These are the five highest-priced home sales reported in Warsaw-Culver & North Central Lakes, Indiana for the week ending November 1, 2026, and together they totaled $4.19 million. The sales reached across three counties, two each in Kosciusko and Marshall and one in Fulton. Plymouth was the only town with more than one, accounting for the second- and third-ranked sales, and at the other end of the list the fourth- and fifth-place homes closed at the same price.
No. 1 — $1,800,000 · 1125 Country Club Ln, Warsaw, Indiana
The highest-priced sale of the week was a lakefront home on Winona Lake, on a cul-de-sac in the Yarnelle Point neighborhood of Warsaw, which sold for $1,800,000. Built in 2018, it is the newest home in this Top 5, and it has 82 feet of frontage on an all-sports lake. The property last sold for $1.625 million in 2022.
A barrel-vaulted entry leads into a great room with a cathedral ceiling, exposed trusses, built-in shelving and a stone fireplace that runs from floor to ceiling. The main level is open, joining that room with the kitchen and with dining and sitting areas on the lake side. The kitchen has a 48-inch Wolf range in front of a custom tile wall, along with custom cabinetry, stone counters and a large island. Through windows, French doors and sliding glass doors, nearly every room looks south across Winona Lake.
The home has five bedrooms and four bathrooms in 3,587 square feet on two stories, with two of the bedrooms on the main level. The primary suite is upstairs and has a balcony on the lake side. Outside are a bluestone patio, a fenced backyard and landscaped grounds, and the two-car garage is heated, with an epoxy floor and a dog-washing station. The Village at Winona is minutes away.
Brian Peterson of Brian Peterson Real Estate was the listing agent for the week’s top sale, and Angela Racolta of Encore Sotheby’s International Realty represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 2 — $730,500 · 16258 Dogwood Ln, Plymouth, Indiana
Pretty Lake is the setting for the second-ranked sale, a one-story lake home on Dogwood Lane in Plymouth that sold for $730,500. Built in 1954, the home has four bedrooms, all on the main level, and three bathrooms in 1,943 square feet.
Every living area has a view of the lake. The open living space has a wall of windows toward the water and a two-way gas fireplace shared by the living room and a sunroom with a heated brick floor. The primary bedroom has its own laundry, and the home has California Closets.
On the shore, the property has 90-plus feet of beach frontage, a Shore Station dock and a 12-by-18-foot storage building. A bluestone patio measuring 16 by 35 feet is bordered with perennials, and there is a fire pit and a putting green. The attached two-car garage is oversized, with room for a golf cart. The Pretty Lake community has a restaurant and the Pretty Lake Golf Course, an 18-hole course with a pool, and the ski lake offers swimming and fishing through the year.
The home went under contract 25 days after it was listed. Joan E Kriscunas of Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group was the listing agent, and Patricia Miller of Century 21 Circle represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 3 — $620,000 · 15941 14th Rd, Plymouth, Indiana
The largest property in this Top 5 covers 22.80 acres along the Yellow River in Plymouth, much of it wooded, with nearly 3,000 feet of river frontage. The home sits nearly a quarter mile back from the road, and it sold for $620,000. The property last sold for $320,000 in 2020.
The brick and cedar Traditional home was built in 1973 and has 3,749 square feet, the most living area of the five, with four bedrooms and three bathrooms. The main floor has a very large living room with a fireplace, an eat-in kitchen, a formal dining room with its own closet and a primary suite with an oversized bath and a walk-in closet. Downstairs are a family room with a second fireplace, another bedroom and a second full kitchen. Many of the rooms look out over the woods and the river.
Outside are a large upper deck, a lower-level patio, a 30-by-36-foot pole barn and other storage, a yard and a garden plot. The river and the woods offer kayaking, fishing, birdwatching and hunting.
Jason Wampler of RE/MAX 1ST CHOICE REALTORS was the listing agent. Jackie Mahony of Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 4 — $520,000 · 1728 Colonial Dr, Rochester, Indiana
In Rochester, the fourth-ranked home has a channel-front setting on Colonial Cove on Lake Manitou, a ski lake, and it sold for $520,000. Built in 2003, the one-story home has five bedrooms and three bathrooms in 2,346 square feet. The open main floor includes a sunroom and laundry, and the walk-out lower level has a large family room, two more bedrooms and a bathroom. A covered patio, an irrigation system and an attached two-car garage complete the property.
Gwen Hornstein of Rochester Realty, LLC listed the home and also represented the buyer, making this the one sale of the week with the same agent on both sides.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 5 — $520,000 · 185 Ems T32 Ln, Leesburg, Indiana
The fifth-ranked home is in Bellrohr Park in Leesburg, with walk-to access to Lake Tippecanoe. A swimming beach easement for residents is steps from the home, and the patio at the front looks across it to the lake. The home sold at its full asking price of $520,000, and the property last sold for $440,000 in 2023.
Built in 1954, the two-story home has three bedrooms and three bathrooms in 2,155 square feet. The open living space rises to a vaulted ceiling with hand-hewn barn beams, and floor-to-ceiling windows in the great room bring in light and some view of the lake. The kitchen was recently updated with stainless appliances and opens to the main living areas.
Outside, concrete parking pads double as a pickleball court, and an outdoor shower is there for rinsing off after a day on the water. The home has a vinyl dock and a detached garage with room for two and a half cars. Lake Tippecanoe is an all-sports lake with two marinas and gas docks, and by boat it is possible to reach the country club for lunch or dinner and Patona Bay for ice cream.
Deb Paton Showley of Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group was the listing agent, and Zack Wilson of Perfect Location Realty represented the buyer. Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group listed two of the homes in this Top 5, this one and the Pretty Lake home in Plymouth.
See this property in Google Street View →
RealtyWire selected these transactions from publicly reported residential sales identified for the calendar week ending Sunday, November 1, 2026. The report may exclude private, off-market, delayed or nondisclosed transactions. Prices, property details and professional representation are reported as available at publication and may be updated following confirmation from transaction participants.
Were you involved in one of these transactions? Contact RealtyWire to verify or correct your professional credit or submit information for a future edition.
