The five highest-priced home sales reported in the Elkhart-Goshen Area, Indiana for the week ending November 8, 2026, totaled $3.802 million. Elkhart accounted for two of them, and Goshen, Granger and Middlebury for one each, all within Elkhart County.
Every one of the five is a single-family home, and none is older than 1997; the newest was finished in 2024. Prices ran from $505,000 to $949,000.
No. 1 — $949,000 · 51055 Twilight Dr, Elkhart, Indiana
The week’s top sale was a contemporary walkout ranch on Simonton Lake, where the property has 133 feet of frontage on a channel and views toward Little Simonton and the entrance to the main channel. The property sits in a no-wake zone and has a dock and a lift for personal watercraft. Steps lead down to a sandy play area at the water’s edge.
Built in 2019, the home has three bedrooms and three bathrooms in 3,328 square feet, on 0.35 acres, the smallest lot among the five. The main level is open, with nine-foot ceilings and full-view windows looking out over the water. The eat-in kitchen has granite counters, custom cabinetry and a large island, and a deck gives room for dining outdoors. The primary suite, with a walk-in closet and a tiled walk-in shower, shares the main floor with a second bedroom, a guest bath and a laundry and mudroom.
The walkout lower level also has nine-foot ceilings, along with a kitchenette, the third bedroom, a family room and a game room. Outside there is a covered outdoor kitchen with granite counters, a sink, a mini-fridge and a built-in gas grill. The three-car garage includes a workshop area with a sink and Craftsman cabinets, plus a loft for storage, and a separate concrete slab provides parking for a boat, trailer or RV.
The home sold for $949,000, which was $24,000 above its asking price of $925,000. Judy Wood of RE/MAX Oak Crest – Elkhart was the listing agent, and Amy Reed of Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 2 — $898,000 · 14212 County Road 8, Middlebury, Indiana
A creek flows through this Middlebury property, which at 4.85 acres has the largest lot in this week’s group. A stock tank pool gives the level grounds a place to cool off, and an irrigation system serves the land.
The home, built in 2018 with a stone and vinyl exterior, is a one-story design with an open floor plan and 4,283 square feet. It has five bedrooms, four of them on the main level, and three full baths and one half bath. The primary suite has a large private bath with a soaker tub, and the kitchen has quartz counters and two pantry areas. A gas fireplace warms the main living space. The finished basement adds a workout room, a bar area, daylight windows and the fifth bedroom with its own bath.
The home went under contract 29 days after it was listed and sold for $898,000. Lisa Schrock of Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Elkhart was the listing agent, and Nathan Schwartz of RE/MAX Results represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 3 — $850,000 · 30306 Copperfield Ln, Granger, Indiana
The backyard centerpiece of this Granger home is a heated saltwater pool with jetted seats, set beside a pool house that has a bathroom, an outdoor shower and storage space. The property is a 0.67-acre corner lot on a cul-de-sac in Copperfield, with a circular driveway at the front.
Troyer built the ranch in 2008, and at 4,611 square feet it has the most living area of the five. There are four bedrooms and five bathrooms, and each bedroom on the main level has its own full bathroom. Ceilings rise to 12 feet, transom windows bring in light, and a gas fireplace anchors the family room. A sound system runs both inside and outside.
The lower level is a second home base, with its own kitchen, a custom rock wall, a new picture window and a large family room. Flex rooms there now serve as a weight room, a guest bedroom and a theater, and there is a full bath along with unfinished storage. The oversized garage is heated and has a sink and a cleanup area, and the home has a whole-house generator.
The property last sold for $565,000 in 2019, and this time it sold for $850,000. Amy Reed of Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group was on both sides of the sale, as listing agent and buyer’s agent. Reed also represented the buyer of this week’s top sale.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 4 — $600,000 · 58732 River Forest Dr, Goshen, Indiana
This home in Goshen’s Fishlers River Forest neighborhood went under contract three days after it was listed and sold for $600,000. A transitional ranch built in 1997, it is the oldest of the five, and it sits on a partially wooded double lot of 1.38 acres. The property last sold for $510,000 in 2020.
Much of the appeal is outdoors. A composite deck overlooks a heated gunite pool with new tile work, and there is a basketball court on the grounds. A three-season room, set up for a future hot tub, opens to the lower patio.
Inside, the formal dining room has hardwood floors and a tray ceiling, and the family room has a gas fireplace and a wall of windows. The eat-in kitchen has a seating area by the fireplace, a breakfast nook, an induction cooktop, two built-in ovens, two pantries and an island with a second sink. The primary suite has its own gas fireplace, a tray ceiling and access to the deck, and its bath includes a jetted tub, two vanities, a large tiled shower and a walk-in closet. Elsewhere on the main level, an office and a bedroom with a loft share a Jack and Jill bath.
The walkout lower level has a third gas fireplace in a large entertainment room, a kitchenette and radiant floor heat. Two bedrooms there share a Jack and Jill bath, and a third has its own bath and a walk-in cedar closet. A second laundry room sits on that level as well. In all, the home has five bedrooms, four full baths and one half bath in 4,264 square feet.
Lori Johnston of Cressy & Everett – South Bend was the listing agent, and Chad Martin of Keller Williams Realty Group represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 5 — $505,000 · 50833 Morning Dove Ct, Elkhart, Indiana
The newest home of the five, completed in 2024, faces a pond in Hidden Lake Reserve in Elkhart. Its main living area has 20-foot ceilings with natural wood beam accents and a window seat that takes in west-facing views over the water. The pond is also in view from the eat-in kitchen, which has quartz counters and a walk-in pantry with waist-height counters for small appliances.
The main-level primary suite has tray ceilings and a circular walk-in closet that measures 10 by 11 feet, and two more bedrooms share that floor. The walkout lower level adds a large family area, two bedrooms and a full bath, along with a 20-by-20-foot garage and workshop. The upper attic could be finished for more space. The home has five bedrooms and three bathrooms in 2,870 square feet on 0.86 acres, and it sold for $505,000.
Courtney Barber of McKinnies Realty, LLC Elkhart was the listing agent, and Megan R Hunter of Brick Built Real Estate represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →