Market Datavs. 1 year ago
30-year mortgage7.11%▲ +0.87 pts15-year mortgage6.45%▲ +0.96 pts10-year Treasury5.10%▲ +0.97 ptsMortgage spread2.01 pts▼ -0.10 ptsMedian list price (Oct)$415k▼ -2.2%List $/sqft (Oct)$222▼ -1.3%Days on market (Oct)63 +0 daysActive listings (Oct)1.18M▲ +7.4%New listings (Oct)357k▼ -7.5%Pending sales (Oct)381k▼ -10.7%Housing starts (Oct)1.31M▲ +2.8%Building permits (Oct)1.3M▼ -8.7%New-home sales (Sep)676k▼ -5.3%Existing-home sales (Oct)3.75M▼ -8.8%Months of supply (Sep)8.4▲ +0.2 moMortgage delinquency (Q2)1.86%▲ +0.08 pts
Updated 12:40 AM ET
Top Sales

Muncie-New Castle Area, Indiana Top 5 Home Sales: Yorktown Home Leads a Week of Log, Brick and New Construction

A log home on wooded country acreage, a brand-new two-story in Muncie and a 1960s brick ranch joined a Yorktown home with a finished lower level among the week's top sales.

Muncie-New Castle Area, Indiana Top 5 Home Sales: Yorktown Home Leads a Week of Log, Brick and New Construction

The five highest-priced home sales reported in Muncie-New Castle Area, Indiana for the week ending November 15, 2026 added up to $2.08 million. Three of the homes are in Henry County and two are in Delaware County, and each sale was in a different town: Yorktown, Shirley, New Castle, Muncie and Middletown.

The group runs from a 2026 new-construction home, the newest of the five, to a ranch built in 1966, the oldest. Two of the properties are on country acreage with pole barns, including one of nearly 12 acres, while the other three are in subdivisions or town settings.

No. 1 — $520,000 · 209 S Buckingham Rd, Yorktown, Indiana

Top home sale No. 1 in Muncie-New Castle Area, Indiana β€” 209 S Buckingham Rd, Yorktown, Indiana, week ending November 15, 2026

The week’s top sale is a one-story brick home from 2002 in the Evergreen West subdivision of Yorktown, and much of its space is on a finished lower level. In all, the home has 4,168 square feet of living area, the most of the five, on a 0.31-acre lot, the smallest of the group. It sold for $520,000, its full asking price, and went under contract eight days after it was listed. The property last sold for $361,000 in 2021.

All three bedrooms are on the main floor. Past the entrance foyer, a great room with a gas-log fireplace opens to the dining area. The kitchen, updated with granite countertops and new flooring, has a large pantry and room to eat in, and the home has tray and vaulted ceilings. The primary suite has a bath that was fully remodeled in 2024 and its own door to the back deck.

The finished lower level adds a family room, a den, a workout room and a half bath, so the home has two full and two half baths in all. Outside, the deck looks over a private backyard, and there is a fire pit area. The home also has an attached two-car garage.

Karen Dall of Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group was the listing agent and also represented the buyer, putting the same agent on both sides of the sale.

See this property in Google Street View →

No. 2 — $500,000 · 7640 W County Road 350 S, Shirley, Indiana

Top home sale No. 2 in Muncie-New Castle Area, Indiana β€” 7640 W County Road 350 S, Shirley, Indiana, week ending November 15, 2026

A log home set a half mile off the road in Shirley sits on 11.95 acres, the largest parcel among the five, outside any subdivision. About five of those acres are wooded with mature trees, and nearly five more are tillable land. The setting is rural Henry County, one hour east of downtown Indianapolis.

Built in 2006, the log home has three bedrooms, three bathrooms and 2,782 square feet of living area. Inside, a cathedral ceiling rises over an open living space, and a wood-burning fireplace is the focus of the living room. There is a breakfast bar, and the main floor also has a bedroom, a full bath and a laundry and mudroom. The primary suite is upstairs, with a bath that has a soaking tub and a separate walk-in shower.

A covered deck wraps around the main level. The full walkout basement is unfinished, with a roughed-in half bath and space for recreation. A 30-by-54-foot pole barn with two overhead doors gives the property storage and work space.

The home sold for $500,000, just above its $499,900 asking price. Sarah Springman of Berkshire Hathaway Home was the listing agent, and Sean McDuffee of Coldwell Banker – Kaiser represented the buyer.

See this property in Google Street View →

No. 3 — $420,000 · 773 Suzanne Ct, New Castle, Indiana

Top home sale No. 3 in Muncie-New Castle Area, Indiana β€” 773 Suzanne Ct, New Castle, Indiana, week ending November 15, 2026

On Suzanne Court in New Castle, a two-story home built in 1990 went under contract four days after it was listed and sold for $420,000. The property last sold for $355,000 in 2022.

The brick and wood-sided home sits on a landscaped lot of 1.14 acres and has three bedrooms, three bathrooms and 3,446 square feet of living area. It has an entrance foyer, hardwood floors, ceilings of nine feet or more and a kitchen with a breakfast bar. One bedroom suite is on the main level, and the home also has a jetted tub, a separate tub and shower, and walk-in closets. The finished basement has walkout access and two extra rooms that can serve as an office or guest space.

The backyard has a privacy fence and a fire pit, and the home also has a deck. The attached two-car garage has a new epoxy floor.

Ashley Huffman of RE/MAX First Integrity was the listing agent. Kayla Walker of F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate represented the buyer.

See this property in Google Street View →

No. 4 — $325,900 · 3100 W Shasta Dr, Muncie, Indiana

Top home sale No. 4 in Muncie-New Castle Area, Indiana β€” 3100 W Shasta Dr, Muncie, Indiana, week ending November 15, 2026

The newest home in this week’s group was finished in 2026 in Country Village, a Muncie neighborhood with sidewalks and street lights. The traditional two-story, with brick and vinyl siding, has four bedrooms, the most of the five, along with three bathrooms and 2,203 square feet of living area on a 0.46-acre lot. It sold for $325,900.

The main floor is open, with the family room running into the kitchen and a breakfast area. The kitchen has a center island and a pantry, and a study near the foyer can work as a home office or playroom. Upstairs, the primary suite has a walk-in closet and a bath with a walk-in shower. Three more bedrooms share that floor with a loft, a full bathroom and the laundry room. There is also a covered outdoor space and an attached two-car garage.

Kayla Walker of F.C. Tucker/Crossroads was the listing agent for the new home, which went under contract 29 days after it was listed.

See this property in Google Street View →

No. 5 — $315,000 · 1956 W Us Highway 36, Middletown, Indiana

Top home sale No. 5 in Muncie-New Castle Area, Indiana β€” 1956 W Us Highway 36, Middletown, Indiana, week ending November 15, 2026

The oldest home of the five is an all-brick ranch from 1966 on 2.40 wooded acres in Middletown. It sold for $315,000 after going under contract eight days after it was listed.

The one-story home has three bedrooms, two bathrooms and 1,571 square feet of living area. Original hardwood floors run through several rooms, and there are two living areas, an eat-in kitchen with plenty of cabinets, a breakfast bar and a fireplace. A glass-enclosed sunroom adds another place to sit.

Along with the attached two-car garage, the land has a 32-by-50-foot pole barn and a 20-by-20-foot outbuilding with room for vehicles, tools and hobbies. The home is in Shenandoah schools. US 36 leads to Middletown, Pendleton, Anderson and New Castle, and there is quick access to Interstate 69 for trips toward Fishers, Noblesville and Indianapolis.

Hilary Casstevens of Epique Inc was the listing agent, and Mitchell Kelm of Highgarden Real Estate represented the buyer.

See this property in Google Street View →


More Top 5 Articles from Muncie-New Castle Area, Indiana

View all Muncie-New Castle Area Top 5 articles →

RealtyWire Top 5 articles are based on publicly reported residential sales and may not include every transaction. Information is subject to correction.Contact RealtyWire to verify or update professional credit.

βœ‰

Stay ahead of the market.

Get expert insights, market updates, and new opportunities delivered to your inbox.

RealtyWire Newsletter Signup
We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe anytime.