The house at 4309 Alleghany Trail has stood on Lake Shawnee since 1984, and it sold with a private enclosed boathouse, a powered boat lift and a large composite dock dating to 2022. The closing led five reported home sales in the Dayton, Ohio metro area for the week ending September 20, 2026, a group totaling $4.29 million.
Jamestown supplied the No. 2 sale as well, a 68-acre certified organic farm that changed hands at $1 million. Oakwood and Centerville account for the rest, with the Soraya Farms community in Centerville represented twice. Build dates stretch from an 1890 farmhouse to a house completed in 2020.
No. 1 — $1,044,000 · 4309 Alleghany Trl, Jamestown, Ohio
The four-bedroom house at 4309 Alleghany Trail sits on the Lake Shawnee waterfront in Jamestown, and the sale carried with it a private enclosed boathouse with a powered boat lift and a large composite dock dating to 2022. The house went up in 1984 and is recorded at a reported 4,318 square feet. The sale closed September 16, 2026.
Listing materials identify a primary suite oriented to the lake, with a private sitting area and wet bar, his-and-her ensuite bathrooms and walk-in closets. The kitchen holds two large islands, extensive cabinetry and storage, and a Jenn-Air six-burner gas range with double ovens, and it opens into the main entertaining rooms.
A walkout lower level adds a second full kitchen, a family room and another wet bar. The detached three-car garage is heated and oversized, fitted with extensive cabinetry and roughly 300 square feet of unfinished storage above. The property previously changed hands for $700,000 in 2021.
The $1,044,000 closing put Joan Elflein of Ohio Broker Direct at the listing side of the highest-priced home sale RealtyWire recorded in the Dayton metro area for the week ending September 20. Mitchell E Belka of Coldwell Banker Heritage represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 2 — $1,000,000 · 643 Brickel Rd, Jamestown, Ohio
Brickel Creek Farm runs to 68 acres at 643 Brickel Rd outside Jamestown, and the certified organic operation on the land has supplied herbs and vegetables to a local grocery chain for 20 years. The transaction closed on September 16, 2026.
Growing infrastructure includes four hoop houses, additional tunnels and beds sown with cover crop, while more than 40 acres of tillable ground are rented out. Farm buildings include a 7,500-bushel grain bin, two Morton barns and a 40-by-66-foot barn framed with doweled beams. The north branch of Caesar Creek runs through the property, which also holds pockets of woods.
The farmhouse at the center of it dates to 1890 and has three bedrooms, two bathrooms and a reported 3,593 square feet. The farm sits minutes from Interstate 71 and just outside Cedarville. The property previously changed hands for $315,000 in 2006.
Tyler McConnell of Comey & Shepherd represented the listing side of the $1,000,000 transaction, which ranked No. 2 in RealtyWire’s Dayton Metro Area Top 5 for the week ending September 20.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 3 — $810,000 · 55 Park Rd, Oakwood, Ohio
Set on nearly half an acre in Oakwood, the 1926 house at 55 Park Road pairs original detailing with renovations done in keeping with that character, the new kitchen among them. It closed on September 17, 2026 for $810,000.
That kitchen was designed around storage and work surface, with a custom vent hood over the gas range and built-ins throughout. A light-filled great room opens through French doors onto the patios and flows into the dining room, and the home office and living room take southern and western views.
The house is recorded with five bedrooms, three bathrooms and a reported 4,186 square feet: a large primary suite with walk-in closets and a full bath upstairs, three guest rooms and a second full bath, and one more bedroom on the third floor. The grounds hold gardens, a fountain, patios and a summer house overlooking the private rear yard, with a circular drive for parking. The property previously changed hands for $629,900 in 2015.
Felix S McGinnis and Jeanne Glennon of Coldwell Banker Heritage were the listing agents. The pair took the No. 3 position in RealtyWire’s Dayton Metro Area Top 5 for the week ending September 20. Kelli D Marshall-Pope of Coldwell Banker Heritage represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 4 — $735,000 · 1135 Petrus Ct, Centerville, Ohio
The two-story house at 1135 Petrus Court went up in 2020 in the Soraya Farms community in Centerville. It holds four bedrooms, three bathrooms and a reported 5,487 square feet. Records date the closing to September 15, 2026, at $735,000.
Eleven-foot ceilings run through the living room and the primary suite, and added transom windows in the primary closet and the upstairs bonus room bring daylight further in. The kitchen has marble countertops, upgraded cabinetry, a large center island, stainless steel appliances and a large pantry, and it sits between a breakfast nook and a formal dining room.
Three more bedrooms upstairs each have walk-in closets, and the daylight basement below runs to more than 2,300 square feet, left unfinished. Outside are a concrete patio, fencing and landscaping, and a water softening system, a video doorbell and a Tesla charging station stay with the house. Soraya Farms residents have use of a clubhouse, a swimming pool, a fitness center and walking trails.
Jordan Lance of Keller Williams Community Part listed the property, and the $735,000 closing ranked No. 4 in RealtyWire’s Dayton Metro Area Top 5 for the week ending September 20.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 5 — $699,000 · 9468 Monaco Cir, Centerville, Ohio
A custom ranch at 9468 Monaco Circle gave Soraya Farms its second entry on the week’s list, at $699,000. The September 18, 2026 closing covered a 2017 house of a reported 2,506 square feet, laid out on a split-bedroom plan with two primary suites.
The first suite sits off the foyer with an ensuite bath, a walk-in tile shower, a linen closet and a walk-in closet. The owner’s suite has a sitting area and a bath with its own walk-in tile shower and a custom closet system. French doors open to a dedicated study that can double as a guest room, and the great room carries a floor-to-ceiling stone fireplace and runs into the kitchen, dining area and sunroom.
The kitchen has quartz countertops, Forno and Samsung stainless appliances, a vented hood, glass-front cabinetry with accent lighting and pull-out shelving. A newly added enclosed lanai extends off the patio doors, fitted with EZ Breeze windows, an oversized stone gas fireplace, a custom mantel, two ceiling fans and stone flooring. The garage has epoxy flooring and overhead storage, and the grounds carry paver patios, a firepit area, decorative retaining walls, irrigation, an invisible fence and 26 added trees. Residents share the Soraya Farms clubhouse, pool, walking trails and fitness area, along with a fishing pond. The property previously changed hands for $552,000 in 2024.
Shelley Parks of eXp Realty was the listing agent. This marks Parks’s second appearance in a RealtyWire Top 5 roundup for the Dayton metro area. Nicole M Gulick of Reign Realty represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
RealtyWire selected these transactions from publicly reported residential sales identified for the calendar week ending Sunday, September 20, 2026. The report may exclude private, off-market, delayed or nondisclosed transactions. Prices, property details and professional representation are reported as available at publication and may be updated following confirmation from transaction participants.
Were you involved in one of these transactions? Contact RealtyWire to verify or correct your professional credit or submit information for a future edition.
See full market data on our Dayton, Ohio market page.
