
Three of the five highest-priced home sales reported in Hayward & Northwest Lakes, Wisconsin for the week ending November 15, 2026, were in Hayward, with one each in Sarona and Rice Lake. Together the five sold for a combined $4.14 million. The list runs from remodeled lake homes with docks and decks over the water to a timber-styled home near a ski trail and a cedar-sided home on nearly eight acres.
No. 1 — $1,395,000 · 12725 W Fabiny Lane, Hayward, Wisconsin

The top sale of the week was a remodeled lake home at 12725 W Fabiny Lane in Hayward, which sold for $1,395,000. It sits on Round Lake, in a protected bay with 150 feet of sandy shoreline for swimming and launching kayaks and paddleboards, and the open water of the lake lies just past the bay. The shore faces southeast.
Built in 1970, the one-story home has three bedrooms, two bathrooms and 2,140 square feet on 0.79 acres. Local craftsman Jon Cain carried out the renovation, mixing granite counters, stainless appliances and soft-close cabinets in the kitchen with reclaimed wood and built-ins in the living room, where a real-stone fireplace burns wood. The four-season room has windows on three sides, a gas fireplace and views out over the lake. Downstairs, the finished walk-out lower level adds a family room with a game area and a snack station.
Much of the living here happens outdoors, across nearly 1,400 square feet of outdoor living space. There is a dining deck off the living room and a grilling deck off the kitchen, a 42-by-16-foot deck with both covered and pergola sections, and a flagstone fire pit area. A dock and a solar lift are part of the waterfront, and the home sold furnished, with a 2022 Bennington pontoon, a canoe, kayaks and paddleboards included. A detached two-car garage and a shed complete the property, which last sold for $550,000 in 2005.
The home went under contract 19 days after it was listed and sold at its full asking price. Courtney Johnson of Edina Realty, Inc. – Hayward was the listing agent, and James Gajewski of Area North Realty Inc represented the buyer, one of two sales in this Top 5 for Gajewski.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 2 — $1,200,000 · 12785 W Peninsula Road, Hayward, Wisconsin

Round Lake was the setting for the second sale as well, a remodeled home at 12785 W Peninsula Road in Hayward that sold for $1,200,000. Built in 1964, it is the oldest home in this week’s group and, at 1,508 square feet, the smallest, with three bedrooms and two bathrooms on 0.80 acres. The home looks south over the water, and a broad deck set up above the shoreline takes in the lake. Inside, the finishes have been updated throughout, and a wood-burning fireplace warms the main living space.
Guests get their own quarters in a loft built over the detached two-car garage. The property last sold for $900,000 in 2022. It went under contract 18 days after it was listed. Ty Wiley of Area North Realty Inc was the listing agent, and Jim Tiffany of C21 Woods to Water represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 3 — $540,000 · 14365W Skiers Lane, Hayward, Wisconsin

At 14365W Skiers Lane in Hayward, a ski-in, ski-out Adirondack-style home in the Brook development sold for $540,000. The ski trail is a few steps away. Built in 2005, it is the newest home in this Top 5, with a timber-frame look and wood floors that run through the rooms. A wood-burning fireplace anchors the living room, and a three-season room sits beneath a composite deck, which gives a second, open-air place to take in the woods around it.
The one-story home has three bedrooms, two full baths and a half bath in 2,115 square feet, plus a finished walk-out lower level. It stands on 4.99 acres, with a detached two-car garage reached by an asphalt driveway. The property last sold for $277,400 in 2007.
James Gajewski of Area North Realty Inc was on both sides of the sale, as the listing agent and the buyer’s agent. It was the second sale in this week’s Top 5 for Gajewski, who also represented the buyer of the No. 1 home, and the second listing on the list for Area North Realty Inc, whose agent Ty Wiley listed the No. 2 sale.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 4 — $510,000 · N3474 Fenander Road, Sarona, Wisconsin

The largest home of the week, at 3,848 square feet, sold for $510,000 at N3474 Fenander Road in Sarona. It sits on Ripley Lake, where there is fishing and swimming, on 1.43 acres with a dock, a big deck along the shore and a shed down by the water. Built in 2002, the one-story home has four bedrooms and three bathrooms and has been remodeled extensively, with luxury vinyl plank floors, new doors and trim, fresh paint, updated bathrooms and a redone kitchen.
The main level has vaulted ceilings, laundry and a private owner’s suite. Below it, the walk-out lower level is built for gatherings, with a family room, a wet bar, more bedrooms, a full bath and storage. The property includes six garage spaces and a heated 30-by-64-foot shop that went up in 2024. From the property, snowmobile and ATV trails are directly accessible, and other lakes, golf courses and restaurants are close by. The property last sold for $165,000 in 2021.
The home sold above its $499,900 asking price. Donnie Marker of Dane Arthur Real Estate Agency/Birchwood was the listing agent.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 5 — $499,900 · 1288 25 1/2 Avenue, Rice Lake, Wisconsin

The fifth sale, at 1288 25 1/2 Avenue in Rice Lake, sold for $499,900 and came with the most land of the week: 7.80 acres among tall trees, with a pond and a landscaped yard. A covered porch wraps around the cedar-sided home and looks out over the pond.
Built in 1998, the home has four bedrooms and three bathrooms in 2,810 square feet. Its center is a vaulted great room with hardwood floors, large windows and a stone fireplace that rises from floor to ceiling, opening to a remodeled kitchen. Two bedrooms, a full bath and laundry are on the main level. The primary suite is upstairs, with a walk-in closet and a bath that has a tiled walk-in shower, a soaking tub and a double vanity. The walk-out lower level adds a large family room, the fourth bedroom and another full bath. A detached three-car garage is heated and insulated, with room for a workshop.
The property last sold for $289,900 in 2016. It sold just above its $499,000 asking price. Casey Watters of Real Estate Solutions was the listing agent, and Lance Mikel of Property Executives Realty represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →