These are the five highest-priced home sales reported in the Lancaster-Hocking Hills Area, Ohio for the week ending November 8, 2026, and together they came to $3.985 million.
Two of the homes are in Logan, two are in Pickerington and one is in Lancaster. Three of the five sit on five acres or more, and one is new construction.
No. 1 — $889,000 · 13950 Nickel Plate Rd, Logan, Ohio
The top sale of the week was 13950 Nickel Plate Road in Logan, a ranch-style home on a hilltop that sold for $889,000. It was custom-built in 2024 and sits on 18.53 acres in Falls Township, within the Logan-Hocking School District. The property last sold for $399,900 in 2024.
The acreage is made up of three parcels, and each one can be built on and sold separately. The home stands on a tract of about 5.08 acres. The two adjoining parcels, of 8.53 and 4.92 acres, are a mix of woods and open ground.
Inside, the home has cathedral ceilings and a loft. It has six bedrooms, the most of any home in this Top 5, with five of them on the main level, along with three full baths and one half bath in 3,416 square feet on one story. A finished bonus room with its own full bath is above the attached two-car garage. Outside, there are a large front porch and a back patio, and the hilltop setting gives the home its views.
Tristden M Bauer of Bauer Realty & Auctions was the listing agent. The home went under contract four days after it was listed and sold at its full asking price, with Justin M Keys of The Columbus Agents representing the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 2 — $830,000 · 5811 Township Road 250, Logan, Ohio
The newest home in the group, and the only new construction among the five, is a Cape Cod-style home built in 2026 at 5811 Township Road 250 in Logan, in Perry County. It sold for $830,000.
The home is on 1.50 wooded acres, and a fire pit and a hot tub are out back. There are also a deck, a patio and a balcony. Inside, the first floor is one large open space, and an open loft looks out into the living area. A game room adds space for recreation, and the home has a full basement.
The home has four bedrooms, one of them on the main level, and three full baths in 2,500 square feet. Granite countertops and tiled showers are among the finishes, and there is a gas-log fireplace. A whole-house generator is included as well.
Justyn Y Smith of Coldwell Banker Realty was the listing agent, and Jake Ryan of Rock House Realty LLC represented the buyer. Coldwell Banker Realty had two listings in this Top 5, this sale at No. 2 and the sale at No. 3.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 3 — $785,000 · 13577 Church View Ct, Pickerington, Ohio
In the Meadowmoore neighborhood of Pickerington, 13577 Church View Court sold for $785,000. The home was custom built by Donley in 2005 and is on a half-acre lot on a cul-de-sac. The property last sold for $769,900 in 2024.
Outside, the in-ground pool is heated and measures 18 by 36 feet. A covered patio has ceiling fans and an outdoor sound system, there is a fire pit area, and the grounds are professionally landscaped. The community has a park with a playground, a pond, sidewalks and an outdoor sports area.
A den or library is just inside the entrance, and the great room opens to a large kitchen with room for seating and cooking. The main floor also has a half bath, a laundry room and a room that can serve as a bedroom or an office. The lower level has the second of the home’s two fireplaces, a custom bar, an eating area and a large family room. Upstairs there is a loft, and the primary suite has a sunken tub, a shower and a walk-in closet. In all, the home has four bedrooms, three full baths and one half bath in 3,270 square feet, plus a three-car garage and hardwood floors.
Susan M Braskett of Coldwell Banker Realty was the listing agent, giving the firm its second listing in this Top 5. Sam Cooper of Howard Hanna Real Estate Svcs represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 4 — $756,000 · 9261 Rich Hollow Rd SW, Lancaster, Ohio
The largest property in the group is at 9261 Rich Hollow Road SW in Lancaster, where a modern-style home on 31.32 acres sold for $756,000. With 3,631 square feet, it is also the largest home of the five, and it is the oldest, built in 1999. The property last sold for $45,000 in 1997, before the current house was built.
The land is wooded and draws plenty of wildlife. It also has a 24-by-36-foot livestock barn and a 40-by-48-foot pole building, and the property has garage space for four cars. The home is in the Amanda Clearcreek School District, just minutes from Clear Creek Metro Park.
The two-story home has three bedrooms and three full baths. It has an open layout and cathedral ceilings, and the kitchen has granite countertops and stainless steel appliances. The basement is fully finished, adding room for living and entertaining.
Jeremy R Mills of Rise Realty was the listing agent, and Ryan Blankenship, also of Rise Realty, represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 5 — $725,000 · 6091 Blacklick Eastern Rd NW, Pickerington, Ohio
Trails cut through natural growth for walking run across the back yard of 6091 Blacklick Eastern Road NW in Pickerington, a ranch-style home that sold for $725,000. The wooded 5.02-acre property is in Violet Township, within the Pickerington School District, and has a stream. A covered back porch looks out on the yard, and stone walkways around the home are grouted in charcoal gray to match the stone on its front. There are also a 14-by-28-foot shed with a loft, a fenced area for dogs and a custom-made chicken coop.
The home was built in 2017 and has three bedrooms, all on the main level, and two full baths in 2,226 square feet. Ceilings are nine feet high throughout, the full basement included. The kitchen has a large granite island and dark stainless steel appliances and is open to the dining room and to a family room with a gas fireplace. Three French doors on the south side bring in natural light and look onto the back yard. Floors are hickory hardwood, with carpet in the bedrooms. The home also has a separate office, a mudroom with laundry and pantry off the garage, a large open bath off the primary bedroom, a three-car attached garage and a generator. The property last sold for $77,000 in 2017.
Joan Elflein of Ohio Broker Direct, LLC was the listing agent, and Jody L Green of Cutler Real Estate represented the buyer. The home went under contract 30 days after it was listed and sold at its full asking price.
See this property in Google Street View →
RealtyWire selected these transactions from publicly reported residential sales identified for the calendar week ending Sunday, November 8, 2026. The report may exclude private, off-market, delayed or nondisclosed transactions. Prices, property details and professional representation are reported as available at publication and may be updated following confirmation from transaction participants.
Were you involved in one of these transactions? Contact RealtyWire to verify or correct your professional credit or submit information for a future edition.
