
The five highest-priced home sales reported in Sheboygan-Manitowoc Lakeshore, Wisconsin for the week ending November 15, 2026 totaled $2.495 million. They spread across five towns, from Elkhart Lake and Plymouth to Sheboygan, Sheboygan Falls and Manitowoc, and four of the five were in Sheboygan County.
The group runs from a farmhouse built in 1860 to a condominium completed this year, with two single-story ranch homes and a two-story contemporary in between. Pleasant View Realty, LLC listed three of the five, and on two of the sales the same agent was on both sides.
No. 1 — $535,000 · N9263 Willow Road, Elkhart Lake, Wisconsin

The oldest home in this week’s group sits on 11.36 acres outside Elkhart Lake, a farmhouse built in 1860 on land that has room for animals. The property is set up as a hobby farm where horses are allowed, with a barn, ponds and a private island, and the home looks out over the water.
The two-story farmhouse has wood siding, wood floors and 2,836 square feet of living space, with two bedrooms and three bathrooms. On the main level, a large family room with a gas fireplace opens to a deck, and the kitchen has double ovens and an island with a cooktop. The living room, dining room and a full bath are just off the kitchen. A rec room with a wet bar, a pool table and access to a patio gives the home a second place to gather. Upstairs, the bedrooms include a primary suite with a walk-in shower. A heated garage with space for five vehicles has room for equipment as well as cars.
The home sold for $535,000. It went under contract 22 days after it was listed, and the property last sold for $445,000 in 2022.
Daniel Carran of Pleasant View Realty, LLC was the listing agent, one of three sales in this Top 5 listed by that brokerage. Kimberly Schlafke represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 2 — $525,000 · 4600 Nicole Lane, Sheboygan, Wisconsin

This 2009 ranch on Sheboygan’s Nicole Lane sits on a double lot of 0.65 acres, and much of the appeal is outdoors. The yard has established gardens, a paved firepit, and pear, apple, plum and cherry trees, along with grapevines, asparagus and an herb bed. There is even an outdoor shower heated by the sun, plus irrigation and a garden shed.
Inside, the home has 9-foot ceilings, archways, crown molding and Shaw hardwood floors, with large expanses of windows. The kitchen, with an island and a pantry, opens to the dining room and to a 12-by-24-foot composite deck. Three of the four bedrooms are on the main level in a split-bedroom plan, and the primary suite has a jetted tub, a tiled shower that runs floor to ceiling and built-in speakers. The finished lower level, with ceilings over 8 feet, adds the fourth bedroom, a full bath, an office, a wet bar and space for watching movies. In all, the home has 2,750 square feet, three bathrooms and a deep three-car attached garage.
The home sold for $525,000 after going under contract 18 days after it was listed. Amee Salzwedel of Shorewest Realtors, Inc. was the listing agent, and Daniel Menzer represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 3 — $510,000 · N6730 Hillside Road, Sheboygan Falls, Wisconsin

In the Town of Sheboygan Falls, this 1977 ranch sits among mature trees on a wooded 2.34-acre lot with a creek, within the Plymouth School District. A blacktop driveway leads up to the brick-and-siding home.
The most distinctive room is a four-season sunroom wrapped in windows, with heated floors for use all year and views of the outdoors. The bathroom floors are heated as well. The home has a living room and a separate family room, and the kitchen pairs granite countertops with wood cabinetry beside a dining area. All three bedrooms are on the main level, and the home has one full and one half bath in 1,808 square feet, the smallest living area of the five. A full basement is partly finished and has walk-out access, and there is a heated two-car attached garage.
The home went under contract six days after it was listed and sold for $510,000, which was $10,100 above its asking price of $499,900. Heather Zimbal of Pleasant View Realty, LLC was on both sides of the sale, as the listing agent and as the agent who represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 4 — $490,000 · N5604 Kathryn Drive, Plymouth, Wisconsin

This two-story contemporary in Plymouth is part of a small rural subdivision in the Kettle Moraine, with country surroundings and neighbors close by. Built in 1992 on 0.90 acres, it has brick and vinyl siding on the outside and 2,932 square feet inside, the largest living area in this group.
The main level has a formal dining room as well as a dining area, a living room and a half bath, and a large family room is built around a natural fireplace. All three bedrooms are on the upper level, where the full bath has a jetted tub and a shower. Downstairs, the rec room is already wired for movies, with surround sound, a projector and a large video screen, and it has room for a bar. The home also has a deck and a two-car attached garage.
The home sold for $490,000, just above its asking price of $487,900. The property last sold for $251,650 in 2016.
Todd Smith of Pleasant View Realty, LLC was the listing agent, and Katy Cain represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 5 — $435,000 · 1920 Ravenswood Lane, Manitowoc, Wisconsin

The newest home of the five is a condominium townhouse in Manitowoc, completed in 2026, that overlooks ponds and the wildlife around them. The community has shared green space.
The two-story home has 2,244 square feet, four bedrooms and three bathrooms, with two of the bedrooms on the main level. It has wood floors and custom cabinetry, and the kitchen includes a farmhouse sink, a five-burner stove and a combined pantry and coffee bar. Two river-rock fireplaces warm the home, one on each level. The primary suite has its own balcony, a tiled shower with no step to enter and heated, lighted mirrors, and the bathrooms have heated towel racks. The finished lower level has full-size windows and walk-out access, and the home has a private entrance, a patio and a two-car attached garage.
The townhouse sold for $435,000. Kimberly Kudick of Century 21 Aspire Group was on both sides of the sale, as the listing agent and as the agent who represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →