul-de-sac, with 88 feet of view across the lake and direct access to the water, a lake where motorboats are not permitted.
A winding drive leads to the home, which has vaulted ceilings, southern exposure, walls of windows and views of the water. The kitchen is open to the dining and living areas. Off the main rooms are a sunroom, an office behind French doors and a primary suite whose shower has body sprayers. The home has three bathrooms, a gas fireplace and an attached three-car garage.
The partly finished walkout lower level has a second kitchen, a recreation room and a second laundry room, and it opens to a wide stone patio. Residents of the community share a private beach, a clubhouse and walking trails. The property last sold for $550,000 in 2023.
Chelsey Steele of First Weber Inc was the listing agent. Sarah Mullenberg of Castle Rock Realty represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 3 — $770,000 · E10104 Buckhorn Rd, Reedsburg, Wisconsin
Built in 1993, the third-place home is the oldest of the five, and it has the most bathrooms, with five. The brick ranch stands on 3.04 acres on the lake in the Buckhorn community of Reedsburg, and it went under contract 13 days after it was listed.
Much of its character is in the woodwork. Cherry cabinetry and trim were made by Amish craftsmen, and the floors are wood. The kitchen has granite counters and a butler’s pantry with a second dishwasher and a wine cooler, and the great room has vaulted ceilings and a wood-burning fireplace. There is a wet bar, a three-season room, and a primary suite with a large walk-in closet and its own bath. In all the home has four bedrooms in 3,796 square feet, and the finished walkout lower level, with ceilings over eight feet, has a recreation room.
Outside, the home is clad in Hardie board fiber cement and fitted with triple-glazed Pella windows. There is Trex decking, a patio and a firepit. Besides the attached two-car garage, a separate insulated garage measuring 21 by 27 feet adds room for storage. The property last sold for $728,500 in 2023.
Jaime Fearing of Gavin Brothers Auctioneers LLC was the listing agent, and Kim K Connors-Johnson of Castle Rock Realty represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 4 — $610,000 · S6720 Eli Valley Rd, Loganville, Wisconsin
The fourth-place sale brings the largest piece of land of the week: 36.01 acres of pasture and tillable ground outside Loganville, in the Driftless Region, with a stream that runs year round and can water livestock. The property last sold for $162,000 in 2019, before the current home was built.
The two-story home followed in 2020. It has four bedrooms and four bathrooms in 3,037 square feet, finished with maple cabinetry, a large kitchen island, hickory stairs and engineered hardwood floors. A wood boiler in the lower level drives radiant heat in the floors of every level, and there is also a freestanding wood-burning fireplace. There is a mud room, a bonus room and an office, and the partly finished lower level has walkout access.
The property runs on a 12-volt solar system rather than conventional electrical service; the listing says the seller would install an electric meter before closing. Outbuildings include a 30-by-50-foot shed with a 14-foot lean-to, an insulated shop measuring 12 by 30 feet and a pole building for cold storage.
Sally Luehman of REMAX RealPros was on both sides of the sale, which was one of two in this Top 5 that Luehman listed for the firm, along with the week’s top sale.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 5 — $585,000 · 252 Falcon Ct, Sauk City, Wisconsin
The newest home in the group, completed in 2025, is a ranch in Cardinal Estates in Sauk City, on a lot of 10,018 square feet that adjoins a park or public land. It sold at its full asking price of $585,000. The property last sold for $92,900 in 2023, before the current home was built.
The plan centers on a large kitchen with quartz counters and backsplash, a work island, stainless steel appliances and a walk-in pantry. A dinette opens to the great room, which has a vaulted ceiling and a fireplace, and luxury vinyl plank runs through both rooms. The primary suite has a tray ceiling, a walk-in closet and a bath with a walk-in shower. The home has three bedrooms and three bathrooms, two full and one half, in 1,753 square feet, with laundry on the main floor, a mud room and an attached two-car garage.
The exposed lower level is unfinished, with plumbing stubbed in for a future bath, and it is ready to be finished with a family room and a fourth bedroom. The private backyard has a covered porch, and the home also has a patio.
The Acker Maly Home Team of RE/MAX Preferred was the listing agent, and Rachel Romens of EXP Realty, LLC represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
RealtyWire selected these transactions from publicly reported residential sales identified for the calendar week ending Sunday, October 25, 2026. The report may exclude private, off-market, delayed or nondisclosed transactions. Prices, property details and professional representation are reported as available at publication and may be updated following confirmation from transaction participants.
Were you involved in one of these transactions? Contact RealtyWire to verify or correct your professional credit or submit information for a future edition.
