The 1971 residence at 5587 Charleston Rd sits beyond a winding drive on more than 39 acres of mature woods, open meadows and scenic trails, with a river crossing the property and a stocked pond and dock of its own. Three bedrooms and two full baths sit under soaring wood ceilings, beside a floor-to-ceiling stone fireplace and behind expansive windows that frame the surrounding land, while seven garage bays and a large heated and insulated outbuilding stand outside.
The $746,500 closing led five reported sales in the metro area for the week, a group totaling $2.58 million. The Newton Falls, Warren and Bristolville properties each sit on open acreage, while Youngstown itself supplies two more: a house finished in 2026 and a 1974 two-story in Windel Hills.
No. 1 — $746,500 · 5587 Charleston Rd, Newton Falls, Ohio
A winding drive through mature woods and open meadows leads to the 1971 residence at 5587 Charleston Rd, which closed September 17, 2026 at $746,500. The three-bedroom, two-bath house carries a reported 2,810 square feet and sits on more than 39 private acres in Newton Falls.
The house was built to face its surroundings. Soaring wood ceilings rise over the main rooms, a floor-to-ceiling stone fireplace anchors them, and expansive windows frame views across the woods and meadows. Warm natural finishes run throughout, nearly every room opens toward the outdoors, and the kitchen has been updated for daily cooking and for entertaining.
The acreage carries mature woods, open meadows, scenic trails, a river and a stocked pond with a dock, ground used for fishing, kayaking, hiking and, in winter, skating on the pond. Seven garage bays, a large heated and insulated outbuilding and additional storage buildings stand on the land, leaving room for collectors, hobbyists, recreational vehicles, a workshop, guest accommodations or multigenerational living. High-speed internet service reaches the property despite the seclusion.
The $746,500 closing put Kelly Mahoney and Jeffrey Sampson of The Agency Cleveland Northcoast at the listing side of the highest-priced reported home sale in the Youngstown metro area for the week, No. 1 in RealtyWire’s Top 5. Brant Jessel of RE/MAX Crossroads Properties represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 2 — $675,000 · 4331 Palmyra Rd SW, Warren, Ohio
A ranch house completed in 2025 on 6.45 acres at 4331 Palmyra Rd SW sold for $675,000 on September 15, 2026, and closed $5,000 above its final asking price of $670,000. The four-bedroom, two-bath home carries a reported 2,149 square feet, all of it on one floor.
The primary suite holds a garden tub, a walk-in shower and two walk-in closets. Granite countertops run through the kitchen, both bathrooms carry quartz vanity tops, and a full basement has already been plumbed for a future full bath.
A 32-by-20-foot covered deck overlooks the acreage. The property also carries a two-car attached garage and a two-car detached garage, both insulated, a 12-by-20-foot shed and a 26-foot RV carport with a 50-amp hookup. Additional features include LG and Frigidaire appliances, whole-house gutter guards, a 10-year insured transferable structural home warranty and a 30-year transferable basement waterproofing warranty. Listing materials note that horses are permitted on the property.
The house went under contract one day after the current listing date, and Holly Ritchie of Keller Williams Chervenic Rlty was the listing agent on the No. 2 reported sale in RealtyWire’s Youngstown Metro Area Top 5 for the week. Ritchie has two earlier sales in RealtyWire’s Top 5 roundups for the metro area.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 3 — $400,000 · 2121 State Route 88, Bristolville, Ohio
A 5.1-acre parcel in the Bristol Local School District carries the 2019 split-level at 2121 State Route 88 in Bristolville, a house that closed September 15, 2026 at $400,000. It went under contract 2 days after the current listing date and carries a reported 1,816 square feet across three bedrooms and two full baths.
Vinyl plank flooring runs through an open main level where the living room, dining area and kitchen flow together. The kitchen has dark cabinetry, high-definition Formica countertops and a two-tier island with seating, and the dining area opens to the backyard patio. Upstairs, three bedrooms each hold double closets; the primary suite adds a private full bath with a tub surround, and a second full bath carries the same. A lower-level family room and laundry sit above a 12-course basement left ready to be finished or used for storage.
Vinyl siding with stone veneer accents, a concrete walkway, fresh landscaping and a covered front porch front the house, and the attached garage has an insulated overhead door. A backyard patio and fire pit sit on the five-plus acres. Mechanical systems include a high-efficiency Carrier furnace with central air, 200-amp electrical service, a power-vent hot water tank, a pressure tank and a water softener.
Danny Duvall of Brokers Realty Group represented the listing side of the No. 3 reported sale in the Youngstown metro area for the week, and has one earlier sale in RealtyWire’s Top 5 roundups for the metro area. The property previously changed hands for $301,000 in 2022 before the September closing.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 4 — $389,900 · 704 Cranberry Crk, Youngstown, Ohio
The house at 704 Cranberry Crk in Youngstown was finished in 2026 and sold for $389,900 on September 15, 2026. The three-bedroom home carries a reported 2,150 square feet.
The main floor holds an oversized living room, a first-floor office, first-floor laundry, a half bath and a kitchen with stainless steel appliances, a dinette area and a glass slider to the rear deck. Upstairs, a private owner’s retreat has a walk-in closet and a full en-suite bath, two more bedrooms carry custom closet organizers and share another full bath, and a loft rounds out the floor as flexible space.
Chad M Cromer of NextHome GO30 Realty was the listing agent. The property went under contract 3 days after the current listing date and closed at its full asking price, placing Cromer at the listing side of the No. 4 reported sale in the Youngstown metro area for the week. Levi Dixie of Century 21 Lakeside Realty represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
No. 5 — $371,000 · 5711 Sharon Dr, Youngstown, Ohio
A corner lot in Windel Hills holds the two-story house at 5711 Sharon Dr, which closed September 18, 2026 at $371,000. Built in 1974 in the Canfield Local School District, it carries three bedrooms and a reported 2,360 square feet.
An updated kitchen anchors the main level with a center island, cabinetry with crown molding, stainless steel appliances and a bay window overlooking the fenced backyard. A living room, a family room, a powder room and first-floor laundry complete that floor, and a finished recreation room downstairs serves as flexible space. All three bedrooms are upstairs, among them a primary suite with its own en-suite bath, alongside a second full bath.
Off the back of the house, a covered porch rises to a cathedral ceiling and carries a ceiling fan, with flowing outdoor curtains enclosing it. A stone patio, a storage shed and the fully fenced backyard fill out the corner lot.
Kathleen C Morell of Howard Hanna was the listing agent. The property previously changed hands for $190,900 in 2019, and the September closing placed Morell at the listing side of the No. 5 reported sale in RealtyWire’s Youngstown Metro Area Top 5 for the week. Julia C Hackett of RE/MAX Valley Real Estate represented the buyer.
See this property in Google Street View →
RealtyWire selected these transactions from publicly reported residential sales identified for the calendar week ending Sunday, September 20, 2026. The report may exclude private, off-market, delayed or nondisclosed transactions. Prices, property details and professional representation are reported as available at publication and may be updated following confirmation from transaction participants.
Were you involved in one of these transactions? Contact RealtyWire to verify or correct your professional credit or submit information for a future edition.
See full market data on our Youngstown, Ohio market page.
