These were the highest-priced home sales reported in Angola & Northeast Indiana Lakes for the week ending October 25, 2026, and together the five sales came to $3.05 million. They were spread across five towns, Hamilton, Shipshewana, Auburn, Angola and Garrett, in Steuben, Lagrange and De Kalb counties.
Four of the five are single-family homes and one is a condominium, and three of them were waterfront properties with piers. The second and third sales went under contract within a week of being listed, and the same agent was on both sides of three of the five sales. The third- and fourth-ranked homes sold for the same price.
No. 1 — $699,000 · 255 Lane #270, Hamilton, Indiana
The top sale of the week was a lakefront ranch home in the Crystal Bay neighborhood of Hamilton, part of the Hamilton Lake community, where the lake is used for skiing, other water sports and fishing. The home sold for $699,000, its full asking price.
Built in 2007, the one-story home has three bedrooms, all on the main level, and two bathrooms in 1,725 square feet. A foyer opens into a bright living room under cathedral ceilings, which leads on to the dining room and an updated kitchen with stainless appliances, a custom backsplash and a breakfast bar. The primary bedroom is an en suite with a double vanity, and water is in view from most of the rooms.
The 7,405-square-foot lot slopes down toward the lake. A sunporch on the lake side looks out across the bay to the neighboring homes, and beyond it are a sun deck and a concrete patio set within 10 feet of the shoreline. The property also has a pier, a covered porch, irrigated landscaping and an attached two-car garage with an epoxy floor.
Shelby Holsinger of Century 21 Bradley Realty, Inc was the listing agent, and Sarah Dalton of Cressy & Everett – South Bend represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 2 — $675,000 · 11055 W 805 N, Shipshewana, Indiana
Fish Lake is an all-sports lake, and this Shipshewana home sits on a level bank at the water, with a sandy bottom and good swimming directly in front of it. It sold for $675,000. Built in 1993, it is the oldest of the week’s five homes.
The two-story home has four bedrooms and three bathrooms in 3,019 square feet. An open plan keeps the lake in view from the main rooms. The kitchen has custom cabinetry and a center island, the dining room has a fireplace and its own view of the water, and two separate living rooms give the household space to spread out. One bedroom and a laundry room are on the main level. Upstairs are three more bedrooms, among them a private primary suite, while the other two share a jack-and-jill bathroom.
Outside, the 0.28-acre property has a deck, a fire pit, boat docking rights and two newer aluminum pier spaces, along with a storage shed for lake gear.
The home went under contract six days after it was listed. Jackie Mahony of Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group was on both sides of the sale, as the listing agent and as the agent who represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 3 — $630,000 · 1802 Bent Tree Ct, Auburn, Indiana
The largest home among the week’s sales is a one-story villa in Bridgewater Villas in Auburn, a custom-built Hescot design within the Bridgewater Golf Community. The condominium sold for $630,000, the same price as the fourth-ranked sale. Its setting on a cul-de-sac gives it fairway views of the first and ninth holes, and a covered brick patio out back looks over a fountain toward the course.
Built in 2011, the ranch-style villa has 3,172 square feet of living space, two bedrooms and three bathrooms, and its 0.61-acre lot is the largest of the five. Inside are coffered ceilings, crown molding throughout, heated floors and cherry cabinetry. The kitchen is built around a large island and has an induction cooktop with a vented hood. For entertaining there is a bar area, a family room, a great room and a formal dining room, wired with a built-in speaker system, and a gas log fireplace with a herringbone insert anchors the living room. The primary suite has a custom tiled shower, and laundry is set inside its walk-in closet.
The heated four-car garage covers more than 1,200 square feet and has epoxy floors, radiant heat and a built-in workshop. The community has an association pool.
The villa went under contract two days after it was listed. Emily Witmer of CENTURY 21 Bradley Realty, Inc was the listing agent, and Amanda Woodbury of CENTURY 21 Bradley Realty, Inc represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 4 — $630,000 · 75 Lane 150b Jimmerson Lk, Angola, Indiana
In the Harbour Island neighborhood of Angola, this traditional-style home has 141 feet of frontage on a channel that leads to the main body of Jimmerson Lake and on through the Lake James chain. It sold for $630,000.
The home was built in 1997 and has four bedrooms and three bathrooms in 2,154 square feet. On the main level, an open kitchen with an oversized island and a breakfast bar runs into the living and dining areas. That level also has bedrooms and a private primary suite. Below, a finished walkout lower level has a family room and another full bathroom, and a loft adds a place for guests to sleep.
The 0.33-acre lot is level, with a large yard. Composite decking, a covered patio and a fire pit give it several places to sit by the water, and a shed near the lake has a loft of its own. The property also has a pier and a two-car garage.
Weston Hankey of Mike Thomas Associates was on both sides of the sale, as the listing agent and as the agent who represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 5 — $416,380 · 817 Concho Ct, Garrett, Indiana
The newest of the five homes, built in 2026, is a two-story home in the Saddle Ridge neighborhood of Garrett that sold for $416,380. It has four bedrooms, including a suite on the main level, plus three full baths and a half bath in 2,396 square feet. An open floor plan centers on an eat-in kitchen with a pantry, the exterior combines masonry and vinyl siding, and the 0.30-acre level lot has an attached three-car garage. Erin Poiry of Mike Thomas Assoc., Inc was on both sides of the sale, as the listing agent and as the agent who represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
RealtyWire selected these transactions from publicly reported residential sales identified for the calendar week ending Sunday, October 25, 2026. The report may exclude private, off-market, delayed or nondisclosed transactions. Prices, property details and professional representation are reported as available at publication and may be updated following confirmation from transaction participants.
Were you involved in one of these transactions? Contact RealtyWire to verify or correct your professional credit or submit information for a future edition.
