Country property set the tone in Muncie-New Castle Area, Indiana during the week ending November 8, 2026. These were the highest-priced home sales reported for the week, and together they came to $2.24 million. Three of the five were in Henry County and two in Delaware County, with Middletown accounting for two of the sales and New Castle, Muncie and Yorktown one each.
The list runs from a home built in 2024 to one built in 1937, and from more than 10 acres of land down to a neighborhood lot in Yorktown. All five are single-family homes, and in one of the sales the same agent was on both sides.
No. 1 — $730,000 · 2644 S Spiceland Rd, New Castle, Indiana
Five acres of mature trees surround 2644 S Spiceland Road in New Castle, which sold for $730,000, the highest price of the week. The land sits outside any subdivision, and its woods are open for walking. The grounds also have a three-tier waterfall and a fish pond, a gazebo, an outdoor kitchen and a heated hot tub, along with a covered front porch for mornings and a screened-in porch for evenings.
The traditional home, finished in brick and cement siding, was custom built in 2004. At 4,734 square feet it is the largest of the five, with four bedrooms and four bathrooms. Its centerpiece is a great room that rises two stories, warmed by a gas fireplace. The primary suite is on the main level, and its bath has a double vanity, a large tiled walk-in shower and a whirlpool tub. The eat-in kitchen has a built-in pantry, and California Closets have been fitted throughout. Upstairs, two bedrooms share a jack-and-jill bath.
The full finished basement works almost as a second home, with an entertainment area, a kitchenette, an office and a full bath. Parking includes both an attached and a detached garage, with room for four cars in all, the most garage space in this Top 5. The detached garage has full electrical service and attic storage above.
Carrie Clark of Keller Williams Indpls Metro N was the listing agent for the week’s top sale, and Heather Upton of Keller Williams Indy Metro NE represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 2 — $475,000 · 3730 W County Road 325 S, Muncie, Indiana
Built in 2024, the newest home on the list was designed for several generations living under one roof. The home at 3730 W County Road 325 S in Muncie has three primary suites, and each one has its own sitting room apart from the sleeping area, a large walk-in closet and a private bathroom with a shower. A fourth bedroom uses a full hall bath with a tub and shower. All four bedrooms are on the main level, and the home’s five bathrooms are the most in this group.
The rest of the 3,025-square-foot traditional home is laid out openly around a large great room. Laminate floors run through the main living areas, while the suites are carpeted. The eat-in kitchen has an island, custom cabinetry and a walk-in pantry right off it, and the appliances can be controlled from a phone. There is an oversized back deck, and the landscaped 1.40-acre corner lot is in a rural subdivision.
The property also has a 24-by-36-foot barn with electricity and water, a whole-house generator, an attached two-car garage and room to park an RV. Both the home and the barn have metal roofs.
The home went under contract 12 days after it was listed and sold for $475,000, its full asking price. Marjorie Jameson of Berkshire Hathaway Indiana Realty was the listing agent and also represented the buyer, so the same agent was on both sides of the sale.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 3 — $430,000 · 8271 W County Road 700 N, Middletown, Indiana
At 10.43 acres, the property at 8271 W County Road 700 N in Middletown has the most land in this Top 5. It is rural ground outside any subdivision, with stretches of mature woods and sunny, grassy open areas. A large pole barn, a wooden barn and a heated greenhouse stand on the land, and a fire pit area comes with its own smokehouse. There is open space left for trails, gardens or more outbuildings, and there is no homeowners association.
The traditional home was built in 1975 and has 3,072 square feet, four bedrooms and three bathrooms. One bedroom is on the main level and the other three are upstairs. The kitchen has a breakfast bar, and below is a full basement that is partly finished. A deck and a porch extend the living space outdoors, and there is an attached two-car garage. The listing puts Anderson about 10 to 15 minutes away, with Fishers, Noblesville, Pendleton and New Castle within about half an hour.
The property last sold for $240,000 in 2018. It sold this time for $430,000.
Kristi Covey of Real Broker, LLC was the listing agent, and Joe Curtis of F.C. Tucker Company represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 4 — $368,900 · 1200 N Wild Pine Dr, Yorktown, Indiana
In the Chase Trail neighborhood of Yorktown, 1200 N Wild Pine Drive sold for $368,900, its full asking price. Built in 2021, the one-story traditional home has three bedrooms, two bathrooms and 2,068 square feet, all on a level, landscaped lot of 8,712 square feet. The home is in the Yorktown school district.
A covered front porch and a front door framed by sidelights open into an entry foyer. The living room beyond has a vaulted ceiling crossed by a stained wood beam and a gas log fireplace with a custom wood mantel. It opens to the kitchen and dining area, where the cabinets and center island have quartz countertops and the backsplash is tiled. Luxury vinyl plank flooring covers most of the main rooms.
The primary suite, with a tray ceiling and crown molding, sits on a split floor plan apart from the other bedrooms. Its five-piece bath has a tiled walk-in shower behind glass, a soaking tub, double vanities and an extra-deep walk-in closet. Out back, a 14-by-14-foot gazebo covers the patio, and a six-foot vinyl privacy fence encloses the yard. Brick wraps three sides of the exterior.
Ryan Orr of RE/MAX Real Estate Groups was the listing agent, and Mark P Studebaker of Trueblood Real Estate represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 5 — $239,900 · 690 High St, Middletown, Indiana
The oldest home on the list went under contract one day after it was listed. Built in 1937, the brick home at 690 High Street in Middletown sits on a quarter-acre corner lot with sidewalks, and it sold for $239,900, its full asking price.
Inside its 2,805 square feet, the living room is warmed by a wood-burning fireplace, and there is a formal dining room as well as an eat-in kitchen with a pantry. A three-season sunroom looks out on the backyard. Two of the three bedrooms are on the main level, sharing it with a full bath, while the primary suite upstairs has its own full bath and a walk-in closet. The partly finished basement adds a recreation room, a bonus room, a workshop, a laundry area and storage. Outside are a patio, a detached one-car garage and a carport beside it.
Jeffrey Cummings of RE/MAX Complete was the listing agent, and Barbara Bade of Keller Williams Indy Metro NE represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →