These are the highest-priced home sales reported in the Evansville-Newburgh Area, Indiana for the week ending November 1, 2026. Together the five sold for $3.257 million.
Three of the sales were in Warrick County and two in Vanderburgh County, spread across Elberfeld, Newburgh and Evansville. The three neighborhood homes are in Victoria Bluffs and Seaton Place in Newburgh and in Lauras Place in Evansville.
No. 1 — $900,000 · 3599 Fehd Rd, Elberfeld, Indiana
Set on 9.06 acres in rural Elberfeld, the week’s top sale is a horse property that sold for $900,000. It is near the Blue Grass Fish & Wildlife Area, a few minutes’ drive from Evansville, Newburgh and Boonville, on a level corner lot with pasture and landscaping and a walking trail nearby. Finished in 2020, the brick Traditional is the newest home in this Top 5.
The main barn is 60 by 84 feet, fully insulated, with concrete floors. It has five stalls inside and four outside, a tack and storage room, an office with a mini-split system for heating and cooling, and a 23-by-25-foot shop with a workbench. A covered lean-to runs 16 by 84 feet, and there is an outdoor wash stall. A second structure, a covered riding arena of 66 by 100 feet, is fitted with commercial-grade lighting and fans. The land also has fencing, pastures, and areas for riding and training, with room to park trailers and equipment.
There is also a heated beach-style pool made of quartz sand and resin, with a natural stone fountain, LED lighting and a sound system. A pool house built in barn style has a covered porch and a flagstone patio.
The home has four bedrooms, three of them on the main level in a split layout, and four bathrooms, three full and one half, in 3,407 square feet. The floor plan is open, and the living room has a gas fireplace. The eat-in kitchen has an island and quartz countertops, and ceilings are nine feet or higher. Radiant floor heat in three zones and a whole-house generator are among the upgrades, and the attached two-car garage is heated.
Jennifer Stallings of Extreme RE Real Estate was the listing agent, and Geri L Terry of F.C. TUCKER EMGE represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 2 — $762,000 · 5688 Victoria Bluffs Dr, Newburgh, Indiana
A heated fiberglass inground pool is the centerpiece of the backyard at 5688 Victoria Bluffs Drive in Newburgh, which sold for $762,000. A covered patio overlooks the water, and a separate half bath for the pool lets swimmers come and go without walking through the home. The primary suite, on the main level, has a view of the pool as well.
The brick two-story was built in 2005 on 0.48 acres in the Victoria Bluffs neighborhood and has an irrigation system. A two-story foyer opens the home, with a formal dining room off the entry on one side and a flex room on the other that could serve as an office, den or library. The living room centers on a gas fireplace. The kitchen, which has an induction range, is placed between two dining areas. The home also has crown molding, tray ceilings and custom cabinetry.
Three more bedrooms are upstairs, one with its own bath, along with a full hall bath and a large bonus room. Altogether the home has four bedrooms and five bathrooms, three full and two half, the most bathrooms of the five, in 3,196 square feet, and a three-car garage. The property last sold for $400,000 in 2013.
Janice E Miller of ERA FIRST ADVANTAGE REALTY, INC listed the home, and Ashley Carroll, also of ERA FIRST ADVANTAGE REALTY, INC, represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 3 — $580,000 · 4266 Windhill Ln, Newburgh, Indiana
All five bedrooms are upstairs at 4266 Windhill Lane, a two-story home in Newburgh’s Seaton Place neighborhood that sold for $580,000. No other home in this Top 5 has as many bedrooms, and its 0.35-acre lot is the smallest of the group.
The main level has a two-story foyer, a formal dining room trimmed in wainscoting and triple crown molding, and a formal living room behind French doors. In the family room, custom bookcases frame a gas fireplace, and the space opens to the kitchen and breakfast area. The kitchen has a curved island under pendant lights, a walk-in pantry and double built-in ovens. Both the breakfast area and the family room open onto a deck. A half bath and a laundry room with a utility sink are also on this floor.
Upstairs, the primary bath has a double vanity, a soaking tub, a separate tiled shower and a walk-in closet, and an oversized fifth bedroom has its own full bath. Built in 1995, the home has 3,810 square feet, four bathrooms, three full and one half, and an oversized three-car garage. It last sold for $393,000 in 2020.
The listing agent was Shea Fleck of KELLER WILLIAMS CAPITAL REALTY, and Johnnie Stewart of Dauby Real Estate represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 4 — $515,000 · 6909 Tonia Ct, Evansville, Indiana
The home at 6909 Tonia Court in Evansville is on a lake, with a deck on the waterfront and a finished walkout basement that gives easy access to the backyard and the water. It is on a cul-de-sac in the Lauras Place neighborhood and sold for $515,000.
It has the most living space of the five, 4,303 square feet. The lower level has room for recreation, entertaining or a home gym. On the main level are a home office, a formal dining room and a living area designed to make the most of the water view. The family room has a gas fireplace and bookcases, the eat-in kitchen has a breakfast bar, and there is a wet bar.
The brick Traditional two-story dates to 1991 and sits on 0.48 acres. Each of its four bedrooms has a walk-in closet, and the primary suite adds a private sitting room. There are four bathrooms, three full and one half, along with a jetted tub and a three-car garage.
Nichole Cullen of Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Indiana Realty was the listing agent. Brandon Stewart of Dauby Real Estate represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 5 — $500,000 · 12505 Petersburg Rd, Evansville, Indiana
A winding drive off Petersburg Road leads into 12505 Petersburg Road in Evansville, a 10-acre property that sold for $500,000. It is the largest piece of land in this Top 5, and most of it is fenced, suited to horses or other animals.
The 30-by-40-foot horse barn has six stalls, including a mare stall, plus a tack room, a loft with an access door for a hay elevator, and a lean-to on the back. A second outbuilding, 40 by 28 feet, has two overhead garage doors and a larger overhead door for an RV or a camper. The property also has a workshop, a fire pit and a detached three-car garage.
The ranch home, built of brick and stone in 1956, is the oldest of the five. It has three bedrooms and three bathrooms, two full and one half, in 2,693 square feet. The family room has a stone fireplace and opens to the eat-in kitchen, which was updated and has large windows looking out over the property. A big deck extends off the kitchen. The bedrooms are split, with a bedroom and full bath at the north end and two bedrooms with another full bath at the south end. The partly finished lower level has a second family room with a fireplace, a kitchenette, a half bath and plenty of storage.
Stacy J Stevens of Landmark Realty & Development, Inc was on both sides of the sale, as the listing agent and as the buyer’s agent, and the home went under contract 21 days after it was listed.
See this property in Google Street View →
RealtyWire selected these transactions from publicly reported residential sales identified for the calendar week ending Sunday, November 1, 2026. The report may exclude private, off-market, delayed or nondisclosed transactions. Prices, property details and professional representation are reported as available at publication and may be updated following confirmation from transaction participants.
Were you involved in one of these transactions? Contact RealtyWire to verify or correct your professional credit or submit information for a future edition.
