These are the five highest-priced home sales reported in the Poughkeepsie-Newburgh metro area for the week ending October 11, 2026, and together they came to $7.18 million. Three of the homes are in Dutchess County and two are in Orange County, with Beacon accounting for two of the five and Tivoli, Cornwall On Hudson and Montgomery one each.
The group spans more than two and a half centuries of building, from village homes within walking distance of Main Street in Beacon to a farm property in northern Dutchess and a new home in a Montgomery subdivision. In two of the five sales, the same agent was on both sides of the deal.
No. 1 — $2,050,000 · 33 Davis Street, Beacon, New York
Known as Rombout House, the brick Second Empire Victorian at 33 Davis Street in Beacon sold for $2,050,000, the top price of the week. Built in 1880, it stands on a corner lot a block from Main Street, under the mansard roof that defines the style. From Davis Street the home presents a measured front; around the corner on Ackerman Street, its full scale and its tower come into view.
A long restoration kept the period character and rebuilt what lies behind it. Pocket doors, the bracketed cornice and the gabled dormers survive, and ceilings rise 10 to 12 feet over new white oak floors laid in a herringbone pattern. On the main level, a gas fireplace with a cast-iron surround anchors the living space, and the kitchen pairs Calacatta marble with a large island and Fisher & Paykel appliances. The room that sets the home apart is the conservatory, which looks out toward Fishkill Creek and Mount Beacon. Elsewhere on the main level, French doors lead out to a broad deck.
The home has five bedrooms, three full baths and a half bath in 3,523 square feet. Three of the bedrooms are upstairs, among them a primary suite with mountain views and a marble bath with a clawfoot tub. The finished lower level, with polished concrete floors and a walk-out, adds the other two bedrooms along with a fitness area and a mudroom, and it opens directly into an attached two-car garage equipped with two EV chargers. The renovation also brought geothermal heating and cooling. Fishkill Creek and its trails are about five minutes away on foot, and Dia:Beacon and the Metro-North station are close by.
Jessica Brasseur and Anthony Dargenzio, both of Houlihan Lawrence, Inc., were the listing agents for the week’s highest-priced sale.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 2 — $1,760,000 · 5020 Route 9G, Tivoli, New York
The Petrus Hoffman House in Tivoli sits well back from Route 9G on a high ridge, with views across meadow and pasture to the Catskills. The stone home, built in 1750, sold for $1,760,000 with 34.84 acres, the largest parcel in this week’s group.
Inside, a center hall opens to a formal living room on one side and a formal dining room on the other, and each still has its original fireplace. The restoration preserved the beaded ceiling beams, wide-board floors, working Dutch doors and 12-over-12 windows, while bringing in central air conditioning and new wiring. The home has six bedrooms, two bathrooms and 3,687 square feet.
The land is worked farmland, and the outbuildings tell much of its story. A Victorian carriage barn topped by a cupola has four horse stalls, and there are paddocks and a run-in shed beyond it. A pond shaded by willows and a freestanding artist’s studio sit on the grounds, and a second, Cape Cod-style home built in 1900 stands on its own parcel. Tivoli’s village center, Bard College and Rhinebeck are a short drive away.
The home sold above its asking price of $1.699 million. Hayes Clement and Kathleen Manikowski, both of Compass Greater New York, LLC, were the listing agents, and Manikowski also represented the buyer, so the same agent was on both sides of the sale.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 3 — $1,200,000 · 4 Grandview Avenue, Cornwall On Hudson, New York
Few homes in the village have the outlook of 4 Grandview Avenue in Cornwall On Hudson. The contemporary, built in 1980 and set back from the street on 0.67 acres, is a riverfront property, and walls of windows across the front take in the Hudson River. It sold for $1,200,000. The property last sold for $610,000 in 2004.
With 3,762 square feet, it is the largest home of the five, and its three full baths and two half baths give it the most bathrooms in the group. The kitchen sits at the center of the plan, with granite counters, a pantry and a picture window facing the view, and it flows into the family room. A stone gas fireplace, hardwood floors and built-in bookshelves run through the main rooms. All four bedrooms share one level, and two of them, including the primary suite, have their own full baths. A finished space at the very top of the home serves as a den or library with water and mountain views.
The finished lower level has a kitchenette, a fitness room, a home office and a bath of its own. Behind the home, a fenced yard has a gunite pool with a slide and a diving board, along with a spa and a waterfall. A pergola shelters an outdoor kitchen with a wet bar, and a fire pit sits within the bluestone hardscaping. At the front are a screened porch and a detached two-car garage. Restaurants, shops and parks in the village are within walking distance.
Gzim Hakanjin of Coldwell Banker Realty was the listing agent and also represented the buyer, putting the same agent on both sides of the sale.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 4 — $1,174,706 · 65 Peale Place, Montgomery, New York
The newest home of the week is a single-story ranch built in 2026 in The Ponds at Montgomery, a community in the Town of Montgomery with quick access to Interstate 84. The home at 65 Peale Place sold for $1,174,706, above its asking price of $975,000. It sits on 2.12 acres and has four bedrooms, three full baths and a half bath in 3,224 square feet. A kitchen with a large island, a pantry and stainless steel appliances opens to a great room with a fireplace, and the primary suite lies just off the kitchen, with its own bath and a walk-in closet. Two bedrooms face the front of the home, and there is also a separate office and a laundry room. Outside, there are covered porches at the front and back, a rear deck and an attached two-car garage.
Richard Baxter of Keller Williams Realty was the listing agent, and Marianne M. Harris of Keller Williams Realty represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 5 — $999,999 · 17 Talbot Avenue, Beacon, New York
A few blocks from Main Street in Beacon, the brick ranch at 17 Talbot Avenue sold for $999,999, above its asking price of $849,900. Built in 1970, the single-level home sits on 0.26 acres, and visitors reach the front door by a stone walkway, with perennial gardens planted around the entry.
The living and dining rooms flow together over newly refinished hardwood floors, and French doors open into a den lined with windows. An oversized sunroom with custom screens leads out to a level, fenced yard with flowering trees. The kitchen has a gas range with a vent hood, quartz counters and glass-front cabinets. The home has three bedrooms, two bathrooms and 2,141 square feet. The primary bedroom is on the main floor and has a walk-in closet and a skylit bath with a tiled shower, and the second bedroom has windows on three sides. An oversized one-car garage completes the home. The property last sold for $625,721 in 2022, and the Hudson River, Dia:Beacon and the galleries and restaurants of Main Street are all within walking distance.
Rebecca Agosta of BHHS Hudson Valley Properties was the listing agent, and Ninfa Meehan of Compass Greater NY, LLC represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
RealtyWire selected these transactions from publicly reported residential sales identified for the calendar week ending Sunday, October 11, 2026. The report may exclude private, off-market, delayed or nondisclosed transactions. Prices, property details and professional representation are reported as available at publication and may be updated following confirmation from transaction participants.
Were you involved in one of these transactions? Contact RealtyWire to verify or correct your professional credit or submit information for a future edition.
See full market data on our Poughkeepsie-Newburgh Metro Area market page.
